Yahoo! pota group — Messages 18013–18112

Dates: 2002-06-13 through 2002-06-16

Messages in pota group. Page 181 of 764.
Index Prev  Next


Group: pota Message: 18013 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18014 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18015 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18016 From: mystic4ever Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18017 From: mystic4ever Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: New POTA toys....scan 2
Group: pota Message: 18018 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18019 From: Ken and Heather Taylor Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2
Group: pota Message: 18020 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Mexico in the TV series
Group: pota Message: 18021 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18022 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18023 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18024 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2
Group: pota Message: 18025 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18026 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18027 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18028 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [RE: So, How was "Ape Nation"?
Group: pota Message: 18029 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18030 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18031 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:
Group: pota Message: 18032 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
Group: pota Message: 18033 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
Group: pota Message: 18034 From: smugster2000 Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18035 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: [RE: So, How was "Ape Nation"?
Group: pota Message: 18036 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
Group: pota Message: 18037 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: "Bourne" Yesterday
Group: pota Message: 18038 From: Eileen Rankin Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
Group: pota Message: 18039 From: Eileen Rankin Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
Group: pota Message: 18040 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18041 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18042 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18043 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18044 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18045 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] "Bourne" Yesterday
Group: pota Message: 18046 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18047 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Story between Planet and Beneath/Beneath and Escape
Group: pota Message: 18048 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18049 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18050 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18051 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18052 From: sand_hill_school Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath/Beneath and Escape
Group: pota Message: 18053 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18054 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18055 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Correcting a typo in Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18056 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Toons Sneak Peek
Group: pota Message: 18057 From: MTotsky@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Alex is the Coolest!
Group: pota Message: 18058 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
Group: pota Message: 18059 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18060 From: CheeseGOTAS@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
Group: pota Message: 18061 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Roll'n Rock
Group: pota Message: 18062 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18063 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
Group: pota Message: 18064 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18065 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
Group: pota Message: 18066 From: smugster2000 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18067 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
Group: pota Message: 18068 From: its_a_mad_house Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18069 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18070 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18071 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18072 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18073 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18074 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: POTA Toons
Group: pota Message: 18075 From: Melkor Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Extended Battle DVD came
Group: pota Message: 18076 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] POTA Toons
Group: pota Message: 18077 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Mutant's illusions
Group: pota Message: 18078 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18079 From: Melkor Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18080 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18081 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Extended Battle DVD came
Group: pota Message: 18082 From: james611102 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18083 From: james611102 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18084 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18085 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18086 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Toons is a Bust
Group: pota Message: 18087 From: CheeseGOTAS@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
Group: pota Message: 18088 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
Group: pota Message: 18089 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18090 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18091 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
Group: pota Message: 18092 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mutant's illusions
Group: pota Message: 18093 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
Group: pota Message: 18094 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Last attempt
Group: pota Message: 18095 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: Last attempt
Group: pota Message: 18096 From: thypentacle Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
Group: pota Message: 18097 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18098 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: what came after Battle...
Group: pota Message: 18099 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
Group: pota Message: 18100 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
Group: pota Message: 18101 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18102 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
Group: pota Message: 18103 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18104 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] what came after Battle...
Group: pota Message: 18105 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: POTA, politics, propaganda, etc.
Group: pota Message: 18106 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
Group: pota Message: 18107 From: Rich Handley Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Digest Number 1102
Group: pota Message: 18108 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: BATTLE DVD
Group: pota Message: 18109 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: OT: "THE BOURNE IDENTITY" and "SCOOBY DOO"
Group: pota Message: 18110 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] BATTLE DVD
Group: pota Message: 18111 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Talking of busts...
Group: pota Message: 18112 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/16/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] POTA, politics, propaganda, etc.



Group: pota Message: 18013 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
.html
Not a bad idea, Helen, but they tend to want a human star and we follow
them around instead of an ape. A reviewer mentioned that Burton would have
probably been happiest and done the best job if he could build the movie
around Ari and Thade, that that's where his interest was. But familiarity
sells and he had to follow the human star. Etc. - - - Jeff


----- Original Message -----
From: "sand_hill_school" <sand_hill_school@...>
To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 3:29 PM
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?


>
> > ....I would suggest one more criterion: the creators are
> > familiar with the apes saga and adhere to established convention
> (as much as
> > they contradict each other anyway).
> >
>
>
> Ok Michael. For what it is worth:
>
> I agree. Someone who is familiar with the Apes saga should write
> this. Now, bearing that in mind...
>
> There are so many stories to be told. I think the TV series may have
> represented these stories somewhat, but I am not very familiar with
> the TV series. So, if we just follow the 5 movies I would suggest
> (again) taking a different point of view.
>
> The Gorillas show the most variety of charactor. Warrior, hunter,
> working class. They show amazing extremes of emotion (unlike the
> Chimps who are very even) and are not as polarized in their views as
> the orangutans.
>
> I would love to see more of the Planet and the Apes' social/political
> interactions. I'm not a writer, so I don't know what sells. But
> rather than being the outsider, I would like to be made to feel like
> one of them -- the Apes. And in my opinion, the Gorilla point of
> view allows the most possibilities for capturing a story. Not to
> contradict the 5 story saga, not to explain it, not to ignore it.
> Just to dig deeper into the Ape world -- as an Ape. Some writer
> should be able to figure this out and provide us with some good
> material.
>
>
> >
> > Someone should do some statistics one day on the value of posts in
> this
> > group. I'll take a punt: 45% insults, 35% smart a** one liners,
> 15% off
> > topic, 5% worth reading.
> >
>
>
> You're right. Guilty. Usually catch a topic near the end when there
> isn't much left to contribute.
>
> --Helen
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 18014 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
.html
I like it too.

I just sent a private to T accidentally that said:

(1) What would be an appropriate medium (eg novel, comic strip, TV
Show, Cable Show, Movie)?

(2) Would you put these all together in one film without linking them
via some commentary about what happens in the films?

My suggestion is that to make something like this work, you would
start with the idea, then get the words, then run by the group to
check for accuracy and inconsistencies, then re-draft (ad infinitum)
and maybe sell out a bit by adding a few elements that would appeal
to an audience (but not put all the emphasis on this aspect as per
POTA 2001!!) then you have a script or a novel or a comic strip.
Voila!

With T's ideas I think they would suit the TV/Cable mini-series
medium. Maybe with a voice-over commentator to explain to the
audience the events (films) they have missed.

The first episode could be Zira and Corn meeting at the Academy. A
sort of love story, but we need to add an interesting idea (eg
rivalry: a jealous rival plots to murder Cornelius - or something
that explores the whole "ape shall never kill ape" thing - are we to
believe that ape never kills ape? Or is it like a Commandment and
simply because it is stated this does not mean the rule is adhered
to?). Maybe explore some chimps stealing drugs from med. school and
selling them - that would fit nicely with the Beneath portrayal of
the protesting chimps!

There is a whole series here!

My suggestion would be to get some ggod words, make a comic strip
(rough sketches - if the publisher likes it they will get their own
artists) then look at turning it into celluloid.

Comments?

Michael

--- "sand_hill_school" <sand_hill_school@...> wrote:
> I like it, LT. (Oops. One line[r].)
>
> --Helen
>
>
>
> --- In pota@y..., LordTZer0@A... wrote:
> >
> > > I believe I have posed a fair question and a whole day later
> there is one
> > > response. I
> > > already know Patrick's response to this because his passion is
to
> create
> > > one
> > > story that makes sense of all other films and from what I can
> tell there
> > > are
> > > a few other concepts too
> >
> > Okay Mikey, allow me to try and make it into the 5%. Here's an
> idea though
> > it might be a stupid one. How about making a single film about
all
> the time
> > in-between films. You could start with Zira and Cornelius
meeting
> at the
> > Academy, graduating and Zira studying humans while Corny goes on
> his dig.
> > Then on to the trail and cover up and Milo salvaging the ship and
> them taking
> > off and the bomb going off. Then Caesar growing up in the circus
> and finish
> > with the war that lead up to battle.
>
>
> ------------------------ ---------------------
~-->
> Will You Find True Love?
> Will You Meet the One?
> Free Love Reading by phone!
> http://us.click.yahoo.com/Deo18C/zDLEAA/Ey.GAA/9_IolB/TM
> --------------------------------------------------------------------
-~->
>
>
>
>

>
>
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 18015 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
.html
Hmmm.

Escape didn't follow a human star, nor did Conquest or Battle.

I must admit I was a bit uneasy with the thought at first, but as I
thought more about it, there is not much you could not transfer/adapt
to ape society and who needs humans all the time?

It should be attempted.

Michael


--- <veetus@...> wrote:
> Not a bad idea, Helen, but they tend to want a human star and we
follow
> them around instead of an ape. A reviewer mentioned that Burton
would have
> probably been happiest and done the best job if he could build the
movie
> around Ari and Thade, that that's where his interest was. But
familiarity
> sells and he had to follow the human star. Etc. - - - Jeff
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "sand_hill_school" <sand_hill_school@...>
> To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
> Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 3:29 PM
> Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
>
>
> >
> > > ....I would suggest one more criterion: the creators are
> > > familiar with the apes saga and adhere to established convention
> > (as much as
> > > they contradict each other anyway).
> > >
> >
> >
> > Ok Michael. For what it is worth:
> >
> > I agree. Someone who is familiar with the Apes saga should write
> > this. Now, bearing that in mind...
> >
> > There are so many stories to be told. I think the TV series may
have
> > represented these stories somewhat, but I am not very familiar
with
> > the TV series. So, if we just follow the 5 movies I would suggest
> > (again) taking a different point of view.
> >
> > The Gorillas show the most variety of charactor. Warrior, hunter,
> > working class. They show amazing extremes of emotion (unlike the
> > Chimps who are very even) and are not as polarized in their views
as
> > the orangutans.
> >
> > I would love to see more of the Planet and the Apes'
social/political
> > interactions. I'm not a writer, so I don't know what sells. But
> > rather than being the outsider, I would like to be made to feel
like
> > one of them -- the Apes. And in my opinion, the Gorilla point of
> > view allows the most possibilities for capturing a story. Not to
> > contradict the 5 story saga, not to explain it, not to ignore it.
> > Just to dig deeper into the Ape world -- as an Ape. Some writer
> > should be able to figure this out and provide us with some good
> > material.
> >
> >
> > >
> > > Someone should do some statistics one day on the value of posts
in
> > this
> > > group. I'll take a punt: 45% insults, 35% smart a** one
liners,
> > 15% off
> > > topic, 5% worth reading.
> > >
> >
> >
> > You're right. Guilty. Usually catch a topic near the end when
there
> > isn't much left to contribute.
> >
> > --Helen
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >

> >
> >
>
>
>
> ------------------------ ---------------------
~-->
> Will You Find True Love?
> Will You Meet the One?
> Free Love Reading by phone!
> http://us.click.yahoo.com/Deo18C/zDLEAA/Ey.GAA/9_IolB/TM
> --------------------------------------------------------------------
-~->
>
>
>
>

>
>
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 18016 From: mystic4ever Date: 6/13/2002
Subject: New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
.html
Attachments :
    .html
    Has anyone else out there seen these?  I saw the display for the first time today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures.  Apparently they were released in May.  Kind of hokey, but if you loved the Burton movie like I did, you'll probably like them!   Odd packaging since the blister card has modified pics of the classic characters, but the actual figures are all POTA 2001 inspired.  There are six that I've seen.  I've attached scans of two of the "gorillas".  The others are a male & female human where the female resembles Daena and the male is an astronaut who doesn't look much like Wahlberg; another gorilla with gold colouring and there's a female warrior gorilla. 
     
    Dan
     
     
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 18017 From: mystic4ever Date: 6/13/2002
    Subject: New POTA toys....scan 2
    .html
    Attachments :
      .html
       
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18018 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
      .html
      That's pretty funny!

      The pics on the card are lifted straight from the Addar model kits
      with guns drawn in!

      Zira and Cornelius look very threatening!

      By the way, I always had a theory that the Addar people got Zira
      mixed up with the blind chimp from the TV Series when they did that
      kit of Zira because she looks BLIND!!!!

      Michael

      --- "mystic4ever" <mystic4ever@...> wrote:
      > Has anyone else out there seen these? I saw the display for the
      first time
      > today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures. Apparently they were
      released
      > in May. Kind of hokey, but if you loved the Burton movie like I
      did, you'l
      > l probably like them! Odd packaging since the blister card has
      modified p
      > ics of the classic characters, but the actual figures are all POTA
      2001 ins
      > pired. There are six that I've seen. I've attached scans of two
      of the "g
      > orillas". The others are a male & female human where the female
      resembles
      > Daena and the male is an astronaut who doesn't look much like
      Wahlberg; ano
      > ther gorilla with gold colouring and there's a female warrior
      gorilla.
      >
      > Dan
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18019 From: Ken and Heather Taylor Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2
      .html
      .html
      Gotta love that Zira, toating a machine gun! If only she was wearing a bikini.
      ----- Original Message -----
      Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 11:20 AM
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2

       

      Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18020 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Mexico in the TV series
      .html
      Urko's wall map shows part of Baja California so the apes must have explored at
      least part of northern Mexico. Central City looks roughly between Phoenix and
      San Diego so they are already close. It actually looks like Urko's map has
      scarecrows in the south -- apparently all of Mexico is the Forbidden Zone of
      the TV series. So maybe there are only humans in Mexico but the apes don't
      want anyone to know.

      Melkor (Morgoth)


      > >"Melkor" <melkor@...> wrote:
      >> I always wandered if Virden and Burke and gone far enough south,
      >would
      >> they have found Spanish speaking apes? Or if humans had still ruled
      >Mexico
      >> wouldn't the apes be aware of it? There could have been an
      >interesting
      >> episode.
      >
      >Suddenly I can't help picturing an all-musical episode with the
      >fugitives and Urko all dancing about to the sounds of tijuana brass.
      >
      >I think I need help.
      >
      >Alan


      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18021 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      .html
      >
      >Rather than tie in directly with the movies or anything like that I
      >would like to see lots of different creative teams tackle different
      >aspects of the Planet of the Apes outside the area we are familiar
      >with. Like "Ape City" did with Europe, why not let us see what
      >happened in Africa, in Japan, in Australia, etc. Funny or serious, it
      >doesn't matter as long as they're creative, and above all else
      >enjoyable.
      >

      Yes there is plenty of room for POTA stories in other countries. On the
      other hand Borneo doesn't have enough orangutans to export them everywhere
      in the world so there would have to be a lot of places without apes.



      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18022 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      .html
      I guess that depends how the story is developed.

      I would not be at all surprised to see science breeding endangered
      species in laboratories and returning them to higher numbers in the
      near future ("as dead as a dodo" may soon mean something is
      resurrected, not extinct!).

      Michael

      --- "Melkor" <melkor@...> wrote:
      > >
      > >Rather than tie in directly with the movies or anything like that I
      > >would like to see lots of different creative teams tackle different
      > >aspects of the Planet of the Apes outside the area we are familiar
      > >with. Like "Ape City" did with Europe, why not let us see what
      > >happened in Africa, in Japan, in Australia, etc. Funny or serious,
      it
      > >doesn't matter as long as they're creative, and above all else
      > >enjoyable.
      > >
      >
      > Yes there is plenty of room for POTA stories in other countries.
      On the
      > other hand Borneo doesn't have enough orangutans to export them
      everywhere
      > in the world so there would have to be a lot of places without apes.
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18023 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      .html
      There are stories begging to be told to fill in the gaps between the
      five original movies. But I wouldn't try to put them together into a movie.
      There would be a possible four separate stories.

      As for your original question the story I would most like to see is the story
      in between BENEATH and ESCAPE and the whole story of Dr. Milo. How does Milo
      get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone? When and why
      does Milo tell Cornelius and Zira about the Icarus? Does Lucius or anyone
      else know?


      >
      >(1) What would be an appropriate medium (eg novel, comic strip, TV
      >Show, Cable Show, Movie)?
      >
      >(2) Would you put these all together in one film without linking them
      >via some commentary about what happens in the films?


      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18024 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2
      .html
      That is wicked!
      Even Burton's Apes have machine guns.

      Thank God for Medicoms.

      Best.
      Al



      >From: "mystic4ever" <mystic4ever@...>
      >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      >To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      >Subject: [Planet of the Apes] New POTA toys....scan 2
      >Date: Thu, 13 Jun 2002 21:20:21 -0400
      >
      >
      ><< spaceapes1.JPG >>




      _____
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18025 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      .html
      The later sequels were unique and by then Roddy was the star. But that was
      a lower budget range. For a big $100 million movie they'd do now, they want
      a bankable HUMAN star. Oliver Stone told "Cinefantastique" he toyed with the
      idea of Schwartzenegger as the human and Stallone as the ape villain, and
      said Stallone was hurt by that. Etc. - - - Jeff


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: <whitty@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 5:48 PM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?


      > Hmmm.
      >
      > Escape didn't follow a human star, nor did Conquest or Battle.
      >
      > I must admit I was a bit uneasy with the thought at first, but as I
      > thought more about it, there is not much you could not transfer/adapt
      > to ape society and who needs humans all the time?
      >
      > It should be attempted.
      >
      > Michael
      >
      >
      > --- <veetus@...> wrote:
      > > Not a bad idea, Helen, but they tend to want a human star and we
      > follow
      > > them around instead of an ape. A reviewer mentioned that Burton
      > would have
      > > probably been happiest and done the best job if he could build the
      > movie
      > > around Ari and Thade, that that's where his interest was. But
      > familiarity
      > > sells and he had to follow the human star. Etc. - - - Jeff
      > >
      > >
      > > ----- Original Message -----
      > > From: "sand_hill_school" <sand_hill_school@...>
      > > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 3:29 PM
      > > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      > >
      > >
      > > >
      > > > > ....I would suggest one more criterion: the creators are
      > > > > familiar with the apes saga and adhere to established convention
      > > > (as much as
      > > > > they contradict each other anyway).
      > > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > > Ok Michael. For what it is worth:
      > > >
      > > > I agree. Someone who is familiar with the Apes saga should write
      > > > this. Now, bearing that in mind...
      > > >
      > > > There are so many stories to be told. I think the TV series may
      > have
      > > > represented these stories somewhat, but I am not very familiar
      > with
      > > > the TV series. So, if we just follow the 5 movies I would suggest
      > > > (again) taking a different point of view.
      > > >
      > > > The Gorillas show the most variety of charactor. Warrior, hunter,
      > > > working class. They show amazing extremes of emotion (unlike the
      > > > Chimps who are very even) and are not as polarized in their views
      > as
      > > > the orangutans.
      > > >
      > > > I would love to see more of the Planet and the Apes'
      > social/political
      > > > interactions. I'm not a writer, so I don't know what sells. But
      > > > rather than being the outsider, I would like to be made to feel
      > like
      > > > one of them -- the Apes. And in my opinion, the Gorilla point of
      > > > view allows the most possibilities for capturing a story. Not to
      > > > contradict the 5 story saga, not to explain it, not to ignore it.
      > > > Just to dig deeper into the Ape world -- as an Ape. Some writer
      > > > should be able to figure this out and provide us with some good
      > > > material.
      > > >
      > > >
      > > > >
      > > > > Someone should do some statistics one day on the value of posts
      > in
      > > > this
      > > > > group. I'll take a punt: 45% insults, 35% smart a** one
      > liners,
      > > > 15% off
      > > > > topic, 5% worth reading.
      > > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > > You're right. Guilty. Usually catch a topic near the end when
      > there
      > > > isn't much left to contribute.
      > > >
      > > > --Helen
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      >
      > > >
      > > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > > ------------------------ ---------------------
      > ~-->
      > > Will You Find True Love?
      > > Will You Meet the One?
      > > Free Love Reading by phone!
      > > http://us.click.yahoo.com/Deo18C/zDLEAA/Ey.GAA/9_IolB/TM
      > > --------------------------------------------------------------------
      > -~->
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18026 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
      .html
      .html
        Interesting, but Fox would have a thing or two to say if they found out! Etc.                               - - - Jeff
       
       
      ----- Original Message -----
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 6:19 PM
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!

      Has anyone else out there seen these?  I saw the display for the first time today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures.  Apparently they were released in May.  Kind of hokey, but if you loved the Burton movie like I did, you'll probably like them!   Odd packaging since the blister card has modified pics of the classic characters, but the actual figures are all POTA 2001 inspired.  There are six that I've seen.  I've attached scans of two of the "gorillas".  The others are a male & female human where the female resembles Daena and the male is an astronaut who doesn't look much like Wahlberg; another gorilla with gold colouring and there's a female warrior gorilla. 
       
      Dan
       
       


      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18027 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      .html
      That's my vote, too. A story to fill in the gaps of "Beneath". Or one
      between "Conquest" and "Battle" showing the apes taking over. But only if
      it's done well. Etc. - - - Jeff


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "Melkor" <melkor@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 7:04 PM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do


      > There are stories begging to be told to fill in the gaps between the
      > five original movies. But I wouldn't try to put them together into a
      movie.
      > There would be a possible four separate stories.
      >
      > As for your original question the story I would most like to see is the
      story
      > in between BENEATH and ESCAPE and the whole story of Dr. Milo. How does
      Milo
      > get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone? When and why
      > does Milo tell Cornelius and Zira about the Icarus? Does Lucius or anyone
      > else know?
      >
      >
      > >
      > >(1) What would be an appropriate medium (eg novel, comic strip, TV
      > >Show, Cable Show, Movie)?
      > >
      > >(2) Would you put these all together in one film without linking them
      > >via some commentary about what happens in the films?
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18028 From: Melkor Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [RE: So, How was "Ape Nation"?
      .html
      > Well, "Apes" is now at Dark Horse, the home of the crossover. They're the
      >folks that brought you "Alien vs. Predator" (which is Fox's next big sci-fi

      The "Alien vs. Predator" idea comes from one of the Predator
      movies where the Predator spaceship contains an "Alien" trophy head.


      >epic. Don't know if their license includes the original "Apes" but I
      >wouldn't be surprised if they do "Zauis vs. Predator vs. Superman" and
      >dedicate it to Cougar. Etc. - - -

      There is a Superman graphic novel that has a bunch of intelligent apes
      but I haven't read it.



      > > > I never got around to getting these. Are they worth a look? For the
      > > > unintiated, it's an APES/Alien Nation crossover tale.
      > > > Gristle P.

      I have the first issue of Ape Nation but I never found the rest.


      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18029 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
      .html
      These are unlicensed figures. Probably from Mexico. You should see their
      STAR WARS knockoffs. Scary.
      Gristle P.


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "mystic4ever" <mystic4ever@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 9:19 PM
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!


      Has anyone else out there seen these? I saw the display for the first time
      today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures. Apparently they were released in
      May. Kind of hokey, but if you loved the Burton movie like I did, you'll
      probably like them! Odd packaging since the blister card has modified pics
      of the classic characters, but the actual figures are all POTA 2001
      inspired. There are six that I've seen. I've attached scans of two of the
      "gorillas". The others are a male & female human where the female resembles
      Daena and the male is an astronaut who doesn't look much like Wahlberg;
      another gorilla with gold colouring and there's a female warrior gorilla.

      Dan
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18030 From: whitty@cyberone.com.au Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      OK Mr Krueger, give us a brief outline of a plot here.

      Michael

      --- <veetus@...> wrote:
      > That's my vote, too. A story to fill in the gaps of "Beneath".
      Or one
      > between "Conquest" and "Battle" showing the apes taking over. But
      only if
      > it's done well. Etc. - - -
      Jeff
      >
      >
      > ----- Original Message -----
      > From: "Melkor" <melkor@...>
      > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 7:04 PM
      > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      >
      >
      > > There are stories begging to be told to fill in the gaps between
      the
      > > five original movies. But I wouldn't try to put them together
      into a
      > movie.
      > > There would be a possible four separate stories.
      > >
      > > As for your original question the story I would most like to see
      is the
      > story
      > > in between BENEATH and ESCAPE and the whole story of Dr. Milo.
      How does
      > Milo
      > > get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone? When
      and why
      > > does Milo tell Cornelius and Zira about the Icarus? Does Lucius
      or anyone
      > > else know?
      > >
      > >
      > > >
      > > >(1) What would be an appropriate medium (eg novel, comic strip,
      TV
      > > >Show, Cable Show, Movie)?
      > > >
      > > >(2) Would you put these all together in one film without linking
      them
      > > >via some commentary about what happens in the films?
      > >
      > >
      > >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18031 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:
      .html
      Here's their site, but no pics of the actual kit. Just the photo on the
      box, which is a still from the beach scene. There is however, a photo of the
      Caesar. Or I could send you photos of mine.
      www.modelprisoners.com
      Gristle P.


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: <LordTZer0@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 7:20 PM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:


      > They also do a three-figure kit of Zira, Cornelius and Dr. Milo in their
      > space suits.
      >
      > Any pics of those? Anywho...I had the mask, and a costume made for a
      > Halloween party that's now well over 25 years old. Luckily my Mom's
      pretty
      > handy with a sewing machine. It still looks pretty good, but I had the
      > physic of a concentration camp prisoner back then so its not going to fit
      > now. And all sorts of posters and lobby cards etc... As well as some
      > appliances. I did have one I did when I was a kid, but foam rubber
      doesn't
      > keep forever. I have a couple of models and Medicoms. The usual. But a
      lot
      > was lost to garage sales in my late teens. The trash can, the game . . .
      In
      > fact I'm not absolutely sure I didn't buy back my own model from a toy
      > collectors store a quater century later at five times the price!
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18032 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
      .html
      .htmlIn a message dated 6/13/2002 3:29:53 PM Central Standard Time, alan@... writes:



      But you only just admitted you never actually read it! Let's not start
      this again.

      Alan


      Yes, I know I admitted I actually never actually read the thing. BUT, I can say it makes the two franchises look stupid because just the idea of it alone is bad. I mean an APE and a NEWCOMER in the same story?!?.... Not gonna make a good story, so that's why I said it, say it now, and will continue to say it.
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18033 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/13/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
      .html
      I know a lot of people who automatically dismiss the idea of "talking
      apes" the same way.

      ABMAC

      On Thursday, June 13, 2002, at 11:34 PM, mlccougar@... wrote:

      > Yes, I know I admitted I actually never actually read the thing. BUT, I
      > can say it makes the two franchises look stupid because just the idea
      > of it alone is bad. I mean an APE and a NEWCOMER in the same
      > story?!?.... Not gonna make a good story, so that's why I said it, say
      > it now, and will continue to say it.
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18034 From: smugster2000 Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and write a
      stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath - this was
      before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.

      I did the first chapter of what I called 'Milo's Tale' (which was
      published in a fanzine) and then abandoned it. Anyway, just for a
      giggle here my un-revised outline that's been sitting on my hard drive
      for at least 9 years.

      CHAPTER 1

      Milo discovers Taylor's ship... his studies soon teach him about the
      possibility of flight. At this stage Milo would love to get the ship
      back into the air - not realising it is actually intended for
      interstellar space travel.

      CHAPTER 2 - 3
      He soon realises the spacecraft represents many sciences that the High
      council have repressed or banned outright. He also knows he would not
      be allowed to study the ship openly and fearing it's destruction
      before he has the chance to learn all it has to offer, he decides to
      keep it a secret.

      CHAPTER 4
      Milo reluctantly returns to Ape city knowing that his continued
      absence would only raise unwelcome questions. - Suspicion rules - his
      motives are questioned and his "souvenirs" confiscated. He appears
      before the High Council and is severely reprimanded for exceeding his
      travel permit. After careful questioning he denies finding anything of
      great interest but Zaius suspects he is lying. Especially when he
      shows Milo a US flag found among his belongings. Milo is rescued by
      Ursus who wrongfully concludes that the flag must belong to some other
      Simian population who are beginning to invade and claim the Zone as
      their own. He begins his argument over the need to expand and invade
      before this Ape City finds itself painted into a corner. We suspect
      Zaius knows Ursus is wrong but cannot confront him without raising
      more questions.

      CHAPTER 5
      Frustrated by the councils obvious aversion to the truth Milo hatches
      a fantasy whereby he will fly the spacecraft over the skies of Ape
      city - a demonstration he feels sure will force the council to admit
      to the possibilities of science and allow previously banned fields of
      research to once again flourish.

      While mulling over the pleasant daydream Milo is roughly pushed aside
      by a runaway human (Taylor) and nearly run down by the pursuing
      mounted police. He witnesses Taylor's cry of "get your stinking paws
      off me" and although shocked, his findings in the ship have at least
      prepared him for the possibility of intelligent humans. (Although up
      until now he didn't quite believe it) He puts two and two together and
      makes a note to introduce himself to Dr. Zira at the earliest
      possibility. He hopes that the talking human may be of enormous help
      to him.

      CHAPTER 6
      Milo asks Darwin, an important, high ranking Chimpanzee for an
      introduction to Zira. After a little Cat and Mouse by the suspicious
      Darwin he is told Zira is currently unavailable due to her part in the
      talking human controvosy. Darwin invites him to a meeting of a "local
      debating society". where he assures Milo he will get the opportunity
      to meet Cornelius, Zira's husband.

      Milo attends the meeting and is surprised to discover a great many
      other chimps, like himself who are frustrated by the Orangutans
      refusal to allow science to advance. They call themselves "The sons of
      Galen" in honour of a legendary Chimpanzee who, the stories say,
      defied the powers that be and dedicated himself to the search for the
      truth. (Fox Mulder of the Ape world) He meets fellow scientist
      Cornelius (who has secrets of his own) The topic for the evening is
      "Did man once ruled the earth" A notion that the Chimps are at least
      happy to discuss. Some ancient artifacts are revealed (mostly by
      Cornelius) supporting his theory that the Ape evolved from men. One
      such artifact is an ancient crumbling book from the 20th century about
      Science Fiction movies. One fading photograph from the movie "When
      worlds collide" show a space ark upon the trestle type launch platform
      that arcs up the side of a mountain. Milo is inspired by this picture
      and thinks he has solved a small part of the problem of how to get the
      spacecraft back into the air.

      CHAPTER 7
      Milo confides his secret to Darwin and Cornelius who agree that the
      ship of which he speaks must be Taylor's. Cornelius is unable to
      accompany Milo on another expedition due to Taylors imminent trial.
      Darwin has too high a profile to be seen leaving the city

      CHAPTER 8
      Milo returns alone (without permission) to the site of the ship. He
      spends many weeks/months in the Forbidden Zone studying the craft
      (with the aid of an oracle like computer program.) The programmes and
      electric's are mostly undamaged but most importantly, fully automated.
      Much superficial water damage is cleaned up and the integrity of the
      craft is returned to almost 100% However some vital components need
      replacing... Components that have no counterparts in the 40th
      century... Without them, the ship is useless.

      CHAPTER 9
      He returns again to Ape city to find that Ursus has now gained
      popularity and is successfully pushing for an invasion of the
      Forbidden Zone. Because of the volatile political climate Zaius
      resources are stretched rather thinly and Milo is allowed to come and
      go almost unnoticed. He calls another meeting of the "Sons of Galen"
      and this time tells them everything. The chimps agree that Milo's plan
      of a fly-over would certainly shake up and perhaps oust the Orangutans
      from power and maybe enable the Chimps to take over and rule more
      sensibly. Milo is confident that the craft would have flown again if
      only it were not lacking the vital missing pieces. Cornelius
      introduces Milo to Zira and they stun him by revealing another ship,
      similar to Taylor's has recently crashed (Brents)

      The "Sons of Galen" begin to organise a huge and risky undertaking.
      Under the cover of the approaching war and while the Gorillas and
      Orangutans are seemingly otherwise occupied a large workforce
      comprised entirely of Chimps head out into the Zone to begin work on
      the huge take off ramp that will be required. Meanwhile Milo,
      Cornelius and Zira set out to locate Brents Ship and hopefully the
      required spare parts.

      The suspicious Zaius has the Chimps followed by Gorilla scouts/spies.
      The spies witness the discovery of the second ship then follow the
      three apes back to the location of the first. They are stunned at the
      scale of the construction work taking place and gallop back to Ape
      city to make their report.

      CHAPTER 10 - 11
      Zaius is not surprised to learn of Zira and Cornelius's part in the
      heresy about to take place. Unable to attend to the matter himself due
      to Ursus's imminent invasion of the Forbidden Zone, Zaius sends a
      batallion of police to arrest the leaders of the heretical rebellion
      and gives them orders to destroy the project.

      A battalion of more than one hundred Policemen gallop into the
      forbidden zone to obey the orders of zaius. Milo meanwhile has managed
      to replace most of the damaged parts. Pack horses, levers and elbow
      grease have lifted the spacecraft into position upon the ramp. In two
      days Milo and a volunteer will attempt to fly the craft in a circuit
      that will take them over the skies of Ape city and over the heads of
      the advancing Gorrilla Army, led by Ursus... The Chimpanzees hope the
      sight of a flying machine will not only halt the senseless war but be
      the catalyst for bringing about a new era of peace.

      Milo is confident the ship will fly but has little idea how to pilot
      or land it safely. He is prepared for what he believes will be a
      one-way trip and is resigned to becoming a martyr to the cause of
      peace and free science. The most he can hope for is to crash once more
      into the water.

      CHAPTER 12
      Dawn breaks on the final day on the Planet of the Apes. Elsewhere the
      gorrila army have begaun to engage the mutants in the underground
      remains of New York City.

      By Lake Powell a huge cloud of dust announces the approach of the
      battalion of Police sent by Zaius. The "Sons of Galen" caught unawares
      scatter and the gorillas approach unopposed. Milo terrified that all
      his dreams are about to be obliterated climbs into the spacecraft.
      Cornelius and Zira try to stop him but the sound of bullets bouncing
      off the hull causes them all to seek refuge inside the ship. The hatch
      is closed, the apes buckle up.

      The automated launch program is initiated. Gorillas arrive at the ship
      and begin to pound upon the hull with rifle butts. The leader gives
      the order to lay dynamite around the huge wooden platform that serves
      as the runway.

      The engines of the ship and the fuse of the dynamite ignite at about
      the same time, as the ship successfully achieves take-off the roar of
      the exploding launch pad is lost in the sound of a much larger
      explosion from New York City.

      The space craft breaks Earths orbit just as the planet explodes
      sending a huge shockwave after it.

      Epilogue:

      Re-us
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18035 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: [RE: So, How was "Ape Nation"?
      .html
      Back in (I think) Summer '99 there was an 8 part "Justice League of
      America" storyline where everybody was turned into apes (Superman, Batman,
      Aquaman, Wonder Woman, etc.) and each character's issue focused on that
      superhero as an ape.It also had an ape city obviously inspired by POTA .
      Etc. - - Jeff


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "Melkor" <melkor@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 8:07 PM
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: [RE: So, How was "Ape Nation"?


      > > Well, "Apes" is now at Dark Horse, the home of the crossover. They're
      the
      > >folks that brought you "Alien vs. Predator" (which is Fox's next big
      sci-fi
      >
      > The "Alien vs. Predator" idea comes from one of the Predator
      > movies where the Predator spaceship contains an "Alien" trophy head.
      >
      >
      > >epic. Don't know if their license includes the original "Apes" but I
      > >wouldn't be surprised if they do "Zauis vs. Predator vs. Superman" and
      > >dedicate it to Cougar. Etc. - - -
      >
      > There is a Superman graphic novel that has a bunch of intelligent apes
      > but I haven't read it.
      >
      >
      >
      > > > > I never got around to getting these. Are they worth a look? For the
      > > > > unintiated, it's an APES/Alien Nation crossover tale.
      > > > > Gristle P.
      >
      > I have the first issue of Ape Nation but I never found the rest.
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18036 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?
      .html
      .html
        It doesn't make the franchises look stupid, it makes the people who did it look stupid, or smart, considering it was supposedly a hit. But John Q. Citizen doesn't know "Ape Nation" exists. Etc.                      - - - Jeff
       
       
      ----- Original Message -----
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 9:34 PM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] So, How was "Ape Nation"?

      In a message dated 6/13/2002 3:29:53 PM Central Standard Time, alan@... writes:



      But you only just admitted you never actually read it! Let's not start
      this again.

      Alan


      Yes, I know I admitted I actually never actually read the thing. BUT, I can say it makes the two franchises look stupid because just the idea of it alone is bad. I mean an APE and a NEWCOMER in the same story?!?.... Not gonna make a good story, so that's why I said it, say it now, and will continue to say it.


      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18037 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: "Bourne" Yesterday
      .html
      Today the flick "The Bourne Identity" opens, the movie Matt Damon passed
      on POTA for. Would POTA have been a better movie if Damon starred? Well, the
      man IS an Oscar-winning screenwriter so maybe he could have given Burton
      some tips (such as, "What is this sh*t? My grandma can write better 'n
      this!").
      And give me a break! Now it's said there's going to be a sequel to "Coyote
      Ugly". And they can't get an "Apes" sequel going?
      - - - Jeff


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "Jeff & Susan Stringer" <stringe@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 9:22 PM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:


      > Here's their site, but no pics of the actual kit. Just the photo on the
      > box, which is a still from the beach scene. There is however, a photo of
      the
      > Caesar. Or I could send you photos of mine.
      > www.modelprisoners.com
      > Gristle P.
      >
      >
      > ----- Original Message -----
      > From: <LordTZer0@...>
      > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 7:20 PM
      > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:
      >
      >
      > > They also do a three-figure kit of Zira, Cornelius and Dr. Milo in their
      > > space suits.
      > >
      > > Any pics of those? Anywho...I had the mask, and a costume made for a
      > > Halloween party that's now well over 25 years old. Luckily my Mom's
      > pretty
      > > handy with a sewing machine. It still looks pretty good, but I had the
      > > physic of a concentration camp prisoner back then so its not going to
      fit
      > > now. And all sorts of posters and lobby cards etc... As well as some
      > > appliances. I did have one I did when I was a kid, but foam rubber
      > doesn't
      > > keep forever. I have a couple of models and Medicoms. The usual. But
      a
      > lot
      > > was lost to garage sales in my late teens. The trash can, the game . .
      .
      > In
      > > fact I'm not absolutely sure I didn't buy back my own model from a toy
      > > collectors store a quater century later at five times the price!
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >

      > >
      > >
      > >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18038 From: Eileen Rankin Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
      .html
      .html
       Did the humans and apes exist elsewhere outside of the US?  When this topic was brought up, my immediate thought was what if the story took place in, say, Hong Kong?  Would we get something like those old martial arts movies with the bad voice overs?  Now that would be cool!!!  LOL
      ---eileen
       
      ----- Original Message -----
      From: Melkor
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 6:44 PM
      To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
       
      Urko's wall map shows part of Baja California so the apes must have explored at
      least part of northern Mexico.   Central City looks roughly between Phoenix and
      San Diego so they are already close.  It actually looks like Urko's map has
      scarecrows in the south -- apparently all of Mexico is the Forbidden Zone of
      the TV series.   So maybe there are only humans in Mexico but the apes don't
      want anyone to know.

      Melkor (Morgoth)


      > >"Melkor" <melkor@...> wrote:
      >> I always wandered if Virden and Burke and gone far enough south,
      >would
      >> they have found Spanish speaking apes?  Or if humans had still ruled
      >Mexico
      >> wouldn't the apes be aware of it?  There could have been an
      >interesting
      >> episode.
      >
      >Suddenly I can't help picturing an all-musical episode with the
      >fugitives and Urko all dancing about to the sounds of tijuana brass.
      >
      >I think I need help.
      >
      >Alan






      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18039 From: Eileen Rankin Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
      .html
      .html
       Did the humans and apes exist elsewhere outside of the US?  When this topic was brought up, my immediate thought was what if the story took place in, say, Hong Kong?  Would we get something like those old martial arts movies with the bad voice overs?  Now that would be cool!!!  LOL
      ---eileen
       
      ----- Original Message -----
      From: Melkor
      Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 6:44 PM
      To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
       
      Urko's wall map shows part of Baja California so the apes must have explored at
      least part of northern Mexico.   Central City looks roughly between Phoenix and
      San Diego so they are already close.  It actually looks like Urko's map has
      scarecrows in the south -- apparently all of Mexico is the Forbidden Zone of
      the TV series.   So maybe there are only humans in Mexico but the apes don't
      want anyone to know.

      Melkor (Morgoth)


      > >"Melkor" <melkor@...> wrote:
      >> I always wandered if Virden and Burke and gone far enough south,
      >would
      >> they have found Spanish speaking apes?  Or if humans had still ruled
      >Mexico
      >> wouldn't the apes be aware of it?  There could have been an
      >interesting
      >> episode.
      >
      >Suddenly I can't help picturing an all-musical episode with the
      >fugitives and Urko all dancing about to the sounds of tijuana brass.
      >
      >I think I need help.
      >
      >Alan






      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18040 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      sounds very good. i have always wondered how they "found" the rocket
      considering it sunk in the middle of the lake and how they got it
      out. i always assumed brents ship's undamaged parts were used to
      repair taylor's ship. why is taylor chased by the apes mounted police
      (which i assume is what you implied). i got the feeling from beneath
      and the end of planet that zaius wanted taylor left alone (more of a
      good riddance) and taylor and nova wondered until the mirage fire and
      mountain took him. speaking of which, what was the mirage mountain in
      beneath. i understand it wasn't really there, but when it disappears
      there is nothing there but flat land. how did taylor disappear in an
      open space? but overall a good outline. i too started a apes story
      before (though much different from this) and would be fun to get
      together with someone and bang out a story. eddie


      --- In pota@y..., "smugster2000" <4print@a...> wrote:
      > A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and write a
      > stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath - this
      was
      > before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.
      >
      > I did the first chapter of what I called 'Milo's Tale' (which was
      > published in a fanzine) and then abandoned it. Anyway, just for a
      > giggle here my un-revised outline that's been sitting on my hard
      drive
      > for at least 9 years.
      >
      > CHAPTER 1
      >
      > Milo discovers Taylor's ship... his studies soon teach him about
      the
      > possibility of flight. At this stage Milo would love to get the
      ship
      > back into the air - not realising it is actually intended for
      > interstellar space travel.
      >
      > CHAPTER 2 - 3
      > He soon realises the spacecraft represents many sciences that the
      High
      > council have repressed or banned outright. He also knows he would
      not
      > be allowed to study the ship openly and fearing it's destruction
      > before he has the chance to learn all it has to offer, he decides
      to
      > keep it a secret.
      >
      > CHAPTER 4
      > Milo reluctantly returns to Ape city knowing that his continued
      > absence would only raise unwelcome questions. - Suspicion rules -
      his
      > motives are questioned and his "souvenirs" confiscated. He appears
      > before the High Council and is severely reprimanded for exceeding
      his
      > travel permit. After careful questioning he denies finding anything
      of
      > great interest but Zaius suspects he is lying. Especially when he
      > shows Milo a US flag found among his belongings. Milo is rescued by
      > Ursus who wrongfully concludes that the flag must belong to some
      other
      > Simian population who are beginning to invade and claim the Zone as
      > their own. He begins his argument over the need to expand and
      invade
      > before this Ape City finds itself painted into a corner. We suspect
      > Zaius knows Ursus is wrong but cannot confront him without raising
      > more questions.
      >
      > CHAPTER 5
      > Frustrated by the councils obvious aversion to the truth Milo
      hatches
      > a fantasy whereby he will fly the spacecraft over the skies of Ape
      > city - a demonstration he feels sure will force the council to
      admit
      > to the possibilities of science and allow previously banned fields
      of
      > research to once again flourish.
      >
      > While mulling over the pleasant daydream Milo is roughly pushed
      aside
      > by a runaway human (Taylor) and nearly run down by the pursuing
      > mounted police. He witnesses Taylor's cry of "get your stinking
      paws
      > off me" and although shocked, his findings in the ship have at
      least
      > prepared him for the possibility of intelligent humans. (Although
      up
      > until now he didn't quite believe it) He puts two and two together
      and
      > makes a note to introduce himself to Dr. Zira at the earliest
      > possibility. He hopes that the talking human may be of enormous
      help
      > to him.
      >
      > CHAPTER 6
      > Milo asks Darwin, an important, high ranking Chimpanzee for an
      > introduction to Zira. After a little Cat and Mouse by the
      suspicious
      > Darwin he is told Zira is currently unavailable due to her part in
      the
      > talking human controvosy. Darwin invites him to a meeting of
      a "local
      > debating society". where he assures Milo he will get the
      opportunity
      > to meet Cornelius, Zira's husband.
      >
      > Milo attends the meeting and is surprised to discover a great many
      > other chimps, like himself who are frustrated by the Orangutans
      > refusal to allow science to advance. They call themselves "The sons
      of
      > Galen" in honour of a legendary Chimpanzee who, the stories say,
      > defied the powers that be and dedicated himself to the search for
      the
      > truth. (Fox Mulder of the Ape world) He meets fellow scientist
      > Cornelius (who has secrets of his own) The topic for the evening is
      > "Did man once ruled the earth" A notion that the Chimps are at
      least
      > happy to discuss. Some ancient artifacts are revealed (mostly by
      > Cornelius) supporting his theory that the Ape evolved from men. One
      > such artifact is an ancient crumbling book from the 20th century
      about
      > Science Fiction movies. One fading photograph from the movie "When
      > worlds collide" show a space ark upon the trestle type launch
      platform
      > that arcs up the side of a mountain. Milo is inspired by this
      picture
      > and thinks he has solved a small part of the problem of how to get
      the
      > spacecraft back into the air.
      >
      > CHAPTER 7
      > Milo confides his secret to Darwin and Cornelius who agree that the
      > ship of which he speaks must be Taylor's. Cornelius is unable to
      > accompany Milo on another expedition due to Taylors imminent trial.
      > Darwin has too high a profile to be seen leaving the city
      >
      > CHAPTER 8
      > Milo returns alone (without permission) to the site of the ship. He
      > spends many weeks/months in the Forbidden Zone studying the craft
      > (with the aid of an oracle like computer program.) The programmes
      and
      > electric's are mostly undamaged but most importantly, fully
      automated.
      > Much superficial water damage is cleaned up and the integrity of
      the
      > craft is returned to almost 100% However some vital components
      need
      > replacing... Components that have no counterparts in the 40th
      > century... Without them, the ship is useless.
      >
      > CHAPTER 9
      > He returns again to Ape city to find that Ursus has now gained
      > popularity and is successfully pushing for an invasion of the
      > Forbidden Zone. Because of the volatile political climate Zaius
      > resources are stretched rather thinly and Milo is allowed to come
      and
      > go almost unnoticed. He calls another meeting of the "Sons of
      Galen"
      > and this time tells them everything. The chimps agree that Milo's
      plan
      > of a fly-over would certainly shake up and perhaps oust the
      Orangutans
      > from power and maybe enable the Chimps to take over and rule more
      > sensibly. Milo is confident that the craft would have flown again
      if
      > only it were not lacking the vital missing pieces. Cornelius
      > introduces Milo to Zira and they stun him by revealing another
      ship,
      > similar to Taylor's has recently crashed (Brents)
      >
      > The "Sons of Galen" begin to organise a huge and risky undertaking.
      > Under the cover of the approaching war and while the Gorillas and
      > Orangutans are seemingly otherwise occupied a large workforce
      > comprised entirely of Chimps head out into the Zone to begin work
      on
      > the huge take off ramp that will be required. Meanwhile Milo,
      > Cornelius and Zira set out to locate Brents Ship and hopefully the
      > required spare parts.
      >
      > The suspicious Zaius has the Chimps followed by Gorilla
      scouts/spies.
      > The spies witness the discovery of the second ship then follow the
      > three apes back to the location of the first. They are stunned at
      the
      > scale of the construction work taking place and gallop back to Ape
      > city to make their report.
      >
      > CHAPTER 10 - 11
      > Zaius is not surprised to learn of Zira and Cornelius's part in the
      > heresy about to take place. Unable to attend to the matter himself
      due
      > to Ursus's imminent invasion of the Forbidden Zone, Zaius sends a
      > batallion of police to arrest the leaders of the heretical
      rebellion
      > and gives them orders to destroy the project.
      >
      > A battalion of more than one hundred Policemen gallop into the
      > forbidden zone to obey the orders of zaius. Milo meanwhile has
      managed
      > to replace most of the damaged parts. Pack horses, levers and elbow
      > grease have lifted the spacecraft into position upon the ramp. In
      two
      > days Milo and a volunteer will attempt to fly the craft in a
      circuit
      > that will take them over the skies of Ape city and over the heads
      of
      > the advancing Gorrilla Army, led by Ursus... The Chimpanzees hope
      the
      > sight of a flying machine will not only halt the senseless war but
      be
      > the catalyst for bringing about a new era of peace.
      >
      > Milo is confident the ship will fly but has little idea how to
      pilot
      > or land it safely. He is prepared for what he believes will be a
      > one-way trip and is resigned to becoming a martyr to the cause of
      > peace and free science. The most he can hope for is to crash once
      more
      > into the water.
      >
      > CHAPTER 12
      > Dawn breaks on the final day on the Planet of the Apes. Elsewhere
      the
      > gorrila army have begaun to engage the mutants in the underground
      > remains of New York City.
      >
      > By Lake Powell a huge cloud of dust announces the approach of the
      > battalion of Police sent by Zaius. The "Sons of Galen" caught
      unawares
      > scatter and the gorillas approach unopposed. Milo terrified that
      all
      > his dreams are about to be obliterated climbs into the spacecraft.
      > Cornelius and Zira try to stop him but the sound of bullets
      bouncing
      > off the hull causes them all to seek refuge inside the ship. The
      hatch
      > is closed, the apes buckle up.
      >
      > The automated launch program is initiated. Gorillas arrive at the
      ship
      > and begin to pound upon the hull with rifle butts. The leader gives
      > the order to lay dynamite around the huge wooden platform that
      serves
      > as the runway.
      >
      > The engines of the ship and the fuse of the dynamite ignite at
      about
      > the same time, as the ship successfully achieves take-off the roar
      of
      > the exploding launch pad is lost in the sound of a much larger
      > explosion from New York City.
      >
      > The space craft breaks Earths orbit just as the planet explodes
      > sending a huge shockwave after it.
      >
      > Epilogue:
      >
      > Re-us
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18041 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the land was
      actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an entrance
      to the underground passageways.

      While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants could easily
      have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental powers
      to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
      projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.

      Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet until I saw
      Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it almost
      certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet already
      had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with annoying,
      but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork for
      their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I think it's
      possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock and
      wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.

      ABMAC

      On Friday, June 14, 2002, at 10:17 AM, epowe_2000 wrote:

      > speaking of which, what was the mirage mountain in
      > beneath. i understand it wasn't really there, but when it disappears
      > there is nothing there but flat land. how did taylor disappear in an
      > open space?
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18042 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      It could use some refining, but like that. Especially the bit about
      salvaging parts from one ship for the other. Still doesn't say HOW Milo
      found Taylors's SUNKEN ship, but anyway. But you're one up on us. You've
      been PUBLISHED...! :)
      Gristle P.


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "smugster2000" <4print@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 6:21 AM
      Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath


      > A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and write a
      > stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath - this was
      > before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.
      >
      > I did the first chapter of what I called 'Milo's Tale' (which was
      > published in a fanzine) and then abandoned it. Anyway, just for a
      > giggle here my un-revised outline that's been sitting on my hard drive
      > for at least 9 years.
      >
      > CHAPTER 1
      >
      > Milo discovers Taylor's ship... his studies soon teach him about the
      > possibility of flight. At this stage Milo would love to get the ship
      > back into the air - not realising it is actually intended for
      > interstellar space travel.
      >
      > CHAPTER 2 - 3
      > He soon realises the spacecraft represents many sciences that the High
      > council have repressed or banned outright. He also knows he would not
      > be allowed to study the ship openly and fearing it's destruction
      > before he has the chance to learn all it has to offer, he decides to
      > keep it a secret.
      >
      > CHAPTER 4
      > Milo reluctantly returns to Ape city knowing that his continued
      > absence would only raise unwelcome questions. - Suspicion rules - his
      > motives are questioned and his "souvenirs" confiscated. He appears
      > before the High Council and is severely reprimanded for exceeding his
      > travel permit. After careful questioning he denies finding anything of
      > great interest but Zaius suspects he is lying. Especially when he
      > shows Milo a US flag found among his belongings. Milo is rescued by
      > Ursus who wrongfully concludes that the flag must belong to some other
      > Simian population who are beginning to invade and claim the Zone as
      > their own. He begins his argument over the need to expand and invade
      > before this Ape City finds itself painted into a corner. We suspect
      > Zaius knows Ursus is wrong but cannot confront him without raising
      > more questions.
      >
      > CHAPTER 5
      > Frustrated by the councils obvious aversion to the truth Milo hatches
      > a fantasy whereby he will fly the spacecraft over the skies of Ape
      > city - a demonstration he feels sure will force the council to admit
      > to the possibilities of science and allow previously banned fields of
      > research to once again flourish.
      >
      > While mulling over the pleasant daydream Milo is roughly pushed aside
      > by a runaway human (Taylor) and nearly run down by the pursuing
      > mounted police. He witnesses Taylor's cry of "get your stinking paws
      > off me" and although shocked, his findings in the ship have at least
      > prepared him for the possibility of intelligent humans. (Although up
      > until now he didn't quite believe it) He puts two and two together and
      > makes a note to introduce himself to Dr. Zira at the earliest
      > possibility. He hopes that the talking human may be of enormous help
      > to him.
      >
      > CHAPTER 6
      > Milo asks Darwin, an important, high ranking Chimpanzee for an
      > introduction to Zira. After a little Cat and Mouse by the suspicious
      > Darwin he is told Zira is currently unavailable due to her part in the
      > talking human controvosy. Darwin invites him to a meeting of a "local
      > debating society". where he assures Milo he will get the opportunity
      > to meet Cornelius, Zira's husband.
      >
      > Milo attends the meeting and is surprised to discover a great many
      > other chimps, like himself who are frustrated by the Orangutans
      > refusal to allow science to advance. They call themselves "The sons of
      > Galen" in honour of a legendary Chimpanzee who, the stories say,
      > defied the powers that be and dedicated himself to the search for the
      > truth. (Fox Mulder of the Ape world) He meets fellow scientist
      > Cornelius (who has secrets of his own) The topic for the evening is
      > "Did man once ruled the earth" A notion that the Chimps are at least
      > happy to discuss. Some ancient artifacts are revealed (mostly by
      > Cornelius) supporting his theory that the Ape evolved from men. One
      > such artifact is an ancient crumbling book from the 20th century about
      > Science Fiction movies. One fading photograph from the movie "When
      > worlds collide" show a space ark upon the trestle type launch platform
      > that arcs up the side of a mountain. Milo is inspired by this picture
      > and thinks he has solved a small part of the problem of how to get the
      > spacecraft back into the air.
      >
      > CHAPTER 7
      > Milo confides his secret to Darwin and Cornelius who agree that the
      > ship of which he speaks must be Taylor's. Cornelius is unable to
      > accompany Milo on another expedition due to Taylors imminent trial.
      > Darwin has too high a profile to be seen leaving the city
      >
      > CHAPTER 8
      > Milo returns alone (without permission) to the site of the ship. He
      > spends many weeks/months in the Forbidden Zone studying the craft
      > (with the aid of an oracle like computer program.) The programmes and
      > electric's are mostly undamaged but most importantly, fully automated.
      > Much superficial water damage is cleaned up and the integrity of the
      > craft is returned to almost 100% However some vital components need
      > replacing... Components that have no counterparts in the 40th
      > century... Without them, the ship is useless.
      >
      > CHAPTER 9
      > He returns again to Ape city to find that Ursus has now gained
      > popularity and is successfully pushing for an invasion of the
      > Forbidden Zone. Because of the volatile political climate Zaius
      > resources are stretched rather thinly and Milo is allowed to come and
      > go almost unnoticed. He calls another meeting of the "Sons of Galen"
      > and this time tells them everything. The chimps agree that Milo's plan
      > of a fly-over would certainly shake up and perhaps oust the Orangutans
      > from power and maybe enable the Chimps to take over and rule more
      > sensibly. Milo is confident that the craft would have flown again if
      > only it were not lacking the vital missing pieces. Cornelius
      > introduces Milo to Zira and they stun him by revealing another ship,
      > similar to Taylor's has recently crashed (Brents)
      >
      > The "Sons of Galen" begin to organise a huge and risky undertaking.
      > Under the cover of the approaching war and while the Gorillas and
      > Orangutans are seemingly otherwise occupied a large workforce
      > comprised entirely of Chimps head out into the Zone to begin work on
      > the huge take off ramp that will be required. Meanwhile Milo,
      > Cornelius and Zira set out to locate Brents Ship and hopefully the
      > required spare parts.
      >
      > The suspicious Zaius has the Chimps followed by Gorilla scouts/spies.
      > The spies witness the discovery of the second ship then follow the
      > three apes back to the location of the first. They are stunned at the
      > scale of the construction work taking place and gallop back to Ape
      > city to make their report.
      >
      > CHAPTER 10 - 11
      > Zaius is not surprised to learn of Zira and Cornelius's part in the
      > heresy about to take place. Unable to attend to the matter himself due
      > to Ursus's imminent invasion of the Forbidden Zone, Zaius sends a
      > batallion of police to arrest the leaders of the heretical rebellion
      > and gives them orders to destroy the project.
      >
      > A battalion of more than one hundred Policemen gallop into the
      > forbidden zone to obey the orders of zaius. Milo meanwhile has managed
      > to replace most of the damaged parts. Pack horses, levers and elbow
      > grease have lifted the spacecraft into position upon the ramp. In two
      > days Milo and a volunteer will attempt to fly the craft in a circuit
      > that will take them over the skies of Ape city and over the heads of
      > the advancing Gorrilla Army, led by Ursus... The Chimpanzees hope the
      > sight of a flying machine will not only halt the senseless war but be
      > the catalyst for bringing about a new era of peace.
      >
      > Milo is confident the ship will fly but has little idea how to pilot
      > or land it safely. He is prepared for what he believes will be a
      > one-way trip and is resigned to becoming a martyr to the cause of
      > peace and free science. The most he can hope for is to crash once more
      > into the water.
      >
      > CHAPTER 12
      > Dawn breaks on the final day on the Planet of the Apes. Elsewhere the
      > gorrila army have begaun to engage the mutants in the underground
      > remains of New York City.
      >
      > By Lake Powell a huge cloud of dust announces the approach of the
      > battalion of Police sent by Zaius. The "Sons of Galen" caught unawares
      > scatter and the gorillas approach unopposed. Milo terrified that all
      > his dreams are about to be obliterated climbs into the spacecraft.
      > Cornelius and Zira try to stop him but the sound of bullets bouncing
      > off the hull causes them all to seek refuge inside the ship. The hatch
      > is closed, the apes buckle up.
      >
      > The automated launch program is initiated. Gorillas arrive at the ship
      > and begin to pound upon the hull with rifle butts. The leader gives
      > the order to lay dynamite around the huge wooden platform that serves
      > as the runway.
      >
      > The engines of the ship and the fuse of the dynamite ignite at about
      > the same time, as the ship successfully achieves take-off the roar of
      > the exploding launch pad is lost in the sound of a much larger
      > explosion from New York City.
      >
      > The space craft breaks Earths orbit just as the planet explodes
      > sending a huge shockwave after it.
      >
      > Epilogue:
      >
      > Re-us
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18043 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      .html
      .html
      No I wouldn't add anything that doesn't tie directly to the originals.  Though I'm warming to the idea of the miniseries.  You could actually show the originals in between the episodes!


      The first episode could be Zira and Corn meeting at the Academy.  A

      sort of love story, but we need to add an interesting idea (eg
      rivalry: a jealous rival plots to murder Cornelius - or something
      that explores the whole "ape shall never kill ape" thing -


      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18044 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      .html
      .html
      How does Milo get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone?


      Knowing Milo he didn't ask.
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18045 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] "Bourne" Yesterday
      .html
      I have a lot of respect for Damon as a writer and as an actor. Good Will
      Hunting was superb and original.

      I read "The Bourne Identity" when I was about 17, and it took me one
      sleepless night to read it. I could not put it down. Robert Ludlum was a
      great yarn spinner in my humble opinion.

      I hated "Coyote Ugly" (other than the obvious hetrosexual male incentives,
      who just had too many clothes on for my liking), but I would still watch it,
      or an inferior sequel, before I watch POTA 2001 again. That's really saying
      something.

      Michael

      > -----Original Message-----
      > From: veetus@... [veetus@...]
      > Sent: Friday, 14 June 2002 21:37
      > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] "Bourne" Yesterday
      >
      >
      > Today the flick "The Bourne Identity" opens, the movie Matt Damon passed
      > on POTA for. Would POTA have been a better movie if Damon
      > starred? Well, the
      > man IS an Oscar-winning screenwriter so maybe he could have given Burton
      > some tips (such as, "What is this sh*t? My grandma can write better 'n
      > this!").
      > And give me a break! Now it's said there's going to be a sequel
      > to "Coyote
      > Ugly". And they can't get an "Apes" sequel going?
      > - - - Jeff
      >
      >
      > ----- Original Message -----
      > From: "Jeff & Susan Stringer" <stringe@...>
      > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 9:22 PM
      > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:
      >
      >
      > > Here's their site, but no pics of the actual kit. Just the
      > photo on the
      > > box, which is a still from the beach scene. There is however, a photo of
      > the
      > > Caesar. Or I could send you photos of mine.
      > > www.modelprisoners.com
      > > Gristle P.
      > >
      > >
      > > ----- Original Message -----
      > > From: <LordTZer0@...>
      > > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 7:20 PM
      > > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Let's Try This:
      > >
      > >
      > > > They also do a three-figure kit of Zira, Cornelius and Dr.
      > Milo in their
      > > > space suits.
      > > >
      > > > Any pics of those? Anywho...I had the mask, and a costume made for a
      > > > Halloween party that's now well over 25 years old. Luckily my Mom's
      > > pretty
      > > > handy with a sewing machine. It still looks pretty good, but
      > I had the
      > > > physic of a concentration camp prisoner back then so its not going to
      > fit
      > > > now. And all sorts of posters and lobby cards etc... As well as some
      > > > appliances. I did have one I did when I was a kid, but foam rubber
      > > doesn't
      > > > keep forever. I have a couple of models and Medicoms. The
      > usual. But
      > a
      > > lot
      > > > was lost to garage sales in my late teens. The trash can,
      > the game . .
      > .
      > > In
      > > > fact I'm not absolutely sure I didn't buy back my own model from a toy
      > > > collectors store a quater century later at five times the price!
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      >
      > >
      > >
      >
      >
      >
      > ------------------------
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18046 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      Well why don't we?

      Michael

      > -----Original Message-----
      > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@...]
      > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 1:18

      would be fun to get together with someone and bang out a story. eddie
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18047 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Story between Planet and Beneath/Beneath and Escape
      .html
      What about the concept of another ape society, from another ape city, that
      is more teshnologically advanced and uses boats/deep sea diving equipment?
      Maybe even radar equipment, though this could be a real stretch.

      They could chance upon floating rubble and dive/explore. While I can't see
      them retrieving this ship, they could retrieve things from it (eg flight
      path simulator, and say a disc similar to the one Burke and Virdon retrieved
      in the TV Series). They could then then insert the disc into Brent's ship
      to reveal the location of the space station where the ship was SUPPOSED to
      land. This could lead to finding a nice, fresh ship/s at/near the space
      station that are kept in an environment where the effects of aging do not
      effect the ship too much (hence explaining the difference in design of the
      ship used to "Escape from the Planet of the Apes"). Inserting the disc into
      this craft brings up systems and because the disc is from Taylor's ship, the
      new ship assumes the same identity/flight path programme etc (hence
      explaining the "it's Taylor's ship" statement in "Escape").

      To explain the quick timing between Taylor's crash land and the destruction
      of earth being enough time for a technologically challenged race to get a
      ship in the air, maybe Dr Milo has already uncovered the ship (the new ape
      tribe find him camped in the building after he has been studying the complex
      and its contents for years), but the disc is the key that was needed to
      power up the ship. Dr Milo contacts his friends Corn and Zira and while
      attempting a test flight they discover they are unable to control the ship
      but the disc has set them on to auto pilot and the rest is written
      ("Escape").

      I just knocked this out as I typed it, so are there any obvious flubs here?

      Michael

      > -----Original Message-----
      > From: Jeff & Susan Stringer [stringe@...]
      > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 3:23
      > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      >
      >
      > It could use some refining, but like that. Especially the bit about
      > salvaging parts from one ship for the other. Still doesn't say HOW Milo
      > found Taylors's SUNKEN ship, but anyway. But you're one up on us. You've
      > been PUBLISHED...! :)
      > Gristle P.
      >
      >
      > ----- Original Message -----
      > From: "smugster2000" <4print@...>
      > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      > Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 6:21 AM
      > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      >
      >
      > > A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and write a
      > > stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath - this was
      > > before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.
      > >
      > > I did the first chapter of what I called 'Milo's Tale' (which was
      > > published in a fanzine) and then abandoned it. Anyway, just for a
      > > giggle here my un-revised outline that's been sitting on my hard drive
      > > for at least 9 years.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 1
      > >
      > > Milo discovers Taylor's ship... his studies soon teach him about the
      > > possibility of flight. At this stage Milo would love to get the ship
      > > back into the air - not realising it is actually intended for
      > > interstellar space travel.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 2 - 3
      > > He soon realises the spacecraft represents many sciences that the High
      > > council have repressed or banned outright. He also knows he would not
      > > be allowed to study the ship openly and fearing it's destruction
      > > before he has the chance to learn all it has to offer, he decides to
      > > keep it a secret.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 4
      > > Milo reluctantly returns to Ape city knowing that his continued
      > > absence would only raise unwelcome questions. - Suspicion rules - his
      > > motives are questioned and his "souvenirs" confiscated. He appears
      > > before the High Council and is severely reprimanded for exceeding his
      > > travel permit. After careful questioning he denies finding anything of
      > > great interest but Zaius suspects he is lying. Especially when he
      > > shows Milo a US flag found among his belongings. Milo is rescued by
      > > Ursus who wrongfully concludes that the flag must belong to some other
      > > Simian population who are beginning to invade and claim the Zone as
      > > their own. He begins his argument over the need to expand and invade
      > > before this Ape City finds itself painted into a corner. We suspect
      > > Zaius knows Ursus is wrong but cannot confront him without raising
      > > more questions.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 5
      > > Frustrated by the councils obvious aversion to the truth Milo hatches
      > > a fantasy whereby he will fly the spacecraft over the skies of Ape
      > > city - a demonstration he feels sure will force the council to admit
      > > to the possibilities of science and allow previously banned fields of
      > > research to once again flourish.
      > >
      > > While mulling over the pleasant daydream Milo is roughly pushed aside
      > > by a runaway human (Taylor) and nearly run down by the pursuing
      > > mounted police. He witnesses Taylor's cry of "get your stinking paws
      > > off me" and although shocked, his findings in the ship have at least
      > > prepared him for the possibility of intelligent humans. (Although up
      > > until now he didn't quite believe it) He puts two and two together and
      > > makes a note to introduce himself to Dr. Zira at the earliest
      > > possibility. He hopes that the talking human may be of enormous help
      > > to him.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 6
      > > Milo asks Darwin, an important, high ranking Chimpanzee for an
      > > introduction to Zira. After a little Cat and Mouse by the suspicious
      > > Darwin he is told Zira is currently unavailable due to her part in the
      > > talking human controvosy. Darwin invites him to a meeting of a "local
      > > debating society". where he assures Milo he will get the opportunity
      > > to meet Cornelius, Zira's husband.
      > >
      > > Milo attends the meeting and is surprised to discover a great many
      > > other chimps, like himself who are frustrated by the Orangutans
      > > refusal to allow science to advance. They call themselves "The sons of
      > > Galen" in honour of a legendary Chimpanzee who, the stories say,
      > > defied the powers that be and dedicated himself to the search for the
      > > truth. (Fox Mulder of the Ape world) He meets fellow scientist
      > > Cornelius (who has secrets of his own) The topic for the evening is
      > > "Did man once ruled the earth" A notion that the Chimps are at least
      > > happy to discuss. Some ancient artifacts are revealed (mostly by
      > > Cornelius) supporting his theory that the Ape evolved from men. One
      > > such artifact is an ancient crumbling book from the 20th century about
      > > Science Fiction movies. One fading photograph from the movie "When
      > > worlds collide" show a space ark upon the trestle type launch platform
      > > that arcs up the side of a mountain. Milo is inspired by this picture
      > > and thinks he has solved a small part of the problem of how to get the
      > > spacecraft back into the air.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 7
      > > Milo confides his secret to Darwin and Cornelius who agree that the
      > > ship of which he speaks must be Taylor's. Cornelius is unable to
      > > accompany Milo on another expedition due to Taylors imminent trial.
      > > Darwin has too high a profile to be seen leaving the city
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 8
      > > Milo returns alone (without permission) to the site of the ship. He
      > > spends many weeks/months in the Forbidden Zone studying the craft
      > > (with the aid of an oracle like computer program.) The programmes and
      > > electric's are mostly undamaged but most importantly, fully automated.
      > > Much superficial water damage is cleaned up and the integrity of the
      > > craft is returned to almost 100% However some vital components need
      > > replacing... Components that have no counterparts in the 40th
      > > century... Without them, the ship is useless.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 9
      > > He returns again to Ape city to find that Ursus has now gained
      > > popularity and is successfully pushing for an invasion of the
      > > Forbidden Zone. Because of the volatile political climate Zaius
      > > resources are stretched rather thinly and Milo is allowed to come and
      > > go almost unnoticed. He calls another meeting of the "Sons of Galen"
      > > and this time tells them everything. The chimps agree that Milo's plan
      > > of a fly-over would certainly shake up and perhaps oust the Orangutans
      > > from power and maybe enable the Chimps to take over and rule more
      > > sensibly. Milo is confident that the craft would have flown again if
      > > only it were not lacking the vital missing pieces. Cornelius
      > > introduces Milo to Zira and they stun him by revealing another ship,
      > > similar to Taylor's has recently crashed (Brents)
      > >
      > > The "Sons of Galen" begin to organise a huge and risky undertaking.
      > > Under the cover of the approaching war and while the Gorillas and
      > > Orangutans are seemingly otherwise occupied a large workforce
      > > comprised entirely of Chimps head out into the Zone to begin work on
      > > the huge take off ramp that will be required. Meanwhile Milo,
      > > Cornelius and Zira set out to locate Brents Ship and hopefully the
      > > required spare parts.
      > >
      > > The suspicious Zaius has the Chimps followed by Gorilla scouts/spies.
      > > The spies witness the discovery of the second ship then follow the
      > > three apes back to the location of the first. They are stunned at the
      > > scale of the construction work taking place and gallop back to Ape
      > > city to make their report.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 10 - 11
      > > Zaius is not surprised to learn of Zira and Cornelius's part in the
      > > heresy about to take place. Unable to attend to the matter himself due
      > > to Ursus's imminent invasion of the Forbidden Zone, Zaius sends a
      > > batallion of police to arrest the leaders of the heretical rebellion
      > > and gives them orders to destroy the project.
      > >
      > > A battalion of more than one hundred Policemen gallop into the
      > > forbidden zone to obey the orders of zaius. Milo meanwhile has managed
      > > to replace most of the damaged parts. Pack horses, levers and elbow
      > > grease have lifted the spacecraft into position upon the ramp. In two
      > > days Milo and a volunteer will attempt to fly the craft in a circuit
      > > that will take them over the skies of Ape city and over the heads of
      > > the advancing Gorrilla Army, led by Ursus... The Chimpanzees hope the
      > > sight of a flying machine will not only halt the senseless war but be
      > > the catalyst for bringing about a new era of peace.
      > >
      > > Milo is confident the ship will fly but has little idea how to pilot
      > > or land it safely. He is prepared for what he believes will be a
      > > one-way trip and is resigned to becoming a martyr to the cause of
      > > peace and free science. The most he can hope for is to crash once more
      > > into the water.
      > >
      > > CHAPTER 12
      > > Dawn breaks on the final day on the Planet of the Apes. Elsewhere the
      > > gorrila army have begaun to engage the mutants in the underground
      > > remains of New York City.
      > >
      > > By Lake Powell a huge cloud of dust announces the approach of the
      > > battalion of Police sent by Zaius. The "Sons of Galen" caught unawares
      > > scatter and the gorillas approach unopposed. Milo terrified that all
      > > his dreams are about to be obliterated climbs into the spacecraft.
      > > Cornelius and Zira try to stop him but the sound of bullets bouncing
      > > off the hull causes them all to seek refuge inside the ship. The hatch
      > > is closed, the apes buckle up.
      > >
      > > The automated launch program is initiated. Gorillas arrive at the ship
      > > and begin to pound upon the hull with rifle butts. The leader gives
      > > the order to lay dynamite around the huge wooden platform that serves
      > > as the runway.
      > >
      > > The engines of the ship and the fuse of the dynamite ignite at about
      > > the same time, as the ship successfully achieves take-off the roar of
      > > the exploding launch pad is lost in the sound of a much larger
      > > explosion from New York City.
      > >
      > > The space craft breaks Earths orbit just as the planet explodes
      > > sending a huge shockwave after it.
      > >
      > > Epilogue:
      > >
      > > Re-us
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >
      > >

      >
      >





      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18048 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: What would you do?
      .html
      .html
      Absolutely.  I seriously believe you could do a shitload of episodes (like a whole TV series) on ape city/ape culture/other ape nations etc and make them all pre Planet.
       
      Then show Planet at the end of the series.
       
      Then all over again focusing on post-Planet (things must have been stirred up by the talking human - a lot would have changed!), pre- beneath and so on.
       
      But for starters, I guess it would be better to just concentrate on one story at a time and see where it goes.
       
      Michael
      -----Original Message-----
      From: LordTZer0@... [LordTZer0@...]
      Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 3:42
      To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?


      No I wouldn't add anything that doesn't tie directly to the originals.  Though I'm warming to the idea of the miniseries.  You could actually show the originals in between the episodes!


      The first episode could be Zira and Corn meeting at the Academy.  A

      sort of love story, but we need to add an interesting idea (eg
      rivalry: a jealous rival plots to murder Cornelius - or something
      that explores the whole "ape shall never kill ape" thing -



      Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18049 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      .html
      .html
      Maybe he just went - or maybe he faked his own death in order to explore the "Zone".
       
      Was there a Forbidden Zone in Boulle's novel or did the creator of the Twilight Zone also create the Forbidden Zone?
       
      The Forbidden Zone would be a great title/place to start with for the first story where Zira and Corn meet.
       
      T, should we collaborate privately and get a story going here?
       
      Michael
      -----Original Message-----
      From: LordTZer0@... [LordTZer0@...]
      Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 3:46
      To: pota@yahoogroups.com
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do


      How does Milo get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone?


      Knowing Milo he didn't ask.


      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18050 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      The mutants insist they don't kill their enemies. I guess scaring them is
      as far as they go (which didn't work). The rolling rock must be an example
      of raw nature or maybe just some action thrown in so the execs wouldn't be
      so nervous of all that screen time walking ( I can't see that moment without
      thinking of "Raiders of the Lost Ark"). I'm sure the astros wouls have
      preferred sharing a Rolling Rock rather than running from one.
      - - Jeff


      ----- Original Message -----
      From: "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@...>
      To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 9:32 AM
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath


      > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the land was
      > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an entrance
      > to the underground passageways.
      >
      > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants could easily
      > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental powers
      > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
      > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
      >
      > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet until I saw
      > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it almost
      > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet already
      > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with annoying,
      > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork for
      > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I think it's
      > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock and
      > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
      >
      > ABMAC
      >
      > On Friday, June 14, 2002, at 10:17 AM, epowe_2000 wrote:
      >
      > > speaking of which, what was the mirage mountain in
      > > beneath. i understand it wasn't really there, but when it disappears
      > > there is nothing there but flat land. how did taylor disappear in an
      > > open space?
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18051 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      .htmlHey, I read your story of Milo, and actually found it pretty good. It has the elements that make it "Ape", and it sure as hell beats what was in the 70's magazine as far as their original stuff. Your story was written better than a lot of things I've read as far as moving the plot along goes, and you said you can't write worth a sh*t... Well, I'd say your idea was good enough that you, or someone else should maybe write this plot of your's into a full blown story. I liked it.

      The only thing, I always kind of thought in my mind that Cornelius and Zira knew Milo for some time, like maybe Cornelius went to school with him or something of that nature. And also in my mind, I always kinda thought that Milo came upon his knowledge of the ship from conversations with those "heretic" friends of his. I was under the impression that Cornelius/Zira told him of what Taylor said, things like the location of the crash, etc.. and then Milo went about to see if this was true... But that was in my mind, I don't know what others think, but your ideas pretty much "work" for me. I think I'd "maybe" only change that part of it. I'd maybe change it to Milo's discovering of the ship after having discussions with his friends "discovered" this curious talking human... But the rest of your story is as good as most other "original" I'm sure... And, by the way, I like the part of them salvaging parts from the wreckage of Brent's ship, that was a good addition...
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18052 From: sand_hill_school Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: Story between Planet and Beneath/Beneath and Escape
      .html
      1.) It seems the Mutants have access to higher levels of
      technology. I'm wondering if there isn't a way that the Mutants may
      have resurrected Taylor's ship -- maybe thinking it was a "bomb" --
      and in some way either knowingly or unknowingly helped Dr. Milo.

      2.) A technologically advanced society of Apes seems logical to me,
      but the existance of another community of Apes would have to be
      firmly and credibly established. There is a treasure trove of
      accessible information left for eons by the advanced human
      civilizations. Even if all the Apes can do is "ape" what humans have
      done, there are materials and information available. It's certainly
      possible.

      3.) I think a third ship could be key to the puzzle, though. Much
      like the third pod idea in POTA 2001 (wash my mouth with soap). The
      chip idea works. (Maybe the dog tags have the information in an
      embedded chip, and you don't need to go underwater at all. Maybe
      they find a discarded ship from the ANSA program -- in working order -
      - and use that one.)

      Someone would have to put it all together, though, and have it make
      sense. Still sounds a bit contrived. And I am sure this is FULL of
      holes.

      I would certainly like to know more about Dr. Milo.

      -- Helen



      --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
      > What about the concept of another ape society, from another ape
      city, that
      > is more teshnologically advanced and uses boats/deep sea diving
      equipment?
      > Maybe even radar equipment, though this could be a real stretch.
      >
      > They could chance upon floating rubble and dive/explore. While I
      can't see
      > them retrieving this ship, they could retrieve things from it (eg
      flight
      > path simulator, and say a disc similar to the one Burke and Virdon
      retrieved
      > in the TV Series). They could then then insert the disc into
      Brent's ship
      > to reveal the location of the space station where the ship was
      SUPPOSED to
      > land. This could lead to finding a nice, fresh ship/s at/near the
      space
      > station that are kept in an environment where the effects of aging
      do not
      > effect the ship too much (hence explaining the difference in design
      of the
      > ship used to "Escape from the Planet of the Apes"). Inserting the
      disc into
      > this craft brings up systems and because the disc is from Taylor's
      ship, the
      > new ship assumes the same identity/flight path programme etc (hence
      > explaining the "it's Taylor's ship" statement in "Escape").
      >
      > To explain the quick timing between Taylor's crash land and the
      destruction
      > of earth being enough time for a technologically challenged race to
      get a
      > ship in the air, maybe Dr Milo has already uncovered the ship (the
      new ape
      > tribe find him camped in the building after he has been studying
      the complex
      > and its contents for years), but the disc is the key that was
      needed to
      > power up the ship. Dr Milo contacts his friends Corn and Zira and
      while
      > attempting a test flight they discover they are unable to control
      the ship
      > but the disc has set them on to auto pilot and the rest is written
      > ("Escape").
      >
      > I just knocked this out as I typed it, so are there any obvious
      flubs here?
      >
      > Michael
      >
      > > -----Original Message-----
      > > From: Jeff & Susan Stringer [stringe@b...]
      > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 3:23
      > > To: pota@y...
      > > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and
      Beneath
      > >
      > >
      > > It could use some refining, but like that. Especially the bit
      about
      > > salvaging parts from one ship for the other. Still doesn't say
      HOW Milo
      > > found Taylors's SUNKEN ship, but anyway. But you're one up on us.
      You've
      > > been PUBLISHED...! :)
      > > Gristle P.
      > >
      > >
      > > ----- Original Message -----
      > > From: "smugster2000" <4print@a...>
      > > To: <pota@y...>
      > > Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 6:21 AM
      > > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      > >
      > >
      > > > A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and
      write a
      > > > stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath -
      this was
      > > > before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.
      > > >
      > > > I did the first chapter of what I called 'Milo's Tale' (which
      was
      > > > published in a fanzine) and then abandoned it. Anyway, just for
      a
      > > > giggle here my un-revised outline that's been sitting on my
      hard drive
      > > > for at least 9 years.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 1
      > > >
      > > > Milo discovers Taylor's ship... his studies soon teach him
      about the
      > > > possibility of flight. At this stage Milo would love to get the
      ship
      > > > back into the air - not realising it is actually intended for
      > > > interstellar space travel.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 2 - 3
      > > > He soon realises the spacecraft represents many sciences that
      the High
      > > > council have repressed or banned outright. He also knows he
      would not
      > > > be allowed to study the ship openly and fearing it's destruction
      > > > before he has the chance to learn all it has to offer, he
      decides to
      > > > keep it a secret.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 4
      > > > Milo reluctantly returns to Ape city knowing that his continued
      > > > absence would only raise unwelcome questions. - Suspicion
      rules - his
      > > > motives are questioned and his "souvenirs" confiscated. He
      appears
      > > > before the High Council and is severely reprimanded for
      exceeding his
      > > > travel permit. After careful questioning he denies finding
      anything of
      > > > great interest but Zaius suspects he is lying. Especially when
      he
      > > > shows Milo a US flag found among his belongings. Milo is
      rescued by
      > > > Ursus who wrongfully concludes that the flag must belong to
      some other
      > > > Simian population who are beginning to invade and claim the
      Zone as
      > > > their own. He begins his argument over the need to expand and
      invade
      > > > before this Ape City finds itself painted into a corner. We
      suspect
      > > > Zaius knows Ursus is wrong but cannot confront him without
      raising
      > > > more questions.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 5
      > > > Frustrated by the councils obvious aversion to the truth Milo
      hatches
      > > > a fantasy whereby he will fly the spacecraft over the skies of
      Ape
      > > > city - a demonstration he feels sure will force the council to
      admit
      > > > to the possibilities of science and allow previously banned
      fields of
      > > > research to once again flourish.
      > > >
      > > > While mulling over the pleasant daydream Milo is roughly pushed
      aside
      > > > by a runaway human (Taylor) and nearly run down by the pursuing
      > > > mounted police. He witnesses Taylor's cry of "get your stinking
      paws
      > > > off me" and although shocked, his findings in the ship have at
      least
      > > > prepared him for the possibility of intelligent humans.
      (Although up
      > > > until now he didn't quite believe it) He puts two and two
      together and
      > > > makes a note to introduce himself to Dr. Zira at the earliest
      > > > possibility. He hopes that the talking human may be of enormous
      help
      > > > to him.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 6
      > > > Milo asks Darwin, an important, high ranking Chimpanzee for an
      > > > introduction to Zira. After a little Cat and Mouse by the
      suspicious
      > > > Darwin he is told Zira is currently unavailable due to her part
      in the
      > > > talking human controvosy. Darwin invites him to a meeting of
      a "local
      > > > debating society". where he assures Milo he will get the
      opportunity
      > > > to meet Cornelius, Zira's husband.
      > > >
      > > > Milo attends the meeting and is surprised to discover a great
      many
      > > > other chimps, like himself who are frustrated by the Orangutans
      > > > refusal to allow science to advance. They call themselves "The
      sons of
      > > > Galen" in honour of a legendary Chimpanzee who, the stories say,
      > > > defied the powers that be and dedicated himself to the search
      for the
      > > > truth. (Fox Mulder of the Ape world) He meets fellow scientist
      > > > Cornelius (who has secrets of his own) The topic for the
      evening is
      > > > "Did man once ruled the earth" A notion that the Chimps are at
      least
      > > > happy to discuss. Some ancient artifacts are revealed (mostly by
      > > > Cornelius) supporting his theory that the Ape evolved from men.
      One
      > > > such artifact is an ancient crumbling book from the 20th
      century about
      > > > Science Fiction movies. One fading photograph from the
      movie "When
      > > > worlds collide" show a space ark upon the trestle type launch
      platform
      > > > that arcs up the side of a mountain. Milo is inspired by this
      picture
      > > > and thinks he has solved a small part of the problem of how to
      get the
      > > > spacecraft back into the air.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 7
      > > > Milo confides his secret to Darwin and Cornelius who agree that
      the
      > > > ship of which he speaks must be Taylor's. Cornelius is unable to
      > > > accompany Milo on another expedition due to Taylors imminent
      trial.
      > > > Darwin has too high a profile to be seen leaving the city
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 8
      > > > Milo returns alone (without permission) to the site of the
      ship. He
      > > > spends many weeks/months in the Forbidden Zone studying the
      craft
      > > > (with the aid of an oracle like computer program.) The
      programmes and
      > > > electric's are mostly undamaged but most importantly, fully
      automated.
      > > > Much superficial water damage is cleaned up and the integrity
      of the
      > > > craft is returned to almost 100% However some vital components
      need
      > > > replacing... Components that have no counterparts in the 40th
      > > > century... Without them, the ship is useless.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 9
      > > > He returns again to Ape city to find that Ursus has now gained
      > > > popularity and is successfully pushing for an invasion of the
      > > > Forbidden Zone. Because of the volatile political climate Zaius
      > > > resources are stretched rather thinly and Milo is allowed to
      come and
      > > > go almost unnoticed. He calls another meeting of the "Sons of
      Galen"
      > > > and this time tells them everything. The chimps agree that
      Milo's plan
      > > > of a fly-over would certainly shake up and perhaps oust the
      Orangutans
      > > > from power and maybe enable the Chimps to take over and rule
      more
      > > > sensibly. Milo is confident that the craft would have flown
      again if
      > > > only it were not lacking the vital missing pieces. Cornelius
      > > > introduces Milo to Zira and they stun him by revealing another
      ship,
      > > > similar to Taylor's has recently crashed (Brents)
      > > >
      > > > The "Sons of Galen" begin to organise a huge and risky
      undertaking.
      > > > Under the cover of the approaching war and while the Gorillas
      and
      > > > Orangutans are seemingly otherwise occupied a large workforce
      > > > comprised entirely of Chimps head out into the Zone to begin
      work on
      > > > the huge take off ramp that will be required. Meanwhile Milo,
      > > > Cornelius and Zira set out to locate Brents Ship and hopefully
      the
      > > > required spare parts.
      > > >
      > > > The suspicious Zaius has the Chimps followed by Gorilla
      scouts/spies.
      > > > The spies witness the discovery of the second ship then follow
      the
      > > > three apes back to the location of the first. They are stunned
      at the
      > > > scale of the construction work taking place and gallop back to
      Ape
      > > > city to make their report.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 10 - 11
      > > > Zaius is not surprised to learn of Zira and Cornelius's part in
      the
      > > > heresy about to take place. Unable to attend to the matter
      himself due
      > > > to Ursus's imminent invasion of the Forbidden Zone, Zaius sends
      a
      > > > batallion of police to arrest the leaders of the heretical
      rebellion
      > > > and gives them orders to destroy the project.
      > > >
      > > > A battalion of more than one hundred Policemen gallop into the
      > > > forbidden zone to obey the orders of zaius. Milo meanwhile has
      managed
      > > > to replace most of the damaged parts. Pack horses, levers and
      elbow
      > > > grease have lifted the spacecraft into position upon the ramp.
      In two
      > > > days Milo and a volunteer will attempt to fly the craft in a
      circuit
      > > > that will take them over the skies of Ape city and over the
      heads of
      > > > the advancing Gorrilla Army, led by Ursus... The Chimpanzees
      hope the
      > > > sight of a flying machine will not only halt the senseless war
      but be
      > > > the catalyst for bringing about a new era of peace.
      > > >
      > > > Milo is confident the ship will fly but has little idea how to
      pilot
      > > > or land it safely. He is prepared for what he believes will be a
      > > > one-way trip and is resigned to becoming a martyr to the cause
      of
      > > > peace and free science. The most he can hope for is to crash
      once more
      > > > into the water.
      > > >
      > > > CHAPTER 12
      > > > Dawn breaks on the final day on the Planet of the Apes.
      Elsewhere the
      > > > gorrila army have begaun to engage the mutants in the
      underground
      > > > remains of New York City.
      > > >
      > > > By Lake Powell a huge cloud of dust announces the approach of
      the
      > > > battalion of Police sent by Zaius. The "Sons of Galen" caught
      unawares
      > > > scatter and the gorillas approach unopposed. Milo terrified
      that all
      > > > his dreams are about to be obliterated climbs into the
      spacecraft.
      > > > Cornelius and Zira try to stop him but the sound of bullets
      bouncing
      > > > off the hull causes them all to seek refuge inside the ship.
      The hatch
      > > > is closed, the apes buckle up.
      > > >
      > > > The automated launch program is initiated. Gorillas arrive at
      the ship
      > > > and begin to pound upon the hull with rifle butts. The leader
      gives
      > > > the order to lay dynamite around the huge wooden platform that
      serves
      > > > as the runway.
      > > >
      > > > The engines of the ship and the fuse of the dynamite ignite at
      about
      > > > the same time, as the ship successfully achieves take-off the
      roar of
      > > > the exploding launch pad is lost in the sound of a much larger
      > > > explosion from New York City.
      > > >
      > > > The space craft breaks Earths orbit just as the planet explodes
      > > > sending a huge shockwave after it.
      > > >
      > > > Epilogue:
      > > >
      > > > Re-us
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      > > >
      >
      > >
      > >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      >
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18053 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
      .html
      .htmlIn a message dated 6/14/2002 12:47:42 PM Central Standard Time, LordTZer0@... writes:



      How does Milo get permission to spend so much time in the forbidden zone?


      Knowing Milo he didn't ask.


      I agree with T on this one. I picture Milo being a bit of a "renegade" when it comes to scientific matters. He probably just went about trying to discover the ships (possible) existance without the permission of the Acadamy. That or he went in under false pretenses, saying he was searching for one thing while secretly trying to uncover the ship.
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18054 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
      .html
      .htmlI'd have to agree with the posting from last night, I'd like to see more on the APE culture itself. And another story I'd kind of like to see is "LANDON"... What happened to him from the time of his capture up until the time Taylor see's the lobotomized ex-astronaut? After it was discovered he could speak, was he immediately taken to the lab to be lobotomized by (I'd assume it was) Dr. Galen? Do you think he played "mute" or immediately let it be known he could talk? Was he at all interrogated by anyone (including Zaius) or did Zaius just simply hand down the order of "quiet" this human before he destroys us. What do you members of the group think on this subject?

      My own opinion is he probably did talk right away, and was kept under very tight security until Zaius was notified... I think Zaius might have talked to him a bit for himself. After all, I don't think he'd let something like that go... I'm sure he must seen this "mutant" for himself before having him "disposed of."
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18055 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Correcting a typo in Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
      .html
      .htmlI think I'd "maybe" only change that part of it. I'd maybe change it to Milo's discovering of the ship after having discussions with his friends "discovered" this curious talking human...

      This should read: I think I'd "maybe" only change that part of it. I'd maybe change it to Milo's discovering of the ship after having discussions with his friends after they "discovered" this curious talking human..
      <.html
      <.html
      Group: pota Message: 18056 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/14/2002
      Subject: Toons Sneak Peek
      .html
      Attachments :
        Here's an example of how the toons background will come out.
        Image provided by, Dan.

        Best.
        Al

        P.S. This is just a jpeg creation, the DVD creation will be a bit better.
        With full titles of episodes and writing.


        _____
        <.html
        Group: pota Message: 18057 From: MTotsky@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
        Subject: Alex is the Coolest!
        .html
        Alex,

        I got my DVD in the mail today. The fact that you did this for the list has
        got to be one of the all time coolest things I have seen anyone do for a
        group of total strangers. If only we could all be so kind to those around us,
        then the world would be a better place.

        You put the "fan" in fantastic!

        Matt
        <.html
        Group: pota Message: 18058 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/14/2002
        Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
        .html
        Attachments :
          Glad to hear it, Matt.
          I've been told by quit a few so far that they've received their's in mail
          the last couple of days.

          Enjoy.
          Al



          >From: MTotsky@...
          >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          >To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          >Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
          >Date: Fri, 14 Jun 2002 23:32:46 EDT
          >




          _____
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18059 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/14/2002
          Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          i'm game though i must say i am more interested in making "all"
          planet stories fit into one cohesive timeline than fill "in the gaps"
          of the movies. yeah, a major undertaking, but i think it can be done.
          that was one of the things my original story dealt with. eddie

          --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > Well why don't we?
          >
          > Michael
          >
          > > -----Original Message-----
          > > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@a...]
          > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 1:18
          >
          > would be fun to get together with someone and bang out a story.
          eddie
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18060 From: CheeseGOTAS@aol.com Date: 6/14/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
          .html
          In a message dated 6/14/02 10:33:10 PM Central Daylight Time, MTotsky@...
          writes:

          << You put the "fan" in fantastic!

          Matt >>

          Ditto.

          -Joe
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18061 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Roll'n Rock
          .html
          Hmmm...I always thought it was the intellectually challenged humans trying
          to attack what they thought were apes (because the astros had clothes and
          spoke).

          Michael

          > -----Original Message-----
          > From: veetus@... [veetus@...]
          > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 10:35
          > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          >
          >
          > The mutants insist they don't kill their enemies. I guess
          > scaring them is
          > as far as they go (which didn't work). The rolling rock must be an example
          > of raw nature or maybe just some action thrown in so the execs wouldn't be
          > so nervous of all that screen time walking ( I can't see that
          > moment without
          > thinking of "Raiders of the Lost Ark"). I'm sure the astros wouls have
          > preferred sharing a Rolling Rock rather than running from one.
          > - - Jeff
          >
          >
          > ----- Original Message -----
          > From: "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@...>
          > To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
          > Sent: Friday, June 14, 2002 9:32 AM
          > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          >
          >
          > > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the land was
          > > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an entrance
          > > to the underground passageways.
          > >
          > > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants could easily
          > > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental powers
          > > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
          > > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
          > >
          > > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet until I saw
          > > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it almost
          > > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet already
          > > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with annoying,
          > > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork for
          > > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I think it's
          > > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock and
          > > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
          > >
          > > ABMAC
          > >
          > > On Friday, June 14, 2002, at 10:17 AM, epowe_2000 wrote:
          > >
          > > > speaking of which, what was the mirage mountain in
          > > > beneath. i understand it wasn't really there, but when it disappears
          > > > there is nothing there but flat land. how did taylor disappear in an
          > > > open space?
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >
          >
          > >
          > >
          >
          >
          >
          > ------------------------
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18062 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          So is the timeline circular or does it change after Cornelius and Zira
          travel back with Milo?

          Michael

          > -----Original Message-----
          > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@...]
          > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 14:05
          > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          >
          >
          > i'm game though i must say i am more interested in making "all"
          > planet stories fit into one cohesive timeline than fill "in the gaps"
          > of the movies. yeah, a major undertaking, but i think it can be done.
          > that was one of the things my original story dealt with. eddie
          >
          > --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > > Well why don't we?
          > >
          > > Michael
          > >
          > > > -----Original Message-----
          > > > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@a...]
          > > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 1:18
          > >
          > > would be fun to get together with someone and bang out a story.
          > eddie
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18063 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
          .html
          You really rock my world Alex!

          If i was gay I would hunt you down and have kinky sex with you.

          Michael

          > -----Original Message-----
          > From: CheeseGOTAS@... [CheeseGOTAS@...]
          > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 14:28
          > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          > Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Alex is the Coolest!
          >
          >
          > In a message dated 6/14/02 10:33:10 PM Central Daylight Time,
          > MTotsky@...
          > writes:
          >
          > << You put the "fan" in fantastic!
          >
          > Matt >>
          >
          > Ditto.
          >
          > -Joe
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18064 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          Jeff Krueger has a good timeline.

          Jeff, wanna post it for comment?

          Michael

          > -----Original Message-----
          > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@...]
          > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 14:05
          > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          >
          >
          > i'm game though i must say i am more interested in making "all"
          > planet stories fit into one cohesive timeline than fill "in the gaps"
          > of the movies. yeah, a major undertaking, but i think it can be done.
          > that was one of the things my original story dealt with. eddie
          >
          > --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > > Well why don't we?
          > >
          > > Michael
          > >
          > > > -----Original Message-----
          > > > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@a...]
          > > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 1:18
          > >
          > > would be fun to get together with someone and bang out a story.
          > eddie
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18065 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
          .html
          .html
          Alex
           
          I'm still waiting for you to tell me how much to send you for Air Mail shipping to Australia.  Did you get my email?
           
          Michael
           
          -----Original Message-----
          From: thypentacle [thypentacle@...]
          Sent: Monday, 10 June 2002 8:41
          To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle

          Just a note to remind you that I switched my DVD request to the toons. :o) Unless of course you're giving me both, please cancel my Battle uncut DVD. Also, would you like me to send you shipping costs?? I forgot to ask.

          ThyPentacle

            Calima 5021 <calima5021com@...> wrote:



          Here is tomorrows mailing list for Battle UNcut.

          1. Brian P.
          2. James A.
          3. ThyPentacle M.D.
          4. Tom K.
          5. Glen S.
          6. Matt T.
          7. Patrick T.
          8. Shelby R.

          All will be shiped Monday morning and should be reaching every by the end of
          the week, seeing there all U.S. Posts.

          The 10 or 11 Toon requests will go out by the end of the month, (still needs
          finishing touches) and POTA 2001 which I believe only, Mike Le Master,
          requested, will be sent out next Monday. Seeing he was the only one. I have
          you down for Toons as well, Lord T.

          A mailing list will be made for toons before shipping as well.
          The Krueger Collection, will be made in JULY and will be sold for $10 each,
          with half royalties going to, Jeff. And for those who won't have Toons,
          Battle UNcut nor POTA 2001 Exclusives, I'll put each up for sale for this
          low price as well, following t Sign-up for Video Highlights of 2002 FIFA World Cup

          Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the .

          <.html
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18066 From: smugster2000 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:

          > The only thing, I always kind of thought in my mind that
          Cornelius and Zira
          > knew Milo for some time, like maybe Cornelius went to school
          with him or
          > something of that nature. And also in my mind, I always kinda
          thought that
          > Milo came upon his knowledge of the ship from conversations
          with those
          > "heretic" friends of his. I was under the impression that
          Cornelius/Zira told
          > him of what Taylor said, things like the location of the crash,
          etc.. and
          > then Milo went about to see if this was true... But that was in my
          mind, I
          > don't know what others think, but your ideas pretty much "work"
          for me. I
          > think I'd "maybe" only change that part of it. I'd maybe change it
          to Milo's
          > discovering of the ship after having discussions with his
          friends
          > "discovered" this curious talking human...

          Although I haven't thought about this story for a long time I do
          remember the biggest headache when I was mapping it out was
          a question of TIME... How much elapses between Taylor landing
          and the planet exploding.?

          So how long between the crash landing and Taylors capture?
          How long does it take his throat to heal and start speaking? (He
          makes a reference to "It's been weeks" just before the trial. How
          long does he wander around in the Forbidden zone before
          capture by the mutants? How long is he in captivity before Brent
          arrives?

          I think I made the decision to allow Milo to find the ship as early
          as possible to allow him as much time as possible to discover
          its secrets.

          I think I still have what little I did wrtie on file - If anyone
          wants it
          email me privately and I'll pass it on.

          Dave
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18067 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
          .html
          Air mail shouldn't be that much. I just sent about 10 dics to England, by 5
          - 7 day air mail and it was no more than 12 dollars. Two Toon discs
          shouldn't be more than 5 dollars (less than half the weight of 12 discs) so
          don't worry about it.

          Best.
          Al

          P.S. Enjoy the Discs, Dave. Let me know when they get there. I sent it out
          on Monday, so it should get to you no later then Saturday (today) or latest
          Monday.



          >From: "Michael Whitty" <whitty@...>
          >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          >To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
          >Subject: RE: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
          >Date: Sat, 15 Jun 2002 22:02:05 +1000
          >
          >Alex
          >
          >I'm still waiting for you to tell me how much to send you for Air Mail
          >shipping to Australia. Did you get my email?
          >
          >Michael
          >
          >-----Original Message-----
          >From: thypentacle [thypentacle@...]
          >Sent: Monday, 10 June 2002 8:41
          >To: pota@yahoogroups.com
          >Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] DVD List for Battle
          >
          >
          >Just a note to remind you that I switched my DVD request to the toons. :o)
          >Unless of course you're giving me both, please cancel my Battle uncut DVD.
          >Also, would you like me to send you shipping costs?? I forgot to ask.
          >
          >ThyPentacle
          >
          > Calima 5021 <calima5021com@...> wrote:
          >
          >
          >
          > Here is tomorrows mailing list for Battle UNcut.
          >
          > 1. Brian P.
          > 2. James A.
          > 3. ThyPentacle M.D.
          > 4. Tom K.
          > 5. Glen S.
          > 6. Matt T.
          > 7. Patrick T.
          > 8. Shelby R.
          >
          > All will be shiped Monday morning and should be reaching every by the
          >end of
          > the week, seeing there all U.S. Posts.
          >
          > The 10 or 11 Toon requests will go out by the end of the month, (still
          >needs
          > finishing touches) and POTA 2001 which I believe only, Mike Le Master,
          > requested, will be sent out next Monday. Seeing he was the only one. I
          >have
          > you down for Toons as well, Lord T.
          >
          > A mailing list will be made for toons before shipping as well.
          > The Krueger Collection, will be made in JULY and will be sold for $10
          >each,
          > with half royalties going to, Jeff. And for those who won't have
          >Toons,
          > Battle UNcut nor POTA 2001 Exclusives, I'll put each up for sale for
          >this
          > low price as well, following t Sign-up for Video Highlights of 2002
          >FIFA
          >World Cup
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          >
          > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
          >




          _____
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18068 From: its_a_mad_house Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
          .html
          These figures certainly are um....interesting. Have you seen them
          for sales here in the states and if so at what store? Thanks,
          Bernard--- In pota@y..., "Jeff & Susan Stringer" <stringe@b...>
          wrote:
          > These are unlicensed figures. Probably from Mexico. You should
          see their
          > STAR WARS knockoffs. Scary.
          > Gristle P.
          >
          >
          > ----- Original Message -----
          > From: "mystic4ever" <mystic4ever@s...>
          > To: <pota@y...>
          > Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2002 9:19 PM
          > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
          >
          >
          > Has anyone else out there seen these? I saw the display for the
          first time
          > today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures. Apparently they were
          released in
          > May. Kind of hokey, but if you loved the Burton movie like I did,
          you'll
          > probably like them! Odd packaging since the blister card has
          modified pics
          > of the classic characters, but the actual figures are all POTA 2001
          > inspired. There are six that I've seen. I've attached scans of
          two of the
          > "gorillas". The others are a male & female human where the female
          resembles
          > Daena and the male is an astronaut who doesn't look much like
          Wahlberg;
          > another gorilla with gold colouring and there's a female warrior
          gorilla.
          >
          > Dan
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18069 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          the timeline changes but not because of zira and cornelius' travel.
          their travel created the original timeline. it changes because of
          another time traveler. the whole idea (besides trying to tie
          disparate apes stories together) was to suggest (as i believed at the
          time) that history's details can be changed but fate (if you want to
          call it that) will always deliver the same outcome when you look at
          the broad picture. eddie

          --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > So is the timeline circular or does it change after Cornelius and
          Zira
          > travel back with Milo?
          >
          > Michael
          >
          > > -----Original Message-----
          > > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@a...]
          > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 14:05
          > > To: pota@y...
          > > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          > >
          > >
          > > i'm game though i must say i am more interested in making "all"
          > > planet stories fit into one cohesive timeline than fill "in the
          gaps"
          > > of the movies. yeah, a major undertaking, but i think it can be
          done.
          > > that was one of the things my original story dealt with. eddie
          > >
          > > --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > > > Well why don't we?
          > > >
          > > > Michael
          > > >
          > > > > -----Original Message-----
          > > > > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@a...]
          > > > > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 1:18
          > > >
          > > > would be fun to get together with someone and bang out a story.
          > > eddie
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >
          > >

          > >
          > >
          > >
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18070 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: POTA weapons
          .html
          --- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
          > >--- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
          > >>>Yet Heston could have declined to play the part, had he had
          > >>>any qualms about the thematic content of the film. Although
          > >>>Heston
          > >>
          > >> And would that happen before or after your pole-shifted
          > >>Australia moves to the northern hemisphere?
          > >
          > >***Would WHAT happen? Heston's decision to appear in
          POTA?
          > >That'd be in, oh, what was it? about 1966-7...? I don't quite
          know
          > >what kinda point you're trying to make here, Morgoth...
          > >
          > >Patrick
          >
          > Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
          roles they are
          > performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
          roles that are
          > different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
          Greatest Hits. But
          > maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
          the patriotic
          > schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
          maybe Heston wants the
          > same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
          Maybe actors never
          > play characters who are different than them...and maybe
          Australia will
          > "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
          happen in the
          > Patrick universe.

          *** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
          the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
          What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
          do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
          politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
          For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
          Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
          that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
          Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
          Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
          didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
          philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
          Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see myself
          supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
          could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
          Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
          was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
          could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
          a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
          own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
          OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
          do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
          or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
          Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
          I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
          of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.

          Patrick Michael Tilton
          EARTH-TIME 6-15-2002
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18071 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          --- In pota@y..., "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@i...> wrote:
          > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the
          land was
          > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an
          entrance
          > to the underground passageways.
          >
          > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants could
          easily
          > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental
          powers
          > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
          > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
          >
          > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet until I
          saw
          > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it
          almost
          > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet
          already
          > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with
          annoying,
          > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork
          for
          > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I think
          it's
          > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock
          and
          > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
          >
          > ABMAC

          *** Heyyyy!!! A word I coined is now in use! "Unflub" lives!
          Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
          unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't they
          make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
          were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
          there leading to the "city of the dead", then Mendez & Co. are safe
          and sound. Or... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
          other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
          possibilities...

          Patrick
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18072 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
          .html
          --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
          > In a message dated 6/14/2002 12:47:42 PM Central Standard
          Time,
          > LordTZer0@A... writes:
          >
          >
          > >
          > > >>
          > >
          > >
          >
          > I agree with T on this one. I picture Milo being a bit of a
          "renegade" when
          > it comes to scientific matters. He probably just went about
          trying to
          > discover the ships (possible) existance without the permission
          of the
          > Acadamy. That or he went in under false pretenses, saying he
          was searching
          > for one thing while secretly trying to uncover the ship.

          *** How's this for an idea?
          Cornelius went into the Forbidden Zone WITH Milo (who helped
          him to build the causeway leading up to the Cave, etc.); Milo later
          on rides further along the coastline (after Cornelius goes back to
          Ape City) and sees not only the Statue of Liberty but ALSO finds
          "on our seaboard" (as Cornelius later tells the Presidential
          Commission) the ANSA ship with 3 seats, which 3 unknown
          astronauts had landed just a little bit earlier (hell, maybe he even
          sees the landing!)...
          I doubt if he took parts from Brent's ship to "patch up" Taylor's
          dredged-up ship, since the Bomb blows the planet up only about
          a week (at the most) after Brent crashlands the thing. Not really
          enough time to scoot over to the site, yank out usable
          doohickeys, and get back to the other ship & install 'em in time to
          take off...

          Patrick
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18073 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          .html--- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > So is the timeline circular or does it change after Cornelius and
          Zira
          > travel back with Milo?
          >
          > Michael

          In a message dated 6/15/2002 10:18:13 AM Central Standard Time, epowe10097@... writes:

          the timeline changes but not because of zira and cornelius' travel.
          their travel created the original timeline. it changes because of
          another time traveler.
          the whole idea (besides trying to tie
          disparate apes stories together) was to suggest (as i believed at the
          time) that history's details can be changed but fate (if you want to
          call it that) will always deliver the same outcome when you look at
          the broad picture. eddie

          We covered the circular vs. new timeline in here before, but I'm telling you, the Ape-o-nauts arrival in "our time" starts the 2nd (i.e NEW) timeline. I think there is no way that their arrival created the original timeline. I don't see how it is at all possible. They come from the original one, how can they possibly create it?

          And who is this "other" time traveller that is supposed to have changed the timeline?
          <.html
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18074 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: POTA Toons
          .html
          As for the 'toons, Alex, try to put them chronological:

          1. Flames of Doom
          2. Escape From Ape City
          3. Unearthly Prophecy
          4. Tunnel of Fear
          5. Lagoon of Peril
          6. Terror on Ice Mnt.
          7. River of Flames
          8. Screaming Wings
          9. Trail to the Unknown
          10. Attack from the Clouds
          11. Mission of mercy
          12. Invasion of the Underdwellers
          13. Battle of the Titans Etc.

          - - - Jeff

          Okay, I'm now capturing and placing these episodes in order.
          This is the same order as my Video Tapes, so that's good. Strangely the
          order in The Planet of the Apes CHRONICLES (the book) is out of order.

          I may place up to 9 episodes in DVD 1 and 4 episodes in DVD 2, which will
          give me some extra space in DVD 2 to add some more POTA goodies. :o)

          Best.
          Al


          _____
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18075 From: Melkor Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Extended Battle DVD came
          .html
          Thanks to Alex I got my Extended Battle DVD today. Excellent! This is now my
          favorite DVD. The music CD is cool too I just finished listening to all of it.

          -Tom


          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18076 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] POTA Toons
          .html
          I know that copyright issues prevent you from considering it, but it
          would be appropriate to have "A Fish Called Selma" and "Planet of the
          NRApes" with the other cartoons.

          ABMAC

          On Saturday, June 15, 2002, at 12:51 PM, Calima 5021 wrote:

          > I may place up to 9 episodes in DVD 1 and 4 episodes in DVD 2, which
          > will
          > give me some extra space in DVD 2 to add some more POTA goodies. :o)
          >
          > Best.
          > Al
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18077 From: mlccougar@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Mutant's illusions
          .html
          .htmlIn a message dated 6/15/2002 11:57:45 AM Central Standard Time, patrickmichaeltilton@... writes:


          Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
          unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't they
          make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
          were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
          there leading to the "city of the dead," then Mendez & Co. are safe
          and sound. Or ... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
          other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
          possibilities...

          Patrick


          I always figured that since they knew the Apes (well, Zaius anyway), seen thru their illusions, they knew it was pointless to even try to use them anymore. Their "weapons" were proven to be useless (Zaius proved "The vision was false...") OK now, that doesn't mean that had they tried other things to scare them off that that wouldn't have worked, but "maybe" since they knew their illusions were proven to be false once, they might have figured the soldiers would have just blindly attacked anything. I'm not setting here saying that is the case, or even that this is chiseled in stone as to what I think on this subject.... But I'd lean towards these thoughts.

          And this is just pure speculation, but "maybe" in a panic (knowing the enemy is on the way) their abilities to throw up these visions or do mind control is weak, if existent at all. I'd kind of guess they can only do them when they feel they are in control of the situation and they are totally concentrating on doing them. I mean look, Ongaro's concentration was broke when he heard  Nova mumble out "Taylor" and then his mind control over Brent and Taylor was broken, giving them the ability to kill him since he no longer had control over them. Imagine a group of scared mutants trying to concentrate on projecting illusions to an army of 100's of armed gorillas, it may not happen. If a savage human girl can break the mind control of a highly developed mind controller, do you think that a group of illusions projected by scared mutants would even hold? My guess would be no. They'd be weak (un-holdable) illusions, if they'd be able to project them at all.
          <.html
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18078 From: epowe_2000 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
          .html
          me and michael were talking about a story I HAD WRITTEN. the person
          was in that story. nothing official. how cornelius and zira can
          create their timeline is all part of how one views time travel. not
          saying you are right or wrong, but tt has always been an area that
          people have taken different outlooks on. i.e. the same possiblities
          in back to the future 2 (michael j. fox being able to be in the same
          time period as another one of himselves) is not the logic shared by
          many other films. it's all in how you perceive time travel to begin
          with. eddie



          --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
          > --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
          > > So is the timeline circular or does it change after Cornelius and
          > Zira
          > > travel back with Milo?
          > >
          > > Michael
          >
          > In a message dated 6/15/2002 10:18:13 AM Central Standard Time,
          > epowe10097@a... writes:
          > >
          > > the timeline changes but not because of zira and cornelius'
          travel.
          > > their travel created the original timeline. it changes because of
          > > another time traveler. the whole idea (besides trying to tie
          > > disparate apes stories together) was to suggest (as i believed at
          the
          > > time) that history's details can be changed but fate (if you want
          to
          > > call it that) will always deliver the same outcome when you look
          at
          > > the broad picture. eddie
          > >
          > We covered the circular vs. new timeline in here before, but I'm
          telling you,
          > the Ape-o-nauts arrival in "our time" starts the 2nd (i.e NEW)
          timeline. I
          > think there is no way that their arrival created the original
          timeline. I
          > don't see how it is at all possible. They come from the original
          one, how can
          > they possibly create it?
          >
          > And who is this "other" time traveller that is supposed to have
          changed the
          > timeline?
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18079 From: Melkor Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: POTA weapons
          .html
          Acting in roles that are different than you and have different views is
          considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that anyone thought
          much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was doing POTA,
          including Heston himself.

          Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is Heston "selling
          out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes around mocking
          the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for a liberal utopia.
          Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that Heston must have the
          same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably would have turned down
          the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's political views and his
          professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this than don't.

          Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play characters with
          different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be renamed "New
          America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities too. Anything
          goes in the Patrick universe.


          >> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
          >roles they are
          >> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
          >roles that are
          >> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
          >Greatest Hits. But
          >> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
          >the patriotic
          >> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
          >maybe Heston wants the
          >> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
          >Maybe actors never
          >> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
          >Australia will
          >> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
          >happen in the
          >> Patrick universe.
          >
          >*** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
          >the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
          >What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
          >do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
          >politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
          >For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
          >Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
          >that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
          >Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
          >Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
          >didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
          >philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
          >Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see myself
          >supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
          >could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
          >Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
          >was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
          >could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
          >a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
          >own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
          >OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
          >do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
          >or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
          >Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
          >I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
          >of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.




          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18080 From: Anthony B. McElveen Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
          .html
          This is addressed to everyone involved in this debate:

          You're assuming that Heston's views differ from Taylor's. When,
          specifically, do Taylor's actions go against Heston's views?

          Taylor doesn't mock patriotism, he mocks misplaced patriotism. He
          doesn't criticize conservatives, he criticizes censorship and
          oppression. He isn't looking for a liberal utopia, he's looking for a
          place where reason prevails. Reason is not the exclusive domain of
          liberals.

          He doesn't want a gun because it's his right, he wants one because he
          can't count on the chimps to kill other apes for his protection.

          What would Taylor have done differently if he'd had Heston's views?

          ABMAC

          On Saturday, June 15, 2002, at 01:27 PM, Melkor wrote:

          > Acting in roles that are different than you and have different views is
          > considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that anyone
          > thought
          > much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was doing
          > POTA,
          > including Heston himself.
          >
          > Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is Heston
          > "selling
          > out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes around
          > mocking
          > the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for a liberal
          > utopia.
          > Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that Heston must
          > have the
          > same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably would have
          > turned down
          > the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's political views and his
          > professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this than don't.
          >
          > Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play characters
          > with
          > different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be renamed
          > "New
          > America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities too.
          > Anything
          > goes in the Patrick universe.
          >
          >
          >>> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
          >> roles they are
          >>> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
          >> roles that are
          >>> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
          >> Greatest Hits. But
          >>> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
          >> the patriotic
          >>> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
          >> maybe Heston wants the
          >>> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
          >> Maybe actors never
          >>> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
          >> Australia will
          >>> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
          >> happen in the
          >>> Patrick universe.
          >>
          >> *** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
          >> the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
          >> What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
          >> do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
          >> politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
          >> For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
          >> Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
          >> that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
          >> Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
          >> Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
          >> didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
          >> philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
          >> Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see
          >> myself
          >> supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
          >> could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
          >> Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
          >> was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
          >> could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
          >> a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
          >> own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
          >> OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
          >> do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
          >> or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
          >> Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
          >> I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
          >> of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
          <.html
          Group: pota Message: 18081 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
          Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Extended Battle DVD came
          .html
          Attachments :
            Cool to hear.

            Enjoy.
            Al


            >From: "Melkor" <melkor@...>
            >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
            >To: pota@yahoogroups.com
            >Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Extended Battle DVD came
            >Date: Sat, 15 Jun 2002 11:16:16 -0700
            >




            _____
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18082 From: james611102 Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
            .html
            Well said Anthony. I've always seen Taylor as a cynic who was
            disgusted with both the right and the left.


            --- In pota@y..., "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@i...> wrote:
            > This is addressed to everyone involved in this debate:
            >
            > You're assuming that Heston's views differ from Taylor's. When,
            > specifically, do Taylor's actions go against Heston's views?
            >
            > Taylor doesn't mock patriotism, he mocks misplaced patriotism. He
            > doesn't criticize conservatives, he criticizes censorship and
            > oppression. He isn't looking for a liberal utopia, he's looking
            for a
            > place where reason prevails. Reason is not the exclusive domain of
            > liberals.
            >
            > He doesn't want a gun because it's his right, he wants one because
            he
            > can't count on the chimps to kill other apes for his protection.
            >
            > What would Taylor have done differently if he'd had Heston's views?
            >
            > ABMAC
            >
            > On Saturday, June 15, 2002, at 01:27 PM, Melkor wrote:
            >
            > > Acting in roles that are different than you and have different
            views is
            > > considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that
            anyone
            > > thought
            > > much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was
            doing
            > > POTA,
            > > including Heston himself.
            > >
            > > Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is
            Heston
            > > "selling
            > > out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes
            around
            > > mocking
            > > the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for a
            liberal
            > > utopia.
            > > Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that Heston
            must
            > > have the
            > > same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably would
            have
            > > turned down
            > > the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's political views
            and his
            > > professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this than don't.
            > >
            > > Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play
            characters
            > > with
            > > different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be
            renamed
            > > "New
            > > America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities
            too.
            > > Anything
            > > goes in the Patrick universe.
            > >
            > >
            > >>> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
            > >> roles they are
            > >>> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
            > >> roles that are
            > >>> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
            > >> Greatest Hits. But
            > >>> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
            > >> the patriotic
            > >>> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
            > >> maybe Heston wants the
            > >>> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
            > >> Maybe actors never
            > >>> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
            > >> Australia will
            > >>> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
            > >> happen in the
            > >>> Patrick universe.
            > >>
            > >> *** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that
            Heston
            > >> the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
            > >> What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
            > >> do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
            > >> politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
            > >> For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
            > >> Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to
            it
            > >> that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
            > >> Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
            > >> Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
            > >> didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
            > >> philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
            > >> Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I
            see
            > >> myself
            > >> supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like
            that). I
            > >> could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the
            3rd
            > >> Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
            > >> was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
            > >> could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
            > >> a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
            > >> own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
            > >> OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
            > >> do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its
            politics,
            > >> or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-
            out" his
            > >> Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
            > >> I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this
            sort
            > >> of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18083 From: james611102 Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
            .html
            We have covered it before and it is really open to individual
            interpetation. There is no real right or wrong way to look at it
            since the filmmakers left things very open at the end of Battle.


            --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
            > We covered the circular vs. new timeline in here before, but I'm
            telling you,
            > the Ape-o-nauts arrival in "our time" starts the 2nd (i.e NEW)
            timeline. I
            > think there is no way that their arrival created the original
            timeline. I
            > don't see how it is at all possible. They come from the original
            one, how can
            > they possibly create it?
            >
            > And who is this "other" time traveller that is supposed to have
            changed the
            > timeline?
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18084 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
            .html
            Dave,

            I agree he needs to find it almost IMMEDIATELY to allow him to become a
            rocket scientist.

            That's why I think the idea of him having discovered another well preserved
            ship (pr more than one) many years ago makes a lot of sense. He could have
            taken years to research, even built a few prototype flying machines (or
            models thereof) shunned by Zauis (and explaining better Zaius fear of
            intelligent humans).

            Michael

            > -----Original Message-----
            > From: smugster2000 [4print@...]
            > Sent: Saturday, 15 June 2002 22:43
            > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
            > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
            >
            >
            > --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
            >
            > > The only thing, I always kind of thought in my mind that
            > Cornelius and Zira
            > > knew Milo for some time, like maybe Cornelius went to school
            > with him or
            > > something of that nature. And also in my mind, I always kinda
            > thought that
            > > Milo came upon his knowledge of the ship from conversations
            > with those
            > > "heretic" friends of his. I was under the impression that
            > Cornelius/Zira told
            > > him of what Taylor said, things like the location of the crash,
            > etc.. and
            > > then Milo went about to see if this was true... But that was in my
            > mind, I
            > > don't know what others think, but your ideas pretty much "work"
            > for me. I
            > > think I'd "maybe" only change that part of it. I'd maybe change it
            > to Milo's
            > > discovering of the ship after having discussions with his
            > friends
            > > "discovered" this curious talking human...
            >
            > Although I haven't thought about this story for a long time I do
            > remember the biggest headache when I was mapping it out was
            > a question of TIME... How much elapses between Taylor landing
            > and the planet exploding.?
            >
            > So how long between the crash landing and Taylors capture?
            > How long does it take his throat to heal and start speaking? (He
            > makes a reference to "It's been weeks" just before the trial. How
            > long does he wander around in the Forbidden zone before
            > capture by the mutants? How long is he in captivity before Brent
            > arrives?
            >
            > I think I made the decision to allow Milo to find the ship as early
            > as possible to allow him as much time as possible to discover
            > its secrets.
            >
            > I think I still have what little I did wrtie on file - If anyone
            > wants it
            > email me privately and I'll pass it on.
            >
            > Dave
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18085 From: Michael Whitty Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
            .html
            That's exactly right but the more I think about it the more I believe Zira
            and Corn set a NEW timeline. You sure can still argue that the outcome will
            still be the same in 3955,but with different variables causing it.

            Michael

            > -----Original Message-----
            > From: epowe_2000 [epowe10097@...]
            > Sent: Sunday, 16 June 2002 4:25
            > To: pota@yahoogroups.com
            > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
            >
            >
            > me and michael were talking about a story I HAD WRITTEN. the person
            > was in that story. nothing official. how cornelius and zira can
            > create their timeline is all part of how one views time travel. not
            > saying you are right or wrong, but tt has always been an area that
            > people have taken different outlooks on. i.e. the same possiblities
            > in back to the future 2 (michael j. fox being able to be in the same
            > time period as another one of himselves) is not the logic shared by
            > many other films. it's all in how you perceive time travel to begin
            > with. eddie
            >
            >
            >
            > --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
            > > --- In pota@y..., "Michael Whitty" <whitty@c...> wrote:
            > > > So is the timeline circular or does it change after Cornelius and
            > > Zira
            > > > travel back with Milo?
            > > >
            > > > Michael
            > >
            > > In a message dated 6/15/2002 10:18:13 AM Central Standard Time,
            > > epowe10097@a... writes:
            > > >
            > > > the timeline changes but not because of zira and cornelius'
            > travel.
            > > > their travel created the original timeline. it changes because of
            > > > another time traveler. the whole idea (besides trying to tie
            > > > disparate apes stories together) was to suggest (as i believed at
            > the
            > > > time) that history's details can be changed but fate (if you want
            > to
            > > > call it that) will always deliver the same outcome when you look
            > at
            > > > the broad picture. eddie
            > > >
            > > We covered the circular vs. new timeline in here before, but I'm
            > telling you,
            > > the Ape-o-nauts arrival in "our time" starts the 2nd (i.e NEW)
            > timeline. I
            > > think there is no way that their arrival created the original
            > timeline. I
            > > don't see how it is at all possible. They come from the original
            > one, how can
            > > they possibly create it?
            > >
            > > And who is this "other" time traveller that is supposed to have
            > changed the
            > > timeline?
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            >
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18086 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: Toons is a Bust
            .html
            Toons is a Bust.
            I've been all day today behind my computer trying to squeeze 13 freaken
            episodes in to two dvd discs. The final equation is that I can't. 13 30 min.
            episodes will have to go on 3 dvd discs which is too much money and trouble
            to do. DVD Blanks are still to expensive and burning 3 DVDs for one request
            or order is 3 hours alone.

            So I'm sad to say that Toons is a Bust, if the cost and burning time to make
            where lower, I wouldn't mind at all, but 3 hours alone to burn one set is a
            little too much. So, for all who requested Toons, looks like Battle UNcut
            will be it. Sorry gang, I tried.

            I'll start work on Jeff's Exclusive stuff next weekend along with more
            televised POTA Classic Stuff to create one very cool POTA Classic DVD. That
            one will be sold at $10 each with half going to, Jeff for Ape Chronicles.

            I'll start shipping out Battle UNcut monday, for all who requested toons,
            along with my Apes Music CD of course.

            Again, I'm sorry, but I tried.

            Best.
            Al





            _____
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18087 From: CheeseGOTAS@aol.com Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
            .html
            In a message dated 6/15/02 11:08:27 PM Central Daylight Time,
            calima5021com@... writes:

            << Again, I'm sorry, but I tried.

            Best.
            Al >>

            That's no problem, man. It was very great of you to actually try and do this
            for the group. I understand that DVDs are expensive, so, atleast you tried.
            So, will you still be offering the toons for sale later as 3 DVDs for maybe
            15 or 20 dollars? Anyway, thanks again for trying.

            -Joe
            <.html
            Group: pota Message: 18088 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/15/2002
            Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
            .html
            Attachments :
              Well, the issue isn't money, because DVD blanks are as low as 3.50 each. And
              of course there going to get a lot cheaper. It's time. 3 hours to burn a 3
              disc set is a long time. So I doubt I'll ever offer it at all, just due to
              that.

              Best.
              Al



              >From: CheeseGOTAS@...
              >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
              >To: pota@yahoogroups.com
              >Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
              >Date: Sun, 16 Jun 2002 00:42:35 EDT
              >




              _____
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18089 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
              .html
              As a matter of fact, Right-winger Gary Oldman got into a big public battle
              with "The Contender" director because he felt the character changed under
              the influence of Dreamworks founder Steven Spielberg. Oldman felt his
              character became too ridiculous and one note, I think because of
              postproduction choices. The director, Rod Lurie, was a film critic here in
              L.A. in the late '90's and he set up these special screenings. I met James
              Cameron at a "Titanic" at one and he gave me some quotes about his plans
              for POTA that Greene used in his book. I like Rod as a person and respect
              his movie opinions, but I've been disappointed with his movies so far.
              Actually I 've only seen "The Contender" but I hear "The Last Castle" wasn't
              too good. He's still in a preachy stage. Etc. - - Jeff


              ----- Original Message -----
              From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@...>
              To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
              Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 8:41 AM
              Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons


              > --- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
              > > >--- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
              > > >>>Yet Heston could have declined to play the part, had he had
              > > >>>any qualms about the thematic content of the film. Although
              > > >>>Heston
              > > >>
              > > >> And would that happen before or after your pole-shifted
              > > >>Australia moves to the northern hemisphere?
              > > >
              > > >***Would WHAT happen? Heston's decision to appear in
              > POTA?
              > > >That'd be in, oh, what was it? about 1966-7...? I don't quite
              > know
              > > >what kinda point you're trying to make here, Morgoth...
              > > >
              > > >Patrick
              > >
              > > Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
              > roles they are
              > > performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
              > roles that are
              > > different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
              > Greatest Hits. But
              > > maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
              > the patriotic
              > > schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
              > maybe Heston wants the
              > > same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
              > Maybe actors never
              > > play characters who are different than them...and maybe
              > Australia will
              > > "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
              > happen in the
              > > Patrick universe.
              >
              > *** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
              > the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
              > What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
              > do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
              > politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
              > For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
              > Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
              > that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
              > Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
              > Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
              > didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
              > philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
              > Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see myself
              > supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
              > could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
              > Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
              > was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
              > could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
              > a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
              > own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
              > OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
              > do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
              > or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
              > Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
              > I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
              > of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
              >
              > Patrick Michael Tilton
              > EARTH-TIME 6-15-2002
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18090 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              .html
              The point is made that the apes "are too dumb to hold our illusions" after
              Zauis doesn't buy the burning Lawgiver. If not, it would've been a pretty
              boring ending. ("There's nothing here, Ursus. Let's go home.").
              I've been reading Pendreigh's great "Legend of POTA" book. It mentions that
              everybody but Michael Wilson wanted Heston to die at the end of "Planet".
              Jacobs, Abrahams, everybody. But Wilson fought it, saying it would diminish
              the ending. If Heston had died:
              a) would it be possible the film wouldn't have been as successful?
              b) they would've had much more freedom in "Beneath" storywise
              Etc. - - - Jeff


              ----- Original Message -----
              From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@...>
              To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
              Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 9:13 AM
              Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath


              > --- In pota@y..., "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@i...> wrote:
              > > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the
              > land was
              > > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an
              > entrance
              > > to the underground passageways.
              > >
              > > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants could
              > easily
              > > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental
              > powers
              > > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
              > > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
              > >
              > > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet until I
              > saw
              > > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it
              > almost
              > > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet
              > already
              > > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with
              > annoying,
              > > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork
              > for
              > > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I think
              > it's
              > > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock
              > and
              > > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
              > >
              > > ABMAC
              >
              > *** Heyyyy!!! A word I coined is now in use! "Unflub" lives!
              > Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
              > unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't they
              > make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
              > were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
              > there leading to the "city of the dead", then Mendez & Co. are safe
              > and sound. Or... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
              > other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
              > possibilities...
              >
              > Patrick
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18091 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do
              .html
              Just as much time as Zira and Cornelius have to watch the ape army from
              their home, then scoot to Taylor's ship.
              - - Jeff


              ----- Original Message -----
              From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@...>
              To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
              Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 9:23 AM
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do


              > --- In pota@y..., mlccougar@a... wrote:
              > > In a message dated 6/14/2002 12:47:42 PM Central Standard
              > Time,
              > > LordTZer0@A... writes:
              > >
              > >
              > > >
              > > > >>
              > > >
              > > >
              > >
              > > I agree with T on this one. I picture Milo being a bit of a
              > "renegade" when
              > > it comes to scientific matters. He probably just went about
              > trying to
              > > discover the ships (possible) existance without the permission
              > of the
              > > Acadamy. That or he went in under false pretenses, saying he
              > was searching
              > > for one thing while secretly trying to uncover the ship.
              >
              > *** How's this for an idea?
              > Cornelius went into the Forbidden Zone WITH Milo (who helped
              > him to build the causeway leading up to the Cave, etc.); Milo later
              > on rides further along the coastline (after Cornelius goes back to
              > Ape City) and sees not only the Statue of Liberty but ALSO finds
              > "on our seaboard" (as Cornelius later tells the Presidential
              > Commission) the ANSA ship with 3 seats, which 3 unknown
              > astronauts had landed just a little bit earlier (hell, maybe he even
              > sees the landing!)...
              > I doubt if he took parts from Brent's ship to "patch up" Taylor's
              > dredged-up ship, since the Bomb blows the planet up only about
              > a week (at the most) after Brent crashlands the thing. Not really
              > enough time to scoot over to the site, yank out usable
              > doohickeys, and get back to the other ship & install 'em in time to
              > take off...
              >
              > Patrick
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18092 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mutant's illusions
              .html
              .html
                It might be, too, they're running out of time and have to get their bomb ready. Certainly they can't let the apes win. Better to blow up the world. Of course, this "If I can't have it, no one can" attitude is pure science fiction. In the real world people aren't that selfish. Right? Etc.                                            - - - Jeff
               
               
              ----- Original Message -----
              Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 11:24 AM
              Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Mutant's illusions

              In a message dated 6/15/2002 11:57:45 AM Central Standard Time, patrickmichaeltilton@... writes:


              Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
              unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't they
              make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
              were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
              there leading to the "city of the dead," then Mendez & Co. are safe
              and sound. Or ... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
              other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
              possibilities...

              Patrick


              I always figured that since they knew the Apes (well, Zaius anyway), seen thru their illusions, they knew it was pointless to even try to use them anymore. Their "weapons" were proven to be useless (Zaius proved "The vision was false...") OK now, that doesn't mean that had they tried other things to scare them off that that wouldn't have worked, but "maybe" since they knew their illusions were proven to be false once, they might have figured the soldiers would have just blindly attacked anything. I'm not setting here saying that is the case, or even that this is chiseled in stone as to what I think on this subject.... But I'd lean towards these thoughts.

              And this is just pure speculation, but "maybe" in a panic (knowing the enemy is on the way) their abilities to throw up these visions or do mind control is weak, if existent at all. I'd kind of guess they can only do them when they feel they are in control of the situation and they are totally concentrating on doing them. I mean look, Ongaro's concentration was broke when he heard  Nova mumble out "Taylor" and then his mind control over Brent and Taylor was broken, giving them the ability to kill him since he no longer had control over them. Imagine a group of scared mutants trying to concentrate on projecting illusions to an army of 100's of armed gorillas, it may not happen. If a savage human girl can break the mind control of a highly developed mind controller, do you think that a group of illusions projected by scared mutants would even hold? My guess would be no. They'd be weak (un-holdable) illusions, if they'd be able to project them at all.


              <.html
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18093 From: veetus@earthlink.net Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons
              .html
              Heston has said he liked the role because of the character arc, a
              misanthrope who winds up defending mankind. And to this day he says he's
              proud of the movie. In fact I just read in the Pendreigh book that Heston
              felt Taylor was more like him than any other character he's played. So
              perhaps there's more to it than surface considerations.
              - - - Jeff


              ----- Original Message -----
              From: "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@...>
              To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
              Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 12:36 PM
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: POTA weapons


              > This is addressed to everyone involved in this debate:
              >
              > You're assuming that Heston's views differ from Taylor's. When,
              > specifically, do Taylor's actions go against Heston's views?
              >
              > Taylor doesn't mock patriotism, he mocks misplaced patriotism. He
              > doesn't criticize conservatives, he criticizes censorship and
              > oppression. He isn't looking for a liberal utopia, he's looking for a
              > place where reason prevails. Reason is not the exclusive domain of
              > liberals.
              >
              > He doesn't want a gun because it's his right, he wants one because he
              > can't count on the chimps to kill other apes for his protection.
              >
              > What would Taylor have done differently if he'd had Heston's views?
              >
              > ABMAC
              >
              > On Saturday, June 15, 2002, at 01:27 PM, Melkor wrote:
              >
              > > Acting in roles that are different than you and have different views is
              > > considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that anyone
              > > thought
              > > much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was doing
              > > POTA,
              > > including Heston himself.
              > >
              > > Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is Heston
              > > "selling
              > > out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes around
              > > mocking
              > > the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for a liberal
              > > utopia.
              > > Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that Heston must
              > > have the
              > > same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably would have
              > > turned down
              > > the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's political views and his
              > > professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this than don't.
              > >
              > > Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play characters
              > > with
              > > different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be renamed
              > > "New
              > > America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities too.
              > > Anything
              > > goes in the Patrick universe.
              > >
              > >
              > >>> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
              > >> roles they are
              > >>> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
              > >> roles that are
              > >>> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
              > >> Greatest Hits. But
              > >>> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
              > >> the patriotic
              > >>> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
              > >> maybe Heston wants the
              > >>> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
              > >> Maybe actors never
              > >>> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
              > >> Australia will
              > >>> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
              > >> happen in the
              > >>> Patrick universe.
              > >>
              > >> *** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
              > >> the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
              > >> What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
              > >> do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
              > >> politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
              > >> For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
              > >> Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
              > >> that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
              > >> Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
              > >> Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
              > >> didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
              > >> philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
              > >> Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see
              > >> myself
              > >> supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
              > >> could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
              > >> Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
              > >> was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
              > >> could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
              > >> a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
              > >> own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
              > >> OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
              > >> do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
              > >> or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
              > >> Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
              > >> I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
              > >> of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18094 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Last attempt
              .html
              I'm making one last attempt at this two disc toon set.
              Made a few adjustments, and hopefuly this will work.
              I'll let you guys know in the morning what happened. Hopefuly my computer
              won't explode! :o)

              Let's pray to the Lawgiver this works.
              Pray your asses off. :o)

              annnnnd...GO!

              Best.
              Al

              P.S. OH AND, HAPPY DAD DAY EVERYONE! :o)



              _____
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18095 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: Last attempt
              .html
              we can only ask for your best try!! good luck!! :)


              --- In pota@y..., "Calima 5021" <calima5021com@m...> wrote:
              >
              > I'm making one last attempt at this two disc toon set.
              > Made a few adjustments, and hopefuly this will work.
              > I'll let you guys know in the morning what happened. Hopefuly my
              computer
              > won't explode! :o)
              >
              > Let's pray to the Lawgiver this works.
              > Pray your asses off. :o)
              >
              > annnnnd...GO!
              >
              > Best.
              > Al
              >
              > P.S. OH AND, HAPPY DAD DAY EVERYONE! :o)
              >
              >
              >
              > _____
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18096 From: thypentacle Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Toons is a Bust
              .html

              That's cool with me. :o)

                Calima 5021 <calima5021com@...> wrote:


              Toons is a Bust.
              I've been all day today behind my computer trying to squeeze 13 freaken
              episodes in to two dvd discs. The final equation is that I can't. 13 30 min.
              episodes will have to go on 3 dvd discs which is too much money and trouble
              to do. DVD Blanks are still to expensive and burning 3 DVDs for one request
              or order is 3 hours alone.

              So I'm sad to say that Toons is a Bust, if the cost and burning time to make
              where lower, I wouldn't mind at all, but 3 hours alone to burn one set is a
              little too much. So, for all who requested Toons, looks like Battle UNcut
              will be it. Sorry gang, I tried.

              I'll start work on Jeff's Exclusive stuff next weekend along with more
              televised POTA Classic Stuff to create one very cool POTA Classic DVD. That
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18097 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              .html
              I think if Heston had died it would have been just as successful. If
              they wanted Heston to die when would it have happened?? after the
              discovery of the Statue of liberty??

              Also by Heston not dying I think it made Beneath all the more
              interesting. Sure they could have gone off in another direction but
              it was great in my opinion to see him still alive near the end of
              the film.

              --- In pota@y..., <veetus@e...> wrote:
              > The point is made that the apes "are too dumb to hold our
              illusions" after
              > Zauis doesn't buy the burning Lawgiver. If not, it would've been a
              pretty
              > boring ending. ("There's nothing here, Ursus. Let's go home.").
              > I've been reading Pendreigh's great "Legend of POTA" book. It
              mentions that
              > everybody but Michael Wilson wanted Heston to die at the end
              of "Planet".
              > Jacobs, Abrahams, everybody. But Wilson fought it, saying it would
              diminish
              > the ending. If Heston had died:
              > a) would it be possible the film wouldn't have been as successful?
              > b) they would've had much more freedom in "Beneath" storywise
              > Etc. - - - Jeff
              >
              >
              > ----- Original Message -----
              > From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@y...>
              > To: <pota@y...>
              > Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 9:13 AM
              > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              >
              >
              > > --- In pota@y..., "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@i...> wrote:
              > > > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the
              > > land was
              > > > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an
              > > entrance
              > > > to the underground passageways.
              > > >
              > > > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants
              could
              > > easily
              > > > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental
              > > powers
              > > > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
              > > > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
              > > >
              > > > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet
              until I
              > > saw
              > > > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it
              > > almost
              > > > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet
              > > already
              > > > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with
              > > annoying,
              > > > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork
              > > for
              > > > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I
              think
              > > it's
              > > > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock
              > > and
              > > > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
              > > >
              > > > ABMAC
              > >
              > > *** Heyyyy!!! A word I coined is now in use! "Unflub" lives!
              > > Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
              > > unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't
              they
              > > make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
              > > were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
              > > there leading to the "city of the dead", then Mendez & Co. are
              safe
              > > and sound. Or... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
              > > other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
              > > possibilities...
              > >
              > > Patrick
              > >
              > >
              > >
              > >
              > >
              > >
              > >

              > >
              > >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18098 From: cgenro Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: what came after Battle...
              .html
              does anyone have any idea what occured after Battle?? what caused
              the humans do de-evolve and become savages? With Ceaser being a kind
              leader who was tolerant to humans what happened that caused the Apes
              to hate the humans again?

              sorry for all the questions. I`ve just seen the movies for the first
              time last week and I thought they were great!! :)
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18099 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] What would you do?
              .html
              "Michael Whitty" <whitty@...> wrote:
              > Agreed Alan, but I would suggest one more criterion: the creators
              are
              > familiar with the apes saga and adhere to established convention (as
              much as
              > they contradict each other anyway).

              I don't know about that - ignoring some aspects altogether and just
              putting forth alternative stories that are based on Planet of the Apes
              would be quite interesting. For example, someone might decide they'd
              love to have a story set within the Planet of the Apes mythology, but
              featuring vampires or something like that (because let's face it, if
              anyone's going to survive a nuclear war, it's good old Dracula).

              Alternatively, what about a series of "what if" stories that show how
              Planet of the Apes might have produced a very different story if just
              one or two minor details had turned out differently. What if...

              ...Stewart hadn't died?
              ...Landon hadn't been lobotomised?
              ...Taylor's ship had actually achieved a perfect landing instead of
              crashing, leaving a perfectly intact ship for him to return to?
              ...Nova had been pregnant after all?
              ...apes and mutants hadn't destroyed the Earth, but started a bloody
              civil war instead? And what if Brent and Taylor had survived?
              ...Cornelius and Zira had been killed while Milo survived?
              ...Caesar never made it to the city?
              ...Armando had lived?

              And so on.

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18100 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] New Ape Toys: SPACE OF THE APES!
              .html
              "mystic4ever" <mystic4ever@...> wrote:
              >Has anyone else out there seen these? I saw the display for the
              first time >today for these SPACE OF THE APES figures.

              Weird. Bizarre. I like them! I've always liked the more bizarre Planet
              of the Apes tie-ins and rip-offs, and these are right up there next to
              the "Apes Attack" figures. They wouldn't have looked out of place in
              the old Terror strip!

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18101 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              .html
              "smugster2000" <4print@...> wrote:
              > A long time ago (But not so far away) I decided to try and write a
              > stroy that filled in the 'gap' between Planet and Beneath - this was
              > before I realised I couldn't write for sh*t.

              Hey, I remember reading the first chapter and really enjoying it. And
              it looks to me like it was only going to get more interesting. I found
              the outline pretty enjoyable, it's a shame you never continued it.

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18102 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Mexico in the TV series
              .html
              "Eileen Rankin" <emr1623@...> wrote:
              >Did the humans and apes exist elsewhere outside of the US?
              > When this topic was brought up, my immediate thought was
              >what if the story took place in, say, Hong Kong? Would we
              >get something like those old martial arts movies with the
              >bad voice overs? Now that would be cool!!! LOL

              So you've not seen "Time of the Apes" then...?

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18103 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              .html
              "Jeff & Susan Stringer" <stringe@...> wrote:
              > It could use some refining, but like that. Especially the bit
              about
              > salvaging parts from one ship for the other. Still doesn't say HOW
              Milo
              > found Taylors's SUNKEN ship, but anyway.

              One theory is that perhaps there was an earthquake of some
              description, just powerful enough to divert the water in another
              direction (or swallow it all up like a sink), which would then leave
              the ship lying exposed on what was once the floor of the lake.

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18104 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] what came after Battle...
              .html
              "cgenro" <cgenro@...> wrote:
              > does anyone have any idea what occured after Battle?? what caused
              > the humans do de-evolve and become savages? With Ceaser being a kind
              > leader who was tolerant to humans what happened that caused the Apes
              > to hate the humans again?

              Perhaps some kind of plague that only affected humans - leaving them
              brain damaged in some way, causing them to revert back to their
              primitive state (and presumably some kind of immunity would be enjoyed
              by the mutants due to their altered genetic make-up). From here they
              would resort to savage animal-like behaviour (as seen in the first
              film) which would lead the apes hating them due to their pest-like
              qualities of destroying Ape crops in their hunt for food.

              Alan
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18105 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: POTA, politics, propaganda, etc.
              .html
              *** Note: this is in answer to the following Melkor post.

              Let me ask you this, Melkie: if the KKK and/or a bunch of neo-Nazis
              were to bankroll a film glorifying Hitler/genocide/racism, etc., and
              if this group were to offer YOU (or your favorite Hollywood actor) a
              major role in the production... would YOU opt to do the film, and
              forevermore have your name associated with antisemitic, racist, pro-
              Nazi propaganda? Would that be "professionalism" on an actor's part,
              to "do the job" regardless of the content of the film? Frankly, if
              Heston were offered a role in a movie which GLORIFIED the mass-murder
              of blacks or jews or gays or ANY particular group, I would conclude
              that he HAD "sold out" (IF, that is, he had tried to make it clear
              that although he disagreed with Mass-murder as a concept he was intent
              on being "professional" and took on the role regardless).

              I remember wondering what Christians and Jews thought about John
              Travolta playing an angel in "Michael"; there are those who believe in
              the existence of angels (and all the other trappings of "Bible
              literalism"), and might they not be offended at the idea of a
              Scientologist portraying a Being that Scientologists don't even
              believe in? Did Travolta--in doing that role--promote, in a way, the
              "Believers' agenda" (if I may call it that), going against
              Scientology's beliefs? If the TV show "Touched By An Angel" can be
              seen (rightly, I think) to be promoting the belief in God/angels/
              salvation & damnation/etc. (hell, just read Cal Thomas' editorial
              columns... he fawns over that show), then why not the movie "Michael"?
              Can you see a "Bible-believing Christian" actor agreeing to take on
              the role of a non-divine, entirely-HUMAN Jesus... with flaws that none
              of the gospel-authors cared to depict? Wouldn't such an actor think
              himself to be committing a blasphemy by portraying his own Lord and
              personal Savior as, say, a demented rabble-rouser... even if that's
              what the script he'd been offered calls for?

              You say that you "doubt that anyone thought much about Heston's
              political views back in 1967"--but my point was that HESTON HIMSELF
              would have thought about the ramifications of endorsing a political
              "statement" that he vehemently disagreed with. I don't care HOW big
              the paycheck is--I don't see a person of integrity signing his/her
              name to a project with which he/she has serious differences, a "crisis
              of conscience" so to speak. When Alec Guinness brilliantly portrayed
              Adolf Hitler as a hate-mongering megalomaniac in "Hitler: The Last Ten
              Days" [a movie I can't recommend enough--it's fantastic], it should
              not have been a difficult moral/ethical choice: he played Hitler the
              way he was; yet, had the script been written as a propaganda piece
              portraying Hitler NOT as he really was but, rather, as a wonderful,
              caring, misunderstood genius... then I cannot see Guinness agreeing to
              play the role.

              Look what happened to Leni Riefenstahl [I may have misspelled her
              name], in the wake of her masterfully-produced "documentary"/
              propaganda piece "Triumph of the Will". No one denies that she was a
              supremely talented filmmaker--that's not the point. It was her
              willingness to lend her talents to the glorification of Hitlerism that
              in effect "black-balled" her from doing any serious work later on,
              since nobody wanted to be associated with ANYBODY who could "sign on"
              to such a project.
              Similarly, if Heston had vociferously disagreed with the political
              messages incorporated into "PLANET OF THE APES", then his conscience
              would have motivated him to disassociate himself from it (hey, just
              because Zanuck couldn't see the "politics" in POTA doesn't mean that
              Heston was blind to it). So, then, IF Heston agreed to do the role,
              portraying a character that was undoubtedly different from himself yet
              IN FURTHERANCE OF A "POLITICAL AGENDA" inherent in the totality of the
              film, it must have been either due to agreeing with the film's
              politics (an ethically defensible move), or IN SPITE OF DISAGREEING
              with those politics--which I think is less defensible, ethically
              speaking, for the reasons stated above.

              I was NOT saying that Heston--by portraying Taylor, who "goes around
              mocking the American flag" etc.--was "selling out", as you mistakenly
              keep inferring. I don't believe that the total film "POTA" endorses
              the mocking of the American flag, just because the main character does
              this. Taylor is the protagonist--but he is NOT a "hero". In a way,
              he's sort of an "anti-hero" whose actions are NOT necessarily
              laudable. Taylor mocks the American flag, probably because America--
              when he left it, in 1972--did not represent to him the "land of the
              free" where Liberty and Equality are cherished and furthered by the
              "powers that be", whereas Landon plants that little flag--probably
              because he cherishes the Ideals of Americanism, loving his country not
              necessarily for what it had been in 1972 but for what America SHOULD
              be all about. America was founded by men who had long-term goals for
              their posterity, trying to create a country which would move closer
              and closer towards Perfection ("in order to form a more perfect
              Union"), a condition they knew that THEY themselves would not live to
              see... yet, perhaps, their descendants WOULD, one day. Landon plants
              the flag, I suspect, because he cherishes the Ideals of Americanism,
              "the American way" which, sadly, our own government (in 1968-to-1972)
              seemed to be working AGAINST (this WAS during the time of the Nixon
              administration, after all... with its escalation of the Vietnam War--
              after Nixon had promised to bring about its end--and its race riots,
              the Kent State massacre, the Watergate "dirty tricks" shenanigans, etc
              etc.). "PLANET OF THE APES" did not endorse the mocking of the flag--
              it merely depicted a "harsh embittered man" (as Heston described his
              character) as the protagonist in a story which satirized some of the
              more blatant follies of the human race in general, and of American
              society in particular. We aren't meant to cheer Taylor's laughing at
              Landon planting the flag--quite the opposite, I think. Yet IF the
              script had been different, and if it HAD called for the audience to
              respond favorably to Taylor's "anti-American" mocking of Landon and
              his flag... then I seriously doubt if Heston would have agreed to do
              such a picture. Heston was savvy enough to know that the character he
              played was NOT a hero, NOT somebody the audience should deem heroic--
              hell, neither are most of the protagonists of Shakespeare's tragedies,
              but those characters are the meatiest roles an actor could ever hope
              to play.
              In my previous posting I wrote: "I trust, Melkor, that you can see the
              difference between this sort of implication and the one you thought I
              had put forward." Evidently, my trust was misplaced, since you still
              haven't understood what I was talking about. I hope this posting helps
              clear up for you the point I was trying to make, rather than the point
              you mistakingly thought I was trying to make.

              Patrick Michael Tilton
              EARTH-TIME 6-16-2002


              --- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
              > Acting in roles that are different than you and have different views is considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that anyone thought much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was doing POTA, including Heston himself.
              >
              > Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is Heston "selling out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes around mocking the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for a liberal utopia. Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that Heston must have the same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably would have turned down the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's political views and his professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this than don't.
              >
              > Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play characters with different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be renamed "New America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities too. Anything goes in the Patrick universe.
              >
              >
              > >> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
              > >roles they are
              > >> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
              > >roles that are
              > >> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
              > >Greatest Hits. But
              > >> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
              > >the patriotic
              > >> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
              > >maybe Heston wants the
              > >> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
              > >Maybe actors never
              > >> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
              > >Australia will
              > >> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
              > >happen in the
              > >> Patrick universe.
              > >
              > >*** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
              > >the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
              > >What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
              > >do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
              > >politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
              > >For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
              > >Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
              > >that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
              > >Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
              > >Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
              > >didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
              > >philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
              > >Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see myself
              > >supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
              > >could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
              > >Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
              > >was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
              > >could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
              > >a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
              > >own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
              > >OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
              > >do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
              > >or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
              > >Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
              > >I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
              > >of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
              >
              >
              >
              >
              >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18106 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              .html
              *** I think it was appropriate not only for Taylor to survive the
              ending of PLANET, but also to be the one to detonate the Bomb at the
              end of BENEATH. At the end of PLANET, Taylor literally calls upon God
              to damn the human race to hell because they "blew it up", nuked the
              Earth into the Stone Age. It's bad enough that Mankind has lost its
              civilization in the most violent (self-inflicted) manner possible, and
              has been reduced to a state of timid savagery... but must God, too,
              heap onto ALL Mankind the eternal punishment of Damnation? Heston has
              talked about how Fox convinced the MPAA that the "goddamn you all to
              hell" line was NOT just profanity (which would've subjected the film
              to a higher rating), but was a case of the character LITERALLY calling
              upon God to damn the human race.
              And then, at the end of BENEATH, Taylor--evidently not satisfied that
              the human race has suffered enough--consigns not only Humanity but ALL
              LIFE ON PLANET EARTH to Death, with the triggering of the Bomb. Now
              that all life is gone, all humans dead... now Taylor's God can go
              about punishing the souls of all the remaining humans (including Nova)
              in Hell for all eternity.
              Heston may have felt that Taylor was "most like him" of any role he'd
              played... but THIS aspect of the character is something that I find
              quite disturbing. I can support the decision Truman made to annihilate
              Hiroshima and Nagasaki--since by doing so he prevented a prolonged
              invasion which would have killed far more people on both sides of the
              conflict; but when Taylor detonates the Bomb which is capable of
              destroying ALL LIFE on the planet, burning it to a cinder (as he says
              to Brent), I think that Taylor was just the type of person to commit
              such an act, given his hatred of Humanity (the Statue scene). I think
              that Heston, perhaps, would admit that THIS aspect of Taylor's
              personality is something which he does NOT share (yeesh, at least I
              HOPE he doesn't).

              Patrick

              --- In pota@y..., "cgenro" <cgenro@y...> wrote:
              > I think if Heston had died it would have been just as successful. If
              > they wanted Heston to die when would it have happened?? after the
              > discovery of the Statue of liberty??
              >
              > Also by Heston not dying I think it made Beneath all the more
              > interesting. Sure they could have gone off in another direction but
              > it was great in my opinion to see him still alive near the end of
              > the film.
              >
              > --- In pota@y..., <veetus@e...> wrote:
              > > The point is made that the apes "are too dumb to hold our
              > illusions" after
              > > Zauis doesn't buy the burning Lawgiver. If not, it would've been a
              > pretty
              > > boring ending. ("There's nothing here, Ursus. Let's go home.").
              > > I've been reading Pendreigh's great "Legend of POTA" book. It
              > mentions that
              > > everybody but Michael Wilson wanted Heston to die at the end
              > of "Planet".
              > > Jacobs, Abrahams, everybody. But Wilson fought it, saying it would
              > diminish
              > > the ending. If Heston had died:
              > > a) would it be possible the film wouldn't have been as successful?
              > > b) they would've had much more freedom in "Beneath" storywise
              > > Etc. - - - Jeff
              > >
              > >
              > > ----- Original Message -----
              > > From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@y...>
              > > To: <pota@y...>
              > > Sent: Saturday, June 15, 2002 9:13 AM
              > > Subject: [Planet of the Apes] Re: Story between Planet and Beneath
              > >
              > >
              > > > --- In pota@y..., "Anthony B. McElveen" <abmac@i...> wrote:
              > > > > You're assuming that the mountain was a mirage and that the
              > > > land was
              > > > > actually flat. I believe both images were projected to hide an
              > > > entrance
              > > > > to the underground passageways.
              > > > >
              > > > > While we're on the subject I'd like to say that the mutants
              > could
              > > > easily
              > > > > have eliminated the entire ape army if they'd used their mental
              > > > powers
              > > > > to hide an existing cliff and lure the apes over it instead of
              > > > > projecting impossible illusions in a physically safe area.
              > > > >
              > > > > Also, I was bothered by the huge rolling boulder in Planet
              > until I
              > > > saw
              > > > > Beneath. Although I've never heard anyone mention it and it
              > > > almost
              > > > > certainly isn't true, I deduced that someone involved in Planet
              > > > already
              > > > > had the idea of psychic mutants who protected their city with
              > > > annoying,
              > > > > but non-lethal, illusions and wanted to lay a little groundwork
              > > > for
              > > > > their eventual appearance. I no longer believe that, but I
              > think
              > > > it's
              > > > > possible that Dehn was also bothered by the self-starting rock
              > > > and
              > > > > wanted to "unflub" a mistake made by his predecessors.
              > > > >
              > > > > ABMAC
              > > >
              > > > *** Heyyyy!!! A word I coined is now in use! "Unflub" lives!
              > > > Incidentally, you have a good point about the Mutants' rather
              > > > unimaginative use of their illusion-casting power. Why didn't
              > they
              > > > make the Apes think that the Queensboro Plaza subway tunnels
              > > > were caved in? If Ursus' army doesn't know there are tunnels
              > > > there leading to the "city of the dead", then Mendez & Co. are
              > safe
              > > > and sound. Or... why not fool the gorillas into thinking they see
              > > > other apes, instead of fleshy-headed mutants? All sorts of
              > > > possibilities...
              > > >
              > > > Patrick
              > > >
              > > >
              > > >
              > > >
              > > >
              > > >
              > > >
              >
              > > >
              > > >
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18107 From: Rich Handley Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] Digest Number 1102
              .html
              >From: "Calima 5021" <calima5021com@...>
              >Subject: Last attempt
              >I'm making one last attempt at this two disc toon set.
              >Made a few adjustments, and hopefuly this will work.
              >I'll let you guys know in the morning what happened. Hopefuly my computer
              >won't explode! :o) Let's pray to the Lawgiver this works.
              >Pray your asses off. :o) annnnnd...GO!

              Al, you're a great guy just for even offering and attempting to do this --
              if it doesn't work out, don't sweat it. Thanks for your generosity, either
              way!

              >P.S. OH AND, HAPPY DAD DAY EVERYONE! :o)

              Thanks, and I second that notion for all my fellow dads. :) I'm happily
              sitting back doing nothing today, and I'm about to go see Scooby-Doo with
              my five-year-old daughter to celebrate. Plus, my wife got me the Harry
              Potter DVD (I admit it, I loved the film), and I'll probably watch it with
              her later tonight, after which we'll recreate the event that caused me to
              be a dad in the first place. LOL!
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18108 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: BATTLE DVD
              .html
              I got my copy in the mail the other day. Al, you're the swingingest
              monkey in this yahoo zoo... I can't thank you enough for this free
              nugget of joy.

              Now if I can only find a way to get it to play on my DVD player! For
              some reason, my DVD machine keeps ejecting it, saying it's "non-
              playable". Argh! It does, however, play on the DVD-rom drive of the PC
              in the computer cluster where I'm typing this (I don't have a DVD-rom
              drive on my home computer, an ancient Mac LC-II... yeah, yeah, I know
              I gotta upgrade one-a-these-days to something less outdated!). I don't
              have much experience with DVD-roms, and it took me a while to figure
              out how to get the PC to play it--not to mention how to get the sound
              to play along with the visuals. But it DOES work on the PC DVD-rom
              drive player thingy. Any suggestions as to how I might fool my home
              DVD player (the one hooked up to my TV) into playing it?

              One of the things that makes this "extended BATTLE" version
              particularly favored over the "normal" version is the parallelism
              between Kolp-and-Alma and Caesar-and-Lisa. The way this "extended"
              version plays, the contrast is noticably evident. Kolp and Caesar are
              both leaders of their respective peoples, and both have relationships
              with women... but Kolp's female companion, Alma, is not the type who
              "second-guesses" her man--she would have blindly followed through with
              Kolp's final wish: to detonate the Alpha Omega bomb... and it's only
              the intervention of Mendez which prevents that from happening.
              Caesar's wife Lisa, on the other hand, never just knits away and says
              "Yes, dear" to her husband; Lisa questions Caesar's decisions--which
              affect not only her and her family, but the entire community. Caesar
              tries to justify his assumptions about Kolp's people by saying that
              they're "malformed" (talk about a "surface" judgment!), and Lisa
              counters that with a comparison to "the freaks in [Armando's] circus".
              Caesar seems hell-bent on seeing ALL the humans in the Forbidden City
              as "mutant... and they're MAD...", yet if not for the humane, rational
              Mendez, Caesar's victory over Kolp would have been short-lived, and
              the "planet of the apes" would have been annihilated NOT in 3955 but
              in 2018 (or whenever BATTLE takes place... I think it's 2018, myself).
              BATTLE is far far better WITH this extra footage... so why the hell
              did Fox edit it out? It's not like the movie was "running long", since
              the playing time is less than an hour and a half (if I'm not
              mistaken), and a good chunk of that is mere flash-back to ESCAPE and
              CONQUEST in the "Lawgiver prologue" scene.

              If you ever do figure out a way to do the cartoons (either on a 2-disc
              or 3-disc set), I think you'll find that there are those of us out
              here who wouldn't mind plunking down a $20 bill for it, to off-set the
              inconvenience it obviously costs you (the 3-hour burning time). But
              even if you ultimately decide that you can't accomplish the task...
              hey, Al, your gift of the BATTLE DVD alone makes you "A-number-one" in
              my book. Hell, if I ever do manage to finish my magnum opus (which
              I've given the title "Destiny of the Planet of the Apes"--I mentioned
              it many months ago in one of my first postings, but haven't mentioned
              any time recently), be forewarned that you shall receive a
              complimentary copy of it, just as my "thank you" for this marvelous
              gift. Mind you, this won't be any time soon, since the Project is
              nowhere near to being completed--but IF it's ever done and published,
              there'll be a copy with your name on the inside front cover.

              Thanks again and again and again (ad infinitum), you "model for us
              all... a gorilla to remember..."

              Patrick Michael Tilton
              EARTH-TIME 6-16-2002
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18109 From: patrickmichaeltilton Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: OT: "THE BOURNE IDENTITY" and "SCOOBY DOO"
              .html
              I went to see both "The Bourne Identity" and "Scooby Doo" yesterday,
              and I have to say I had a good time.

              BOURNE is terrific, a great non-Bond/Flint/"I Spy"/"Austin Powers" spy
              flick. As fun as the Bond films can be, they tend to get "over the
              top", whereas this Ludlum-based story has more of a "real world" feel
              to it (note: NOT the MTV "real world"!!!).
              I hope that this is the beginning of a franchise; Matt Damon does a
              great job (I haven't read the book it's based on, but judging just
              from the movie, other Bourne stories are more than welcome),
              convincing kicking ass in the fight scenes. I'm still not exactly sure
              how his character loses his recent memory (could it be a "Memento"-
              like form of amnesia?), but regardless, it was a good set-up: his
              "second nature" training as an assassin kicks in reflexively, even
              though he somehow can't remember that he was/is an assassin. Maybe the
              book better explains the memory loss bit, but no matter. The movie was
              great.

              SCOOBY DOO was about what I expected it to be: an okay film version of
              source material which I had no vested interest in seeing "done right"
              (like "Planet of the Apes" for instance). I was disappointed in
              Burton's flick... but "Scooby Doo" I found to be entertaining--
              especially when they made fun of the established concepts (portraying
              Scrappy Doo as the unwelcome "5th wheel" fans always thought him to
              be, for instance). The CGI work--though obviously "fakey"--did what it
              needed to do: bring to "life" an anthropomorphic dog who can actually
              talk! The casting was good (I didn't hate Freddie Prinze Jr. as Fred,
              by God!)... and absolutely INSPIRED in the case of Matthew Lillard as
              Shaggy. He was perfect!
              The flick was geared more for a kids' audience, but there were just
              enough double entendres in it to amuse a 30-something guy like me. And
              I have to admit that Velma sure fills out that sweater...

              So... "THE BOURNE IDENTITY": 2 opposable thumbs UP! And "SCOOBY DOO":
              2 opposable thumbs UP... if you're in the mood for this sorta thing. I
              was, so... yeah!

              Patrick
              <.html
              Group: pota Message: 18110 From: Calima 5021 Date: 6/16/2002
              Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] BATTLE DVD
              .html
              Attachments :
                Yeah, most DVD players will play DVD-Rs, but if you have a DVD player more
                than a couple of years old, it won't. Because DVD-Rs back then were mostly
                unheard of. But now the latest models now play CD-R, CD-RW and DVD-R. I was
                at my local Best Buy the other day and saw a JVC DVD player that played
                everything for only $120.00

                But at least you have a DVD-ROM to see it, If you have trouble hearing it,
                most likely it's not hooked up right.

                DVD players are always a bit tricky, I have a friend who is able too see it,
                but the movie skips from time to time. And, Matt told me the same the other
                day. Bottom line, you need a DVD player that is 100% compatible to play a
                DVD-R. And seeing what there worth now, it's worth the buy.

                Toons continue to be a bust.
                So all I can offer is Battle UNcut and Jeff Exclusives next month for $10
                bucks. All free requests will be sent out during the course of next week and
                I'll get started on Jeff's stuff next weekend.
                Again, it's not really a question of money, it's a question of sitting
                behind my computer and burning for 3 hours to make one toon set. It's way
                too much time and like everyone here, I have an 8 hour job and a personal
                life. So burning 1 DVD for one hour is the best I can do as far as time on
                my hands.

                Best.
                And Enjoy Battle UNcut, with one ass kicking Apes Classic DVD coming soon.

                Al





                >From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@...>
                >Reply-To: pota@yahoogroups.com
                >To: pota@yahoogroups.com
                >Subject: [Planet of the Apes] BATTLE DVD
                >Date: Sun, 16 Jun 2002 14:23:36 -0000
                >




                _____
                <.html
                Group: pota Message: 18111 From: Alan Maxwell Date: 6/16/2002
                Subject: Talking of busts...
                .html
                Attachments :
                  This appeared in the new Previews magazine. As generic Apes
                  characters, these are really nice pieces. Can't say that they're that
                  brilliant as far as likenesses go, however.

                  Alan
                  <.html
                  Group: pota Message: 18112 From: Jeff & Susan Stringer Date: 6/16/2002
                  Subject: Re: [Planet of the Apes] POTA, politics, propaganda, etc.
                  .html
                  Cripes. Enough already.
                  Griatle P.


                  ----- Original Message -----
                  From: "patrickmichaeltilton" <patrickmichaeltilton@...>
                  To: <pota@yahoogroups.com>
                  Sent: Sunday, June 16, 2002 9:28 AM
                  Subject: [Planet of the Apes] POTA, politics, propaganda, etc.


                  > *** Note: this is in answer to the following Melkor post.
                  >
                  > Let me ask you this, Melkie: if the KKK and/or a bunch of neo-Nazis
                  > were to bankroll a film glorifying Hitler/genocide/racism, etc., and
                  > if this group were to offer YOU (or your favorite Hollywood actor) a
                  > major role in the production... would YOU opt to do the film, and
                  > forevermore have your name associated with antisemitic, racist, pro-
                  > Nazi propaganda? Would that be "professionalism" on an actor's part,
                  > to "do the job" regardless of the content of the film? Frankly, if
                  > Heston were offered a role in a movie which GLORIFIED the mass-murder
                  > of blacks or jews or gays or ANY particular group, I would conclude
                  > that he HAD "sold out" (IF, that is, he had tried to make it clear
                  > that although he disagreed with Mass-murder as a concept he was intent
                  > on being "professional" and took on the role regardless).
                  >
                  > I remember wondering what Christians and Jews thought about John
                  > Travolta playing an angel in "Michael"; there are those who believe in
                  > the existence of angels (and all the other trappings of "Bible
                  > literalism"), and might they not be offended at the idea of a
                  > Scientologist portraying a Being that Scientologists don't even
                  > believe in? Did Travolta--in doing that role--promote, in a way, the
                  > "Believers' agenda" (if I may call it that), going against
                  > Scientology's beliefs? If the TV show "Touched By An Angel" can be
                  > seen (rightly, I think) to be promoting the belief in God/angels/
                  > salvation & damnation/etc. (hell, just read Cal Thomas' editorial
                  > columns... he fawns over that show), then why not the movie "Michael"?
                  > Can you see a "Bible-believing Christian" actor agreeing to take on
                  > the role of a non-divine, entirely-HUMAN Jesus... with flaws that none
                  > of the gospel-authors cared to depict? Wouldn't such an actor think
                  > himself to be committing a blasphemy by portraying his own Lord and
                  > personal Savior as, say, a demented rabble-rouser... even if that's
                  > what the script he'd been offered calls for?
                  >
                  > You say that you "doubt that anyone thought much about Heston's
                  > political views back in 1967"--but my point was that HESTON HIMSELF
                  > would have thought about the ramifications of endorsing a political
                  > "statement" that he vehemently disagreed with. I don't care HOW big
                  > the paycheck is--I don't see a person of integrity signing his/her
                  > name to a project with which he/she has serious differences, a "crisis
                  > of conscience" so to speak. When Alec Guinness brilliantly portrayed
                  > Adolf Hitler as a hate-mongering megalomaniac in "Hitler: The Last Ten
                  > Days" [a movie I can't recommend enough--it's fantastic], it should
                  > not have been a difficult moral/ethical choice: he played Hitler the
                  > way he was; yet, had the script been written as a propaganda piece
                  > portraying Hitler NOT as he really was but, rather, as a wonderful,
                  > caring, misunderstood genius... then I cannot see Guinness agreeing to
                  > play the role.
                  >
                  > Look what happened to Leni Riefenstahl [I may have misspelled her
                  > name], in the wake of her masterfully-produced "documentary"/
                  > propaganda piece "Triumph of the Will". No one denies that she was a
                  > supremely talented filmmaker--that's not the point. It was her
                  > willingness to lend her talents to the glorification of Hitlerism that
                  > in effect "black-balled" her from doing any serious work later on,
                  > since nobody wanted to be associated with ANYBODY who could "sign on"
                  > to such a project.
                  > Similarly, if Heston had vociferously disagreed with the political
                  > messages incorporated into "PLANET OF THE APES", then his conscience
                  > would have motivated him to disassociate himself from it (hey, just
                  > because Zanuck couldn't see the "politics" in POTA doesn't mean that
                  > Heston was blind to it). So, then, IF Heston agreed to do the role,
                  > portraying a character that was undoubtedly different from himself yet
                  > IN FURTHERANCE OF A "POLITICAL AGENDA" inherent in the totality of the
                  > film, it must have been either due to agreeing with the film's
                  > politics (an ethically defensible move), or IN SPITE OF DISAGREEING
                  > with those politics--which I think is less defensible, ethically
                  > speaking, for the reasons stated above.
                  >
                  > I was NOT saying that Heston--by portraying Taylor, who "goes around
                  > mocking the American flag" etc.--was "selling out", as you mistakenly
                  > keep inferring. I don't believe that the total film "POTA" endorses
                  > the mocking of the American flag, just because the main character does
                  > this. Taylor is the protagonist--but he is NOT a "hero". In a way,
                  > he's sort of an "anti-hero" whose actions are NOT necessarily
                  > laudable. Taylor mocks the American flag, probably because America--
                  > when he left it, in 1972--did not represent to him the "land of the
                  > free" where Liberty and Equality are cherished and furthered by the
                  > "powers that be", whereas Landon plants that little flag--probably
                  > because he cherishes the Ideals of Americanism, loving his country not
                  > necessarily for what it had been in 1972 but for what America SHOULD
                  > be all about. America was founded by men who had long-term goals for
                  > their posterity, trying to create a country which would move closer
                  > and closer towards Perfection ("in order to form a more perfect
                  > Union"), a condition they knew that THEY themselves would not live to
                  > see... yet, perhaps, their descendants WOULD, one day. Landon plants
                  > the flag, I suspect, because he cherishes the Ideals of Americanism,
                  > "the American way" which, sadly, our own government (in 1968-to-1972)
                  > seemed to be working AGAINST (this WAS during the time of the Nixon
                  > administration, after all... with its escalation of the Vietnam War--
                  > after Nixon had promised to bring about its end--and its race riots,
                  > the Kent State massacre, the Watergate "dirty tricks" shenanigans, etc
                  > etc.). "PLANET OF THE APES" did not endorse the mocking of the flag--
                  > it merely depicted a "harsh embittered man" (as Heston described his
                  > character) as the protagonist in a story which satirized some of the
                  > more blatant follies of the human race in general, and of American
                  > society in particular. We aren't meant to cheer Taylor's laughing at
                  > Landon planting the flag--quite the opposite, I think. Yet IF the
                  > script had been different, and if it HAD called for the audience to
                  > respond favorably to Taylor's "anti-American" mocking of Landon and
                  > his flag... then I seriously doubt if Heston would have agreed to do
                  > such a picture. Heston was savvy enough to know that the character he
                  > played was NOT a hero, NOT somebody the audience should deem heroic--
                  > hell, neither are most of the protagonists of Shakespeare's tragedies,
                  > but those characters are the meatiest roles an actor could ever hope
                  > to play.
                  > In my previous posting I wrote: "I trust, Melkor, that you can see the
                  > difference between this sort of implication and the one you thought I
                  > had put forward." Evidently, my trust was misplaced, since you still
                  > haven't understood what I was talking about. I hope this posting helps
                  > clear up for you the point I was trying to make, rather than the point
                  > you mistakingly thought I was trying to make.
                  >
                  > Patrick Michael Tilton
                  > EARTH-TIME 6-16-2002
                  >
                  >
                  > --- In pota@y..., "Melkor" <melkor@m...> wrote:
                  > > Acting in roles that are different than you and have different views is
                  considered professionalism, not "selling out". I doubt that anyone thought
                  much about Heston's political views back in 1967 while he was doing POTA,
                  including Heston himself.
                  > >
                  > > Taylor is clearly different then Heston and saying that this is Heston
                  "selling out" is insulting to the whole acting profession. Taylor goes
                  around mocking the American flag, criticizing conservatives, and hoping for
                  a liberal utopia. Heston does not do any of these things. By implying that
                  Heston must have the same views as Taylor because otherwise Heston probably
                  would have turned down the POTA role you are insulting both Heston's
                  political views and his professionalism. If you don't mean to imply this
                  than don't.
                  > >
                  > > Maybe actors are "selling out" whenever they happen to play characters
                  with different views than their own...and maybe Australia will be renamed
                  "New America" and have all its cities renamed to American cities too.
                  Anything goes in the Patrick universe.
                  > >
                  > >
                  > > >> Sorry Patrick but your implying that actors are the same as the
                  > > >roles they are
                  > > >> performing because professional actors like Heston don't play
                  > > >roles that are
                  > > >> different from them reminded me about one of your earlier
                  > > >Greatest Hits. But
                  > > >> maybe Heston really does let out a big hearty laugh to mock
                  > > >the patriotic
                  > > >> schmoes who put up American flags like Taylor does. And
                  > > >maybe Heston wants the
                  > > >> same liberal utopia Taylor wants in his POTA monologue.
                  > > >Maybe actors never
                  > > >> play characters who are different than them...and maybe
                  > > >Australia will
                  > > >> "pole-shift" over to a different hemisphere. Anything can
                  > > >happen in the
                  > > >> Patrick universe.
                  > > >
                  > > >*** I don't think that that was what I was implying (i.e. that Heston
                  > > >the Actor wouldn't play a Character who was different than him).
                  > > >What I was suggesting was that Heston could have refused to
                  > > >do the role based on a philosophical disagreement with the
                  > > >politics of the film, had he had any personal reasons to do so.
                  > > >For example, the movie "The Contender" (with Joan Allen, Jeff
                  > > >Bridges, and Gary Oldman) has a decidedly "left-wing" slant to it
                  > > >that a die-hard "right-wing" actor (such as Heston [?] or Bruce
                  > > >Willis, etc.) might not have wanted to associate himself with.
                  > > >Heston was not hard up for acting jobs back in 1968, so IF he
                  > > >didn't like Serling and Wilson's script (and the
                  > > >philosophical/political slant of it), he could have told Arthur
                  > > >Jacobs, "Sorry, Artie... but this isn't the kind of project I see
                  myself
                  > > >supporting--try Kirk Douglas, maybe..." (or something like that). I
                  > > >could easily see a "left-winger" turning down ANY role in the 3rd
                  > > >Rambo movie, or "Invasion U.S.A." (etc.), or any other role that
                  > > >was "Rah rah rah" with a blatant Right-Wing agenda; similarly, I
                  > > >could see a "right-winger" turning down any role in a movie with
                  > > >a Left-Wing agenda, just for the sake of being "true" to his/her
                  > > >own principles. Heston, who COULD have turned down PLANET
                  > > >OF THE APES due to a disagreement over its politics, decided to
                  > > >do the film--which means that either he AGREED with its politics,
                  > > >or he did it despite disagreeing with its politics... "selling-out" his
                  > > >Conscience in order to get paid for the job.
                  > > >I trust, Melkor, that you can see the difference between this sort
                  > > >of implication and the one you thought I had put forward.
                  > >
                  > >
                  > >
                  > >
                  > >
                  <.html


                  Copyright © 2026, Hunter Goatley. All rights reserved.
                  Last updated 2026-03-31 10:42.