Yahoo! pota group — Messages 39868–39967

Dates: 2006-12-07 through 2006-12-26

Messages in pota group. Page 399 of 764.
Index Prev  Next


Group: pota Message: 39868 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/7/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39869 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/7/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39870 From: James Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39871 From: thadesdarlinghuman Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Halloween, 2003...
Group: pota Message: 39872 From: James Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
Group: pota Message: 39873 From: Dave B Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Monkey business
Group: pota Message: 39874 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39875 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: Monkey business
Group: pota Message: 39876 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Power Records POTA on You Tube
Group: pota Message: 39877 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
Group: pota Message: 39878 From: Ty Templeton Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Re: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
Group: pota Message: 39879 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Michael Clarke Duncan's Birthday , 12/10/2006, 12:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39880 From: taebokitti@aol.com Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: gorilla extinction
Group: pota Message: 39881 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Re: gorilla extinction
Group: pota Message: 39882 From: rberk1382 Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39883 From: James Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39884 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39885 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Revolution Rocks!
Group: pota Message: 39886 From: Cornelius718@aol.com Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39887 From: rberk1382@aol.com Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39888 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39889 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
Group: pota Message: 39890 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39891 From: Dave B Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Message in a bottle when and h
Group: pota Message: 39892 From: James Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Message in a bottle when and h
Group: pota Message: 39893 From: James Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39894 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Richard D. Zanuck's Birthday , 12/13/2006, 12:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39895 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39896 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
Group: pota Message: 39897 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39898 From: Ty Templeton Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39899 From: brendan486 Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: Power Records POTA on You Tube
Group: pota Message: 39900 From: Hunter Goatley Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39901 From: Greg Plonowski Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Marvel UK issue 113
Group: pota Message: 39902 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: GOOD news
Group: pota Message: 39903 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/14/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39904 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/14/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39905 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/14/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
Group: pota Message: 39906 From: gp3085 Date: 12/14/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams and Simian Scrolls
Group: pota Message: 39907 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/15/2006
Subject: Re: Power Records POTA on You Tube
Group: pota Message: 39908 From: James Date: 12/15/2006
Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
Group: pota Message: 39909 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/16/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
Group: pota Message: 39910 From: David Giwner Date: 12/16/2006
Subject: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39911 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/17/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39912 From: Glen Date: 12/17/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39913 From: James Date: 12/17/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39914 From: Dave B Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39915 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39916 From: David Giwner Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39917 From: David Giwner Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39918 From: brendan486 Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39919 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39920 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 12/18/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39921 From: Jonathan Date: 12/19/2006
Subject: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39922 From: Paul Date: 12/19/2006
Subject: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
Group: pota Message: 39923 From: Greg Plonowski Date: 12/20/2006
Subject: Marvel UK issue 114
Group: pota Message: 39924 From: David Giwner Date: 12/20/2006
Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
Group: pota Message: 39925 From: Glen Date: 12/20/2006
Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
Group: pota Message: 39926 From: p3murds@aol.com Date: 12/20/2006
Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
Group: pota Message: 39927 From: Paul Date: 12/20/2006
Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
Group: pota Message: 39928 From: Paul Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: APE CITY WEBSITE
Group: pota Message: 39929 From: James Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
Group: pota Message: 39930 From: James Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39931 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39932 From: Jonathan Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39933 From: Jonathan Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39934 From: Paul Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
Group: pota Message: 39935 From: Glen Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
Group: pota Message: 39936 From: brendan486 Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39937 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39938 From: Glen Date: 12/21/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39939 From: Paul Date: 12/22/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39940 From: Jonathan Date: 12/22/2006
Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
Group: pota Message: 39941 From: James Date: 12/22/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39942 From: James Date: 12/22/2006
Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
Group: pota Message: 39943 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/22/2006
Subject: Estella Warren's Birthday , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39944 From: Paul Date: 12/23/2006
Subject: Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39945 From: brendan486 Date: 12/23/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39946 From: Glen Date: 12/23/2006
Subject: Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39947 From: Glen Date: 12/23/2006
Subject: Happy Holidays everyone...
Group: pota Message: 39948 From: p3murds@aol.com Date: 12/23/2006
Subject: Re: [POTA] Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:0
Group: pota Message: 39949 From: Rich Handley Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Merry Christmas
Group: pota Message: 39950 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Holiday
Group: pota Message: 39951 From: john rutkoski Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Holiday
Group: pota Message: 39952 From: john rutkoski Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Merry Christmas
Group: pota Message: 39953 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39954 From: theskulpter Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
Group: pota Message: 39955 From: Jonathan Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Have a Merry Christmas :-)
Group: pota Message: 39956 From: Jonathan Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39957 From: Glen Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
Group: pota Message: 39958 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39959 From: Judy Watson Date: 12/24/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39960 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/25/2006
Subject: Planet of the Apes 1968, 12/25/2006, 2:00 am
Group: pota Message: 39961 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39962 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
Group: pota Message: 39963 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39964 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/25/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39965 From: Jonathan Date: 12/26/2006
Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
Group: pota Message: 39966 From: theskulpter Date: 12/26/2006
Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
Group: pota Message: 39967 From: theskulpter Date: 12/26/2006
Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!



Group: pota Message: 39868 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/7/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html
yes the one on the left seems to be looking in a
particular direction and enjoying it!! I wonder what
Merou is doing in that pose tho? The whole magazine is
illustrated by the same person altho it doesn't say
who it is....all a bit risque as it is a men's pulp
mag.....there is one of a stripper dancing for a drunk
man in another story....

Tim

--- brendan486 <nzape@...> wrote:

> Pretty cool Tim. I hadn't seen these before and
> thanks for the nude
> picture alert.Fortunately the Human male didn't turn
> around, but I
> am wondering why the Gorillas are smiling.
> Brendan.
>
> --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\""
> <apefan23@...> wrote:
> >
> > I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> > Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> > features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure
> how
> > condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn
> and
> > Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short
> Novel"
> > on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is
> called
> > Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only
> two
> > illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> > alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
> > drawings...maybe they are! ......someone might
> have
> > shared these before but I hadn't seen them...
> >
> > Tim
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
_________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39869 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/7/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html
I'm not seeing any picture...Are they in the Files section?...

G

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\"" <apefan23@...> wrote:
>
> I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure how
> condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn and
> Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short Novel"
> on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is called
> Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only two
> illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
> drawings...maybe they are! ......someone might have
> shared these before but I hadn't seen them...
>
> Tim
>
>
>
>
__________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39870 From: James Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html

They can be seen by clicking here: http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/spnew

Thanks to Tim for sharing them with us.

 


--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "hotscheetz" <HotScheetz@...> wrote:
>
> I'm not seeing any picture...Are they in the Files section?...
>
> G
>
> --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\"" apefan23@ wrote:
> >
> > I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> > Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> > features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure how
> > condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn and
> > Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short Novel"
> > on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is called
> > Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only two
> > illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> > alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39871 From: thadesdarlinghuman Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Halloween, 2003...
.html
All together I paid almost 200.00 bucks for the POTA mask: latex,
makeup, the works, plus some sh!T that was much stronger than rubber
cement. In fact it had a special adhesive relaxer called "Bondoff".
So anyway, I had a lot of laughs on the way to work wearing this
full ape prosthesis, all the way to real hair and that, not to mention
I had on a pair of sunglasses and was followed and pulled up next to
just to get a better look.
Wrinkle the nose, show some teeth and they drove off with a leary
not...
I work in liquor store you can imagine what my "regular"
customers were going through(I believe a few joined A.A.!). It was all
fine and dandy until I dropped a keg on a sandaled foot(MINE!). Oh,
black and blue and sore as hell but I was not about to go to ER like
that, so I hobbled through until 12:00 am and went home and that was
where I forgot about how badly my foot ached...
This was some really strong stuff I had stuck on my face! It took
an hour and a half to rip the mask off of my face and in between the
breaks of pulling, I looked like a leper... Big hunks of skin hanging
off of my face, ya know?
By the time I yanked it all of with the help of "Bond off", the top
of my foot was as black as a bowling ball but there were no broken
bones! I went back to work the next day and was really careful about
dropping those kegs so that if they bounced they did not use my foot
as a buffer...
Masks are fun as long as you can simply lift them over your head.
Just don't glue 'em to your face like I did... ;}
Truly,

Thade's Darling Human
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39872 From: James Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
.html

The new LESSON FROM THE LAWGIVER is now available. This is part four in our multi-part LESSON. Thanks to Glen and all who contributed.

To view the LESSON click on the banner on the Yahoo Home page or click this link: http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/files/LFTL.htm.

Visit all the Group's special features including:

Also, be sure to join our sub-groups:

<.html
Group: pota Message: 39873 From: Dave B Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Monkey business
.html
Reading Boulle's Monkey Planet for the first time in years I noticed
that the narrative suddenly switches from past to present tense half
way through chapter 27...

Deliberate or a translation error?


CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN

I woke early after a restless night. I turned over three or four times
in my bed and rubbed my eyes before fully recovering consciousness,
still unaccustomed to the civilized I life I had been leading for a
month, feeling anxious every morning at not hearing the straw creak
and not feeling Nova's warmth against me.

I eventually came to my senses. I was living in one of the most
comfortable apartments in the institute. The apes had proved extremely
generous. I had a bedroom, a bathroom, clothes, books, a television
set. I read all the papers, I was free, I could go out, walk about the
streets, attend any entertainment. My presence in a public place still
provoked considerable interest, but the emotion of the first few days
had started to die down.

Cornelius was now the scientific head of the institute. Zaius had been
dismissed—he had been given another post, however, and a new
decoration—and Zira's fianc6 installed in his place. This had resulted
in a reorganization of the personnel, a general promotion of the
chimpanzee element, and renewed activity in every department Zira had
become the new director's assistant.

As for me, I took part in the scientist's research work, no longer as
a guinea pig but as a collaborator. However, it was only with great
difficulty and after much hesitation on the part of the Grand Council
that Cornelius had been granted this favor. The authorities still
appeared reluctant to admit my nature and origin.
I dressed quickly, left my room, and walked over to the wing of the
institute where I had once been a prisoner: the department under Zira,
who was still directing it in addition to her new duties. With
Cornelius' permission ; I had embarked there on a systematic study of
the men.

***And then...***

Here I am in the room with the cages, walking along the corridor in
front of the bars like one of the masters of this planet. Shall I
admit that I come here frequently, more frequently than my duties
demand? There are times when I feel burdened by constantly simian
surroundings, and here I find a sort of refuge.

The captives are well acquainted with me now and recognize my
authority. Do they see any difference between me, Zira, and the
warders who bring them their food? I should like to think so, but I
doubt it. For the last month, despite my patience and efforts, I, too,
have been unsuccessful in making them achieve any higher level of
performance than that of well-trained animals. A secret intuition
tells me, however, that their potentialities are enormous.

I should like to teach them to talk. This is my great ambition. I have
not succeeded, I admit. It is only with the utmost difficulty that
some of them manage to repeat a monosyllabic sound or two, which
certain chimpanzees on Earth can do. It is not much, but I am
persevering. What encourages me is the new persistence with which
their eyes try to meet mine, eyes which for some time have seemed to
be gradually changing in expression. I fancy I can see in them a spark
of curiosity, associated with a superior mentality, breaking through
the animal mindlessness.

I move slowly around the room, stopping in front of each of the
captives. I speak to them; I speak to them gently, patiently. They are
now accustomed to this unusual behavior on my part. They seem to
listen. I go on for several minutes, then stop speaking in whole
sentences and pronounce a few simple words, repeating them over and
over again, hoping for an echo. One of them clumsily articulates a
syllable, but this is as far as he will go today. The subject soon
gets tired, abandons the superhuman task, and lies down on the floor
as though after some exhausting effort. I sigh and pass on to the next
one. I finally come to the cage in which Nova is at present vegetating
in solitary sadness. Sadness—this at least is what I, with my
Earthman's conceit, wish to believe, and I struggle to detect this
emotion on her beautiful but inexpressive features. Zira has not given
her another mate, and I am grateful for that.

Dave
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39874 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html
Thanks, James...Is there any way to have the entire story scanned and
put into the Files for everyone?...

G

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "James" <JamesA1102@...> wrote:
>
>
> They can be seen by clicking here:
> http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/spnew
> <http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/spnew>
>
> Thanks to Tim for sharing them with us.
>
>
>
>
> --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "hotscheetz" <HotScheetz@> wrote:
> >
> > I'm not seeing any picture...Are they in the Files section?...
> >
> > G
> >
> > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\"" apefan23@ wrote:
> > >
> > > I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> > > Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> > > features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure how
> > > condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn and
> > > Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short Novel"
> > > on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is called
> > > Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only two
> > > illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> > > alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
> > > drawings...maybe they are! ......someone might have
> > > shared these before but I hadn't seen them...
> > >
> > > Tim
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
__________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39875 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/8/2006
Subject: Re: Monkey business
.html
I always felt it was deliberate...It changes the pace of the story,
making it more immediate...

G

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Dave B" <smugster2000@...> wrote:
>
> Reading Boulle's Monkey Planet for the first time in years I noticed
> that the narrative suddenly switches from past to present tense half
> way through chapter 27...
>
> Deliberate or a translation error?
>
>
> CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN
>
> I woke early after a restless night. I turned over three or four
times
> in my bed and rubbed my eyes before fully recovering consciousness,
> still unaccustomed to the civilized I life I had been leading for
a
> month, feeling anxious every morning at not hearing the straw creak
> and not feeling Nova's warmth against me.
>
> I eventually came to my senses. I was living in one of the most
> comfortable apartments in the institute. The apes had proved
extremely
> generous. I had a bedroom, a bathroom, clothes, books, a television
> set. I read all the papers, I was free, I could go out, walk about
the
> streets, attend any entertainment. My presence in a public place
still
> provoked considerable interest, but the emotion of the first few
days
> had started to die down.
>
> Cornelius was now the scientific head of the institute. Zaius had
been
> dismissed—he had been given another post, however, and a new
> decoration—and Zira's fianc6 installed in his place. This had
resulted
> in a reorganization of the personnel, a general promotion of the
> chimpanzee element, and renewed activity in every department Zira
had
> become the new director's assistant.
>
> As for me, I took part in the scientist's research work, no longer
as
> a guinea pig but as a collaborator. However, it was only with great
> difficulty and after much hesitation on the part of the Grand
Council
> that Cornelius had been granted this favor. The authorities still
> appeared reluctant to admit my nature and origin.
> I dressed quickly, left my room, and walked over to the wing of the
> institute where I had once been a prisoner: the department under
Zira,
> who was still directing it in addition to her new duties. With
> Cornelius' permission ; I had embarked there on a systematic study
of
> the men.
>
> ***And then...***
>
> Here I am in the room with the cages, walking along the corridor in
> front of the bars like one of the masters of this planet. Shall I
> admit that I come here frequently, more frequently than my duties
> demand? There are times when I feel burdened by constantly simian
> surroundings, and here I find a sort of refuge.
>
> The captives are well acquainted with me now and recognize my
> authority. Do they see any difference between me, Zira, and the
> warders who bring them their food? I should like to think so, but I
> doubt it. For the last month, despite my patience and efforts, I,
too,
> have been unsuccessful in making them achieve any higher level of
> performance than that of well-trained animals. A secret intuition
> tells me, however, that their potentialities are enormous.
>
> I should like to teach them to talk. This is my great ambition. I
have
> not succeeded, I admit. It is only with the utmost difficulty that
> some of them manage to repeat a monosyllabic sound or two, which
> certain chimpanzees on Earth can do. It is not much, but I am
> persevering. What encourages me is the new persistence with which
> their eyes try to meet mine, eyes which for some time have seemed to
> be gradually changing in expression. I fancy I can see in them a
spark
> of curiosity, associated with a superior mentality, breaking through
> the animal mindlessness.
>
> I move slowly around the room, stopping in front of each of the
> captives. I speak to them; I speak to them gently, patiently. They
are
> now accustomed to this unusual behavior on my part. They seem to
> listen. I go on for several minutes, then stop speaking in whole
> sentences and pronounce a few simple words, repeating them over and
> over again, hoping for an echo. One of them clumsily articulates a
> syllable, but this is as far as he will go today. The subject soon
> gets tired, abandons the superhuman task, and lies down on the floor
> as though after some exhausting effort. I sigh and pass on to the
next
> one. I finally come to the cage in which Nova is at present
vegetating
> in solitary sadness. Sadness—this at least is what I, with my
> Earthman's conceit, wish to believe, and I struggle to detect this
> emotion on her beautiful but inexpressive features. Zira has not
given
> her another mate, and I am grateful for that.
>
> Dave
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39876 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Power Records POTA on You Tube
.html
In case anyone is interested:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFLuInWfGm0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iks_CDhkrQ8&mode=related&search=


Hunter, I hope this wasn't "borrowed" from you...


Chris L.
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39877 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
.html
While thinking about the POTA timeline earlier today, I realized
something that I'm not sure has been addressed or not. In REVOLUTION,
Breck says that he "conceived, commissioned, and funded" (or something to
that effect) the Doomsday bomb, which implies that it was built when
Breck was in a position of power. So then, how did Taylor (in BENEATH)
know about it's existence? He would have had to know when he left Earth,
which is almost 20 years prior to CONQUEST/REVOLUTION. Even
conservatively placing Breck at 40/45 years of age during CONQUEST, I
can't see him having that kind of power when he was in his early 20's.

Thoughts, anyone?


Chris L.
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39878 From: Ty Templeton Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Re: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
.html
I always felt Breck was bragging a bit, and that he had been INVOLVED in the government project (as was Taylor) but the funding and design certainly came from the taxpayer.   No doubt Taylor and Breck knew each other, as did Hasslein.



Ty the Guy.  Plotting, not dialogue.

On 12/9/06, Chris Lawless <lawford42@...> wrote:

While thinking about the POTA timeline earlier today, I realized
something that I'm not sure has been addressed or not. In REVOLUTION,
Breck says that he "conceived, commissioned, and funded" (or something to
that effect) the Doomsday bomb, which implies that it was built when
Breck was in a position of power. So then, how did Taylor (in BENEATH)
know about it's existence? He would have had to know when he left Earth,
which is almost 20 years prior to CONQUEST/REVOLUTION. Even
conservatively placing Breck at 40/45 years of age during CONQUEST, I
can't see him having that kind of power when he was in his early 20's.

Thoughts, anyone?

Chris L.


<.html
Group: pota Message: 39879 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/9/2006
Subject: Michael Clarke Duncan's Birthday , 12/10/2006, 12:00 am
.html
.html
Reminder from:   pota's Calendar
Title:   Michael Clarke Duncan's Birthday 
Date:   Sunday December 10, 2006
Time:   All Day
Repeats:   This event repeats every year.
Copyright © 2006  Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved | <.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39880 From: taebokitti@aol.com Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: gorilla extinction
.html
.html I was just reading on the internet that 5,000 gorillas have died from the ebola virus, not good news. Elaine<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39881 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Re: gorilla extinction
.html
Yes I heard that on NPR....chimps dying as well....

Tim


--- taebokitti@... wrote:

> I was just reading on the internet that 5,000
> gorillas have died from the
> ebola virus, not good news. Elaine
>




________________________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39882 From: rberk1382 Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Mort Abrahams
.html
Hello. I am Mort Abrahams niece. I am trying to find out if there is
more than one version of Behind the Planet of the Apes. I have a
recollection of seeing a version on TV that consisted mostly of
interaction with my uncle. The version I recently viewed on the 35th
Anniversary DVD seems different. Is it my memory? Or is it reality?
I emailed Terry Hoknes with this question and he suggested that I
contact you all.

By the way, my uncle, now 90, is terrific, and living in the LA area.
He is still a voting member of the Motion Picture Academy, and a sharp
and vigorous person.
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39883 From: James Date: 12/10/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
I believe the DVD version added 10 to 15 minutes to the film that was
not shown on TV.

It is good to hear that your uncle is doing so well. There are so few
of the original cast and crew still around anymore. Please be sure and
give him our warmest regards.

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "rberk1382" <rberk1382@...> wrote:
>
> Hello. I am Mort Abrahams niece. I am trying to find out if there
is
> more than one version of Behind the Planet of the Apes. I have a
> recollection of seeing a version on TV that consisted mostly of
> interaction with my uncle. The version I recently viewed on the 35th
> Anniversary DVD seems different. Is it my memory? Or is it
reality?
> I emailed Terry Hoknes with this question and he suggested that I
> contact you all.
>
> By the way, my uncle, now 90, is terrific, and living in the LA
area.
> He is still a voting member of the Motion Picture Academy, and a
sharp
> and vigorous person.
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39884 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
Us hairy monkeys at Simian Scrolls can vouch for Mort being sharp and
intelligent--he's given us a wonderful interview that will grace the
next issue of Scrolls, due out early next year.Mort is a living legend!
John, Scrolls.
>
> Hello. I am Mort Abrahams niece. I am trying to find out if there
is
> more than one version of Behind the Planet of the Apes. I have a
> recollection of seeing a version on TV that consisted mostly of
> interaction with my uncle. The version I recently viewed on the 35th
> Anniversary DVD seems different. Is it my memory? Or is it
reality?
> I emailed Terry Hoknes with this question and he suggested that I
> contact you all.
>
> By the way, my uncle, now 90, is terrific, and living in the LA
area.
> He is still a voting member of the Motion Picture Academy, and a
sharp
> and vigorous person.
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39885 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Revolution Rocks!
.html
Mr.Comics' Revolution has a really good review in Jack Kirby Collector
#47( Kirby's Kamandi is viewed as 'DCs Planet of the Apes' by
many).They say 'the expert upstarts at Mr. Comics make it worth the
trip and describe the series as 'an impressive job'.From the home of
Kirby, that's praise indeed. Now I'm even more rabid for the trade
paperback! John, Scrolls.
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39886 From: Cornelius718@aol.com Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
.html
When next year and how can I get a copy? 
 
 
-----Original Message-----
From: john@...
To: pota@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Mon, 11 Dec 2006 11:32 AM
Subject: [POTA] Re: Mort Abrahams

Us hairy monkeys at Simian Scrolls can vouch for Mort being sharp and
intelligent- -he's given us a wonderful interview that will grace the
next issue of Scrolls, due out early next year.Mort is a living legend!
John, Scrolls.
>
> Hello. I am Mort Abrahams niece. I am trying to find out if there
is
> more than one version of Behind the Planet of the Apes. I have a
> recollection of seeing a version on TV that consisted mostly of
> interaction with my uncle. The version I recently viewed on the 35th
> Anniversary DVD seems different. Is it my memory? Or is it
reality?
> I emailed Terry Hoknes with this question and he suggested that I
> contact you all.
>
> By the way, my uncle, now 90, is terrific, and living in the LA
area.
> He is still a voting member of the Motion Picture Academy, and a
sharp
> and vigorous person.
>


Check out the new AOL. Most comprehensive set of free safety and security tools, free access to millions of high-quality videos from across the web, free AOL Mail and more.
<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39887 From: rberk1382@aol.com Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
.html
And when can I get a copy of Mort Abrahams interview?
<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39888 From: hotscheetz Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html
Tim, Is there a way you can scan the whole story, and post it here?...

G

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\"" <apefan23@...> wrote:
>
> I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure how
> condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn and
> Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short Novel"
> on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is called
> Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only two
> illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
> drawings...maybe they are! ......someone might have
> shared these before but I hadn't seen them...
>
> Tim
>
>
>
>
__________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39889 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/11/2006
Subject: Re: speaking of Monkey Planet
.html
I could....Hunter actually offered to host it.....I
haven't compared it to the novel yet....but since it
is from the novel I thought that it might be
repetitive since the novel is readily
available...those were the only two
illustrations....but I can if there is interest...have
to find time to scan!

Tim


--- hotscheetz <HotScheetz@...> wrote:

> Tim, Is there a way you can scan the whole story,
> and post it here?...
>
> G
>
> --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Tim \"apefan\""
> <apefan23@...> wrote:
> >
> > I won this magazine on ebay.....It is "Bizarre!
> > Mystery Magazine" Vol.1 No. 2 November 1965 and
> > features a new story by Pierre Boulle. Not sure
> how
> > condensed it is.....I see right off the bat Jinn
> and
> > Phyllis are not in it...It says "Complete Short
> Novel"
> > on the cover...Not sure what that means!! It is
> called
> > Planet of the Apes in the mag and there are only
> two
> > illustrations... enclosed here....NAKED people
> > alert!!...which sort of look like the Hungarian
> > drawings...maybe they are! ......someone might
> have
> > shared these before but I hadn't seen them...
> >
> > Tim
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
__________ ________________________
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39890 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
We're aiming at Feb 2007 and ordering details will appear on this
Group, courtesy of the lovely James.We have, courtesy of the even more
lovely Kass(please don't tell her I said that) a US ordering option.
We'll keep everyone posted.We've learned over the years that Christmas
and New Year must be avoided as release dates!Mort's niece is entitled
to a free copy for having such a great uncle, so if we get a postal
address, that would be our pleasure. John, Scrolls.
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39891 From: Dave B Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Message in a bottle when and h
.html
Upon re-reading the conclusion of Boulle's original Novel I found
myself wondering how Merou managed to get that bottle, containing his
message, back into space.

Dave
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39892 From: James Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Message in a bottle when and h
.html
I always imagined that Nova and the child ran back to the spaceship.
Ulysess ran after them and relaunched the ship into space to seek a
planet where humans still ruled.

--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Dave B" <smugster2000@...> wrote:
>
> Upon re-reading the conclusion of Boulle's original Novel I found
> myself wondering how Merou managed to get that bottle, containing his
> message, back into space.
>
> Dave
>
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39893 From: James Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "shanter2002" <john@...> wrote:
> the lovely James.

Dems fightin' words:-)
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39894 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/12/2006
Subject: Richard D. Zanuck's Birthday , 12/13/2006, 12:00 am
.html
.html
Reminder from:   pota's Calendar
Title:   Richard D. Zanuck's Birthday 
Date:   Wednesday December 13, 2006
Time:   All Day
Repeats:   This event repeats every year.
Copyright © 2006  Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved | <.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39895 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
.html
.html
Isn't the DVD version the same as the version that was broadcast in the UK initially?
 
 
Chris L.
 
 
 
"James" < JamesA1102@...  >wrote:
 
>>I believe the DVD version added 10 to 15 minutes to the film that
was
not shown on TV. <<
<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39896 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: who built the Alpha Omega bomb?
.html
.html
Interesting. Hinting at elements in the next story, Ty??    :-)
 
Actually, that ball would be in your court (and by "your", I mean the whole team behind the series) since I don't think Breck claiming responsibility for creating the bomb has appeared anywhere else (novelizations, etc) except REVOLUTION.
 
 
Chris L.
 
 
 
"Ty Templeton" tybunny@...  wrote:
 
>>I always felt Breck was bragging a bit, and that he had been
INVOLVED in the
government project (as was Taylor) but the funding and design certainly came
from the taxpayer. No doubt Taylor and Breck knew each other, as did
Hasslein.

Ty the Guy. Plotting, not dialogue. <<
 
 
Chris Lawless <lawford42@juno. com> wrote:
 
>>While thinking about the POTA timeline earlier today, I
realized
something that I'm not sure has been addressed or not. In REVOLUTION,
Breck says that he "conceived, commissioned, and funded" (or something to
that effect) the Doomsday bomb, which implies that it was built when
Breck was in a position of power. So then, how did Taylor (in BENEATH)
know about it's existence? He would have had to know when he left Earth,
which is almost 20 years prior to CONQUEST/REVOLUTION . Even
conservatively placing Breck at 40/45 years of age during CONQUEST, I
can't see him having that kind of power when he was in his early 20's.

Thoughts, anyone? <<


<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39897 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: BENEATH trivia
.html
.html
A few odds & ends I found on both Wikipedia and IMDB:
 
 
>>The closing sequence with Taylor dying and accidentally detonating
the doomsday bomb was a last minute change made on the day the scene was filmed. In the original scripted scene, his detonation of the bomb was deliberate. <<
 
I always thought it was deliberate, though maybe a little more so in the original (final draft) of the shooting script (which was used in Marvel's adaptation of BENEATH).
 
 
>>The film's themes of a future world where intelligent animals had
evolved to supplant man as the dominant form of life on the planet and a society that worshiped a nuclear missile were featured in "Kamandi", a DC Comics comic book series created by acclaimed artist Jack Kirby. <<
 
 
Anyone know if this is true or not? I may have to pick up those hardcover reprints if that's the case.
 
 
>> The Alpha Omega bomb design was inspired by the 7mm Remington
Magnum rifle cartridge. <<
 
I'd never heard this before. Makes sense when you look at it though: 
 
 
>>A heavily edited version of the film was shown on British
television c.1991 which excised most of the violent and horrific scenes, most notably from the last third of the film, including both scenes where Brent is forced to attack Nova, the revelation of the underground humans true appearance, the fight Brent & Taylor are forced to have in the prison cell, and much of the shoot-out at the film's climax. <<
 
Can any of our UK fans shed some light on this one?
 
 
There's more info on each site, in case anyone is interested.
 
 
Chris L.
 
 
 
 
 
 
<.html
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39898 From: Ty Templeton Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
.html
>>The film's themes of a future world where intelligent animals had
evolved to supplant man as the dominant form of life on the planet and a society that worshiped a nuclear missile were featured in "Kamandi", a DC Comics comic book series created by acclaimed artist Jack Kirby. <<
 
 
Anyone know if this is true or not? I may have to pick up those hardcover reprints if that's the case.<<



Holy cow!  I thought every POTA fan knew about this. 

Yup, Kamandi is "not that loosely" based on Planet of the Apes, and even in the face of such clear cut intellectual theft, the series is a high water mark in the career of the King.  I consider it second only to the Fantastic Four as Jack's best sustained work.  The series was ALL about the world after the Great Disaster, when the cities were destroyed and a great number of different animal species gain the power of speech and reason.  Not just apes  (although gorillas feature PROMINENTLY throughout the series), but tigers, dogs, snakes, bears and cats, become rulers of the Earth, in place of an essentially extinct mankind.  The sub-title for the series was "The Last Boy On Earth".  Think of it more as Planet of the Beasts, and you have the series in a nutshell, with a teenager substituting for Taylor.  There's even a "Nova" character, in the form of a sexy, mute female (topless, but for well placed long hair), who followed Kamandi around for much of the series as the love interest.  As in Planet of the Apes, horses and cows remained domestic animals, which led to many covers featuring tigers and bears on horseback. 

One of my favorite comics of the Seventies, a treat for the imagination.

The first issue's cover eveen featured a half destroyed Statue of Liberty, so neither the publisher, nor the artist was being shy about their attempt to glom onto the success of the Apes film franchise. 


http://www.comics.org/coverview.lasso?id=25510&zoom=4

That's a link to the cover for #1.  Here's a link to much info on the series itself, including a cover gallery of every issue cover...check out the CLEAR Planet of the Apes covers on issues # 3, 5, 16, 19

http://www.comics.org/covers.lasso?SeriesID=2028

Hope this helps.

Ty the Guy.  The nexus of things Comics and Apes




 




<.html
Group: pota Message: 39899 From: brendan486 Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: Power Records POTA on You Tube
.html
--- In pota@yahoogroups.com, Chris Lawless <lawford42@...> wrote:
>
> In case anyone is interested:
>
> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFLuInWfGm0
>
> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iks_CDhkrQ8&mode=related&search=
>
>
> Hunter, I hope this wasn't "borrowed" from you...
>
>
> Chris L.
>

Chris,I was interested. It has been years since I heard this and I
had forgotten how hilarious the Voice of Taylor was. Who was the
voice artist? I think it was reminiscient of Mayor Adam West from
the Family Guy.
Brendan.
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39900 From: Hunter Goatley Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
.html
> A few odds & ends I found on both Wikipedia and IMDB:

> >>The closing sequence with Taylor dying and accidentally detonating the
> doomsday bomb was a last minute change made on the day the scene was
> filmed. In the original scripted scene, his detonation of the bomb was
> deliberate. <<

> I always thought it was deliberate, though maybe a little more so in the
> original (final draft) of the shooting script (which was used in Marvel's
> adaptation of BENEATH).

I never thought anyone could possibly think it was accidental. It
always seemed very obviously deliberate to me.

Hunter
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39901 From: Greg Plonowski Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: Marvel UK issue 113
.html
Marvel UK issue 113 is now available to download from Hunter's site. This issue has more of the Battle adaptation, and another installment of the re-printing of the Beneath adaptation. No letter column again this week.
 
 
Thanks,
Greg

 
<.html
Group: pota Message: 39902 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/13/2006
Subject: GOOD news
.html
Attachments :
    Endangered gorillas prosper in heart of Africa
    By Marie-Louise Gumuchian Wed Dec 13, 8:43 AM ET

    PARC NATIONAL DES VOLCANS, Rwanda (Reuters) - One
    hour's trek into the Rwandan rainforest, a crunching
    sound breaks the silence that hangs over the misty
    thick bush.


    Slow and loud, it lasts for a few minutes, then stops
    abruptly. Suddenly a gorilla's face peers through the
    giant nettles to look at the tourists who have sweated
    along jungle trails to catch a glimpse of him and his
    family.

    The 200-kg (440-lb) male, the silver-grey saddle on
    his back signaling maturity, studies his visitors.

    Then, his curiosity satisfied, the mountain gorilla
    emerges from the bush, crawls to the top of a clearing
    on the lush mountainside and continues loudly chomping
    on his bamboo shoot.

    A female follows and stretches out next to the
    silverback, keeping a careful eye on the intruders as
    her babies playfully fight, thumping their chests and
    rolling down the hill.

    Their low-pitched grunts are answered in kind by a
    guide so both humans and gorillas know the others are
    just observing. "Look at those babies," one tourist
    marvels. "Aren't they amazing?"

    Agashya and his family are among the world's 700-odd
    surviving mountain gorillas who live in their natural
    habitats in Rwanda, Uganda and Democratic Republic of
    Congo.

    Split between the Virunga volcanoes which straddle the
    borders of the three central African countries and
    Uganda's Bwindi National Park, the gorillas have
    actually seen their numbers increase in the last few
    years.

    A 2003 census showed a 17 percent increase from 1989
    to 380 mountain gorillas living around the Virunga
    volcanoes in a series of three national parks. About
    320 live in Bwindi.

    "There is no difference in the number of births," said
    Justin Rurangirwa, chief park warden of Rwanda's Parc
    National des Volcans (PNV) where Agashya lives. "What
    has changed is that there's no more poaching."

    POACHING PATROLS

    International studies of mountain gorillas began after
    German explorer Oscar von Beringe became the first
    non-African to encounter one in the Virungas in 1902.

    In the two decades that followed, scientists and
    trophy hunters killed over 50 mountain gorillas, the
    International Gorilla Conservation Program says.
    Hunting and habitat destruction have also driven them
    to the verge of extinction.

    Mountain gorillas are not hunted for bushmeat. Some
    were poached to sell their hands and feet to
    collectors. Others have been maimed or killed by traps
    intended for other animals.

    U.S. researcher Dian Fossey brought the gorillas
    international fame with her efforts to save them from
    poachers.

    Fossey studied the gorillas in Rwanda before her
    murder in 1985 -- her work was the subject of the 1988
    Hollywood movie "Gorillas in the Mist."

    Dedicated anti-poaching and conservation efforts,
    which include close monitoring and working with locals
    to protect the habitat, have helped increase numbers.

    "There is a lot of protection and conservation. Not
    only in Rwanda, Uganda and Congo, the whole world is
    taking part," said guide Francis Bayingana. "We have
    poaching patrols on a daily basis."

    Bayingana said the last poaching incident in the
    Rwandan park was in 2002 when two females were shot
    dead, a baby taken and a silverback injured.

    The gorillas have also been threatened by conflict in
    Congo and Rwanda. Rebels would flit easily across the
    region's borders and sometimes the gorillas were
    caught in crossfire.

    VISIT FOR $375

    With its robust build, long muscular arms, massive
    chest and broad hands and feet, the mountain gorilla
    is closely related to man, sharing 98 percent of its
    genetic material with humans.

    That makes it vulnerable to many of the same diseases
    -- but without necessary immunities so that a sickness
    that may seem harmless to humans can be dangerous for
    gorillas.

    Tourists are told to stand at a certain distance from
    the gorillas they encounter and must turn away to
    cough.

    A maximum of eight people are allowed to visit a group
    each day and stay for just one hour. Each foreign
    visitor pays $375 for the experience in Rwanda, where
    seven groups of gorillas have become used to receiving
    visitors.

    To see the gorillas, which live 2,500 metres (8,200
    ft) above sea level with some roaming higher, visitors
    trek on muddy trails across rugged slopes covered in
    bamboo, moss and stumps.

    Hundreds visit every month and numbers are growing,
    giving Rwanda's government a powerful incentive to
    protect the animals in a country better known to many
    for a 1994 genocide in which around 800,000 people
    were killed.

    "Gorillas are our national pride," Bayingana said.
    "There has to be promotion of conservation."

    About 10,650 tourists came to Rwanda's park last year.
    Up to November this year, nearly 12,000 had been, park
    figures show.

    Agashya's Group 13 is the only one at the park which
    has seen its numbers increase dramatically. From 7
    members in 2002, Group 13 now counts 20 members. Other
    groups are stable, although in the largest, rare twins
    were born in 2004.

    Although strong and powerful, the gorillas are
    generally gentle. Tourists are told how to behave in
    their presence -- whisper, no pointing, eating or
    shouting when stung by a nettle.

    Leaving bags and walking sticks with porters, they can
    take cameras with them but no flash photography is
    allowed.

    And if a gorilla charges, stand still unless told to
    crouch or move back. Despite the fearful looks from
    the animals, Bayingana is reassuring.

    "They don't mind our presence," he said. "They do what
    they do unless we disturb them."



    ________________________
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39903 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/14/2006
    Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
    .html
    .html
    Thanks for the info/links Ty.
     
    I was aware of the series and a general resemblance to POTA, but I didn't realize to what extent it actually mirrored the concepts. Was there actually an issue that featured an society that worshipped a nuclear missile?
     
    BTW (on a *slightly* related note)- anyone who's Jack Kirby fan should really check out the show 'Minoriteam' on Adult Swim. It's a great tribute to both Jack Kirby and The Marvel Superheroes cartoon series from 1966. Returns to the schedule in February.
     
     
    Chris L.
     
     
     
    "Ty Templeton" tybunny@...  wrote:
     
    >>Holy cow! I thought every POTA fan knew about this.

    Yup, Kamandi is "not that loosely" based on Planet of the Apes, and even in
    the face of such clear cut intellectual theft, the series is a high water
    mark in the career of the King. I consider it second only to the Fantastic
    Four as Jack's best sustained work. The series was ALL about the world
    after the Great Disaster, when the cities were destroyed and a great number
    of different animal species gain the power of speech and reason. Not just
    apes (although gorillas feature PROMINENTLY throughout the series), but
    tigers, dogs, snakes, bears and cats, become rulers of the Earth, in place
    of an essentially extinct mankind. The sub-title for the series was "The
    Last Boy On Earth". Think of it more as Planet of the Beasts, and you have
    the series in a nutshell, with a teenager substituting for Taylor. There's
    even a "Nova" character, in the form of a sexy, mute female (topless, but
    for well placed long hair), who followed Kamandi around for much of the
    series as the love interest. As in Planet of the Apes, horses and cows
    remained domestic animals, which led to many covers featuring tigers and
    bears on horseback.

    One of my favorite comics of the Seventies, a treat for the imagination.

    The first issue's cover eveen featured a half destroyed Statue of Liberty,
    so neither the publisher, nor the artist was being shy about their attempt
    to glom onto the success of the Apes film franchise.

    http://www.comics. org/coverview. lasso?id= 25510&zoom= 4

    That's a link to the cover for #1. Here's a link to much info on the series
    itself, including a cover gallery of every issue cover...check out the CLEAR
    Planet of the Apes covers on issues # 3, 5, 16, 19

    http://www.comics. org/covers. lasso?SeriesID= 2028

    Hope this helps.  <<
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39904 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/14/2006
    Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
    .html
    Kirby was, and is, King, no doubt about it.He actually did some
    Planet of the Apes art when he did some designs for a planned 80s
    animated series loosely based on the TV Series. Apes and Kirby--it
    don't get no better than that! John, Scrolls.
    >
    > >>The film's themes of a future world where intelligent animals had
    evolved
    > to supplant man as the dominant form of life on the planet and a
    society
    > that worshiped a nuclear missile were featured in
    *"Kamandi<http://wiki/Kamandi>
    > "*, a DC Comics <http://wiki/DC_Comics> comic book
    > <http://wiki/Comic_book>series created by acclaimed artist Jack
    > Kirby <http://wiki/Jack_Kirby>. <<
    >
    >
    > Anyone know if this is true or not? I may have to pick up those
    hardcover
    > reprints if that's the case.<<
    >
    >
    >
    > Holy cow! I thought every POTA fan knew about this.
    >
    > Yup, Kamandi is "not that loosely" based on Planet of the Apes, and
    even in
    > the face of such clear cut intellectual theft, the series is a high
    water
    > mark in the career of the King. I consider it second only to the
    Fantastic
    > Four as Jack's best sustained work. The series was ALL about the
    world
    > after the Great Disaster, when the cities were destroyed and a
    great number
    > of different animal species gain the power of speech and reason.
    Not just
    > apes (although gorillas feature PROMINENTLY throughout the
    series), but
    > tigers, dogs, snakes, bears and cats, become rulers of the Earth,
    in place
    > of an essentially extinct mankind. The sub-title for the series
    was "The
    > Last Boy On Earth". Think of it more as Planet of the Beasts, and
    you have
    > the series in a nutshell, with a teenager substituting for Taylor.
    There's
    > even a "Nova" character, in the form of a sexy, mute female
    (topless, but
    > for well placed long hair), who followed Kamandi around for much of
    the
    > series as the love interest. As in Planet of the Apes, horses and
    cows
    > remained domestic animals, which led to many covers featuring
    tigers and
    > bears on horseback.
    >
    > One of my favorite comics of the Seventies, a treat for the
    imagination.
    >
    > The first issue's cover eveen featured a half destroyed Statue of
    Liberty,
    > so neither the publisher, nor the artist was being shy about their
    attempt
    > to glom onto the success of the Apes film franchise.
    >
    >
    > http://www.comics.org/coverview.lasso?id=25510&zoom=4
    >
    > That's a link to the cover for #1. Here's a link to much info on
    the series
    > itself, including a cover gallery of every issue cover...check out
    the CLEAR
    > Planet of the Apes covers on issues # 3, 5, 16, 19
    >
    > http://www.comics.org/covers.lasso?SeriesID=2028
    >
    > Hope this helps.
    >
    > Ty the Guy. The nexus of things Comics and Apes
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39905 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/14/2006
    Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams
    .html
    .html
    What was the number of the most recent issue? I'm drawing a complete blank right now...
     
     
    Chris L.
     
     
     
    "shanter2002" < john@... > wrote:
     
    >>We're aiming at Feb 2007 and ordering details will appear on this
    Group, courtesy of the lovely James.We have, courtesy of the even more
    lovely Kass(please don't tell her I said that) a US ordering option.
    We'll keep everyone posted.We've learned over the years that Christmas
    and New Year must be avoided as release dates!Mort's niece is entitled
    to a free copy for having such a great uncle, so if we get a postal
    address, that would be our pleasure. <<<.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39906 From: gp3085 Date: 12/14/2006
    Subject: Re: Mort Abrahams and Simian Scrolls
    .html
    Issue 12 was the most recent. It came out earlier this year.

    Greg

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, Chris Lawless <lawford42@...> wrote:
    >
    > What was the number of the most recent issue? I'm drawing a complete
    > blank right now...
    >
    >
    > Chris L.
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39907 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/15/2006
    Subject: Re: Power Records POTA on You Tube
    .html
    .html
    I don't know if anyone ever figured out who did what. One of these days I'll have to look around for some Power Records sites and see if any info was available.
     
    I've always thought that they were pretty ambitious projects, and the artwork in the POTA releases in particular was very well done. The image of the unmasked mutants creeped me out so much as a kid that I couldn't even look at it. Some of the music in the adaptations was pretty interesting too. Presumably it was all stock library music, but the cues that were chosen accompanied the scenes exceptionally well.
     
    After watching the You Tube version, I remembered how some of the sound effects were used a few times throughout i.e. the background noises from when Taylor is beating the gorilla hunter in the beginning ("THIS is for Dodge, and THIS is for Landon!!") is used again when Julius is beating Taylor for stealing Zira's clipboard and also when Lucius is helping Taylor escape ("Hit him Bright Eyes!"). Also some of the same voice actors doing different parts i.e. Landon, Dr. Galen, Lucius, and the gorilla guard who says "I've told the authorities about your talking trick Bright Eyes." were all voiced by the same person who supplied Brent's voice in the BENEATH adaptation. The fact that the same guy voiced Taylor in both PLANET and BENEATH shows that at least someone was paying attention to detail, though I have to admit Brendan that I don't quite hear Mayor West there.   :-) 
     
     
    Chris L.
     
     
     
    "brendan486" < nzape@...
    > wrote:
     
    >>Chris,I was interested. It has been years since I heard this and I
    had forgotten how hilarious the Voice of Taylor was. Who was the
    voice artist? I think it was reminiscient of Mayor Adam West from
    the Family Guy. <<
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39908 From: James Date: 12/15/2006
    Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
    .html

    This week's LESSON FROM THE LAWGIVER is now available. This is the final chapter of the special 5 part LESSON. Thanks to Glen Scheetz and all who contributed.

    To view the LESSON click on the banner on the Yahoo Home page or use this link: http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/files/LFTL.htm.

    Visit all the Group's special features including:

    Also, be sure to join our sub-groups:

    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39909 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/16/2006
    Subject: Re: BENEATH trivia
    .html
    .html
    Was there ever any definitive info released about this past the fact that it was in the planning stages? That really could have been interesting if it had been given a chance. I wonder if it would have been a more serialized type of storytelling like RETURN was (or KAMANDI for that matter)? It's a shame it never happened.
     
     
    Chris L.
     
     
     
    "shanter2002" < john@... > wrote:
     
    >>Kirby was, and is, King, no doubt about it.He actually did some
    Planet of the Apes art when he did some designs for a planned 80s
    animated series loosely based on the TV Series. Apes and Kirby--it
    don't get no better than that! <<<.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39910 From: David Giwner Date: 12/16/2006
    Subject: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Just my wild imagination here. I was talking to a woman yesterday who had 2 talking parrots.
    I was thinking why werent there any parrots on POTA?
    I would have loved to see a Gorillas face when he heard a parrot talk.......
    Imagine Brent's facial expression when Cornelious told him not to speak to the Gorrilas....
    Classic.....
     
    Happy Holidays
    Dave-NYC.....

    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39911 From: Chris Lawless Date: 12/17/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    .html
    There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember, save for the dog in the TV series. Wonder if that was intentional or not, and if so, was it a statement being made about how one animal species would or wouldn't treat another?
     
     
    Chris L.
     
     
     
    "David Giwner" < bikergator25@... >
     
    >>Just my wild imagination here. I was talking to a woman yesterday
    who had 2 talking parrots.
    I was thinking why werent there any parrots on POTA?
    I would have loved to see a Gorillas face when he heard a parrot talk.......
    Imagine Brent's facial expression when Cornelious told him not to speak to the Gorrilas....
    Classic..... <<<.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39912 From: Glen Date: 12/17/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Horses and cows, too...

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, Chris Lawless <lawford42@...> wrote:
    >
    > There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember, save
    for
    > the dog in the TV series. Wonder if that was intentional or not,
    and if
    > so, was it a statement being made about how one animal species
    would or
    > wouldn't treat another?
    >
    >
    > Chris L.
    >
    >
    >
    > "David Giwner" < bikergator25@... >
    >
    > >>Just my wild imagination here. I was talking to a woman yesterday
    who
    > had 2 talking parrots.
    > I was thinking why werent there any parrots on POTA?
    > I would have loved to see a Gorillas face when he heard a parrot
    > talk.......
    > Imagine Brent's facial expression when Cornelious told him not to
    speak
    > to the Gorrilas....
    > Classic..... <<
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39913 From: James Date: 12/17/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    In Planet the only animals seen are horses and humans. In Beneath at
    least one bird is shown after the Gorilla shoots Brent. There are
    numerous animals in Escape but none in Conquest. In Battle Cornelius
    has his squirrel and rabbits are mentioned. The TV series had the dog
    plus several species of farm animals and a scorpion.
    The cartoon series & comics had several mutated monsters which I'm glad
    the live-action films & series never induldged in.


    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Glen" <HotScheetz@...> wrote:
    >
    > Horses and cows, too...
    >
    > G
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39914 From: Dave B Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    When Zira first speaks to the Inquest during 'Escape' her simple
    answers are compared to those of a Parrot. Her response 'A PARROT!"
    seems quite indignant from which I assume she knows what a parrot is
    and is offended by being compared to one...

    One could also argue that her response is merely one of confusion ("A
    Parrot?")

    Is this line in the script?

    Dave
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39915 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Young Cornelius had Ricky, his pet squirrel.John, Scrolls.
    >
    > There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember, save
    for
    > the dog in the TV series. Wonder if that was intentional or not,
    and if
    > so, was it a statement being made about how one animal species
    would or
    > wouldn't treat another?
    >
    >
    > Chris L.
    >
    >
    >
    > "David Giwner" < bikergator25@... >
    >
    > >>Just my wild imagination here. I was talking to a woman yesterday
    who
    > had 2 talking parrots.
    > I was thinking why werent there any parrots on POTA?
    > I would have loved to see a Gorillas face when he heard a parrot
    > talk.......
    > Imagine Brent's facial expression when Cornelious told him not to
    speak
    > to the Gorrilas....
    > Classic..... <<
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39916 From: David Giwner Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Dave, you are so right,. I forgot about that scene.
    Dave-NYC...

    Dave B <smugster2000@...> wrote:
    When Zira first speaks to the Inquest during 'Escape' her simple
    answers are compared to those of a Parrot. Her response 'A PARROT!"
    seems quite indignant from which I assume she knows what a parrot is
    and is offended by being compared to one...

    One could also argue that her response is merely one of confusion ("A
    Parrot?")

    Is this line in the script?

    Dave


    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39917 From: David Giwner Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Yeah, you are  right. But it did not talk.
    I was thinking about what Dr. Zaius siad about the apes being Gods chosen..
    Dave-NYC

    shanter2002 <john@...> wrote:
    Young Cornelius had Ricky, his pet squirrel.John, Scrolls.
    >
    > There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember, save
    for
    > the dog in the TV series. Wonder if that was intentional or not,
    and if
    > so, was it a statement being made about how one animal species
    would or
    > wouldn't treat another?
    >
    >
    > Chris L.
    >
    >
    >
    > "David Giwner" < bikergator25@ ... >
    >
    > >>Just my wild imagination here. I was talking to a woman yesterday
    who
    > had 2 talking parrots.
    > I was thinking why werent there any parrots on POTA?
    > I would have loved to see a Gorillas face when he heard a parrot
    > talk.......
    > Imagine Brent's facial expression when Cornelious told him not to
    speak
    > to the Gorrilas....
    > Classic..... <<
    >


    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39918 From: brendan486 Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Since the Apes speak English, could this comment about being
    compared to a Parrot be a reference to the colloquial/idiomatic use
    of the word 'parrot.'
    i.e. someone who is nothing but a mimic.Someone who mimics.
    Zira may not even know that the word represented a specie of bird.
    It is still insulting to be compared to someone who mimics only as
    it implies they have no ability to think for oneself.
    Brendan



    -- In pota@yahoogroups.com, David Giwner <bikergator25@...> wrote:
    >
    > Dave, you are so right,. I forgot about that scene.
    > Dave-NYC...
    >
    > Dave B <smugster2000@...> wrote:
    > When Zira first speaks to the Inquest during 'Escape'
    her simple
    > answers are compared to those of a Parrot. Her response 'A PARROT!"
    > seems quite indignant from which I assume she knows what a parrot
    is
    > and is offended by being compared to one...
    >
    > One could also argue that her response is merely one of confusion
    ("A
    > Parrot?")
    >
    > Is this line in the script?
    >
    > Dave
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39919 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    .html
    In a message dated 12/17/2006 5:38:11 P.M. Central Standard Time, lawford42@... writes:
    There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember
     
    And yet when Zira is compared to a parrot
    she seems to know what they're talking about.
     
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39920 From: LordTZer0@AOL.com Date: 12/18/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    .html
    In a message dated 12/18/2006 12:39:22 A.M. Central Standard Time, smugster2000@... writes:
    Her response 'A PARROT!"
    seems quite indignant from which I assume she knows what a parrot is
    and is offended by being compared to one...

    One could also argue that her response is merely one of confusion ("A
    Parrot?")
     
    More like righteous indignation.
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39921 From: Jonathan Date: 12/19/2006
    Subject: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    Greetings All :-)

    I've been a member of this group for a while now,
    and though I've been largely a lurker here- primarily
    because I've been so busy elsewhere, namely with run-
    ning an RP on Yahoo and being a busy 3D and photoma-
    nipulation artist, in addition to work and the other
    time-consuming aspects of real life- but I come here
    from time to time to partake in the posted exchsanges
    between the active members here, in addition to using
    the various wonderful POTA links to be found here.

    Anyway, to get more to the point; While going through
    the messages here from the last month or so, a link was
    posted, leading to the website of 'THE HASSLEIN CURVE-
    A Timeline of the Planet of the Apes, to be found at...
    http://rhandley.0catch.com/POTA/timeline_01.html"

    Being deeply interested in the POTA saga, I was
    compelled to read most of it, when I cam across some-
    thing I didn't expect, a full mention of 'inter-species
    relations' between 'unrelated' Ape species, namely that
    of a love, and sex, shared between a female Chimpanzee
    and a male Gorilla. Noted on the last page of the very
    extensive chronology, an exerpt is below, with full
    credit to the author, of course, and I quote;

    ------------------------------------------------------
    Early 3900s

    A female chimpanzee and a male gorilla elope to Wambo
    Province to escape persecution for their forbidden
    cross-species love.

    Return to the Planet of the Apes episode #7: "River
    of Flames" (BB-n)

    NOTE: This information comes from the novelization
    of the episode, entitled Return to the Planet of
    the Apes #3: Man, the Hunted Animal.

    The gorilla's name is Truga.

    Return to the Planet of the Apes episode #2: "Escape
    from Ape City" (BB-n)

    NOTE: This information comes from the novelization
    of the episode, entitled Return to the Planet of
    the Apes #1: Visions from Nowhere.

    Their grandson, Mungwort, later faces racial pre-
    judice because of his resultant mixed heritage.

    Return to the Planet of the Apes episode #7: "River
    of Flames" (BB-n)

    NOTE: This information comes from the novelization
    of the episode, entitled Return to the Planet of the
    Apes #3: Man, the Hunted Animal.
    ------------------------------------------------------

    Now... I don't know if the subject of such inter-Ape
    relations has much been discussed here, or even if it is
    completely appropriate, but I'd like to discuss this
    subject in a mature and adult context with anyone inter-
    ested.

    I'd like to first note that I an something of a
    student of history, and history indeed does include
    the examination of society over time, including the
    study of social morals, standards and laws, when it
    comes to the matter of 'sex'... and venial relations
    between people deemed to be of different social stand-
    ing, and... 'race'

    It is notable that in Human history, even in the
    U.S. of the 20th century, some laws, especially in
    the U.S. South, made it illegal for persons of dif-
    ferent races to 'intermix' in an intimate or carnal
    way, and certainly racial intermarriage was indeed
    quite forbidden. This was considered to be a true
    crime, and was legally severely punishable. Thank
    God such laws are not currently upheald, and in most
    cases have been removed from the books.

    The mixing of the Human races, known as 'miscege-
    nation', is still, in this modern world of the 21st
    Century, unfortunately, frowned upon in many places,
    either passively or actively. In some places the
    intermarrying of a Christian to a Jew or an Arab
    can result in legal sanctions or horrific public
    uproar, which can result in imprisonment, injury,
    or death. It's depressing that such prejudices still
    exist in this day and age.

    Anyway... POTA is loaded with prejudices, namely
    that of Humans Vs. Apes in particular, and very
    likely within Ape society itself on many levels.

    Notable however... is that Ape society isn't com-
    prised of just one race as with Humans, but made up
    of three distinctly different sentient species, each
    having evolved on three different branches of the
    Ape line of generally-related limb of the evolution-
    ary tree. The distinctions between them are clear,
    ad in spite of their general similarities, it's
    amazing that they intermix at all beyond perhaps
    a limited commercial/trade level. More than that
    ther share the same city, blocks, and homes and
    places of work, being fully interactive on virtually
    all social levels. Other than the fact that they are
    al generally Apes, the only thing that seems to be
    holding them together as a society of mixed species,
    is their central beliefs, which they all seem to
    generally agree upon. It's further amazing because
    in nature... the three Ape forms don't mix, and when
    they meet- there's terrible and often violent con-
    flict.

    More to the point, in such a society, the subject
    of sex between these three species is one, which if
    looked at realistically, must be one of serious in-
    terest and consideration. Whether or not the three
    species in some combination or another can interbreed
    is to a large degree irrelavant, as surely there are
    either laws or moral standards in place that forbid
    intimate- i.e. a 'sexual relations', between the three.
    Even if punitive measures are not in place, there cer-
    tainly must be common moral social standards in place
    that could bring serious social consequences upon those
    whom would risk such behavior, contrary to those stan-
    dards. The consternation of local citizens can bring
    great pressure upon such individuals that break the
    social rules. 'Offenders' risk being ostrasized by
    their families, and possible exile from their homes,
    community, or their homeland. The matter is indeed
    even more serious in their society, if a hybrid off-
    spring is the result.

    My question to any interested members here is;
    How much of a problem do you think this is in the
    mixed Ape society that we have come to know so well,
    with many questions... not answered, and likely not
    forthcoming? How often do you think such things
    occur? And perhaps, is hybridization actually even
    possible betwen any of the three, or do they naturally
    remain 'pure', in the same sense that cats and dogs
    cannot interbreed?

    I'll be very interested in hearing your feedback
    on this matter. Thankyou :-)

    Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39922 From: Paul Date: 12/19/2006
    Subject: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
    .html
    My name is Paul, and I live in the Seattle area (from Detroit). I am
    43 years old, remember watching the firt POTA movie when it came out.
    I was a kid watching it from the back seat with my parents watching
    from the front seat. It was amazing for me at the time.

    Today, I am still in love with watching these Apes videos. I also have
    a bunch of figures as well.

    Does anyone enjoy watching the POTA cartoons as much as I do?

    I want to get some of the comics next, and the series even though it
    wasn't that good.

    Very respectfully, Paul
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39923 From: Greg Plonowski Date: 12/20/2006
    Subject: Marvel UK issue 114
    .html
    The latest issue is now available to download from Hunter's site. This issue continues both the Battle adaptation and the reprinting of the Beneath adaptation. As a special holiday bonus, the letter column is back, with two pages of letters for all you letter column fans.
     
    I'll be traveling next Wednesday and won't have internet access, so you're all on your own to find your way to Hunter's site to download issue 115 next week.
     
    Hope you all have a nice, safe holiday.
     
    Greg
     
     
     
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39924 From: David Giwner Date: 12/20/2006
    Subject: Re: Parrots on POTA
    .html
    Yes, you  are right. SO I guess the parrots where around.
    Dave-NYC

    LordTZer0@... wrote:
    In a message dated 12/17/2006 5:38:11 P.M. Central Standard Time, lawford42@juno. com writes:
    There really weren't any domesticated animals that I remember
     
    And yet when Zira is compared to a parrot
    she seems to know what they're talking about.
     

    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of

    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39925 From: Glen Date: 12/20/2006
    Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
    .html
    Hi Paul, Welcome aboard...You'll find people here that luv every
    aspect of POTA -- even Burton...=)

    You might want to check out Hunter's site, where he has most every
    comic on Apes uploaded...https://pota.goatley.com/

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Paul" <p3murds@...> wrote:
    >
    > My name is Paul, and I live in the Seattle area (from Detroit). I am
    > 43 years old, remember watching the firt POTA movie when it came
    out.
    > I was a kid watching it from the back seat with my parents watching
    > from the front seat. It was amazing for me at the time.
    >
    > Today, I am still in love with watching these Apes videos. I also
    have
    > a bunch of figures as well.
    >
    > Does anyone enjoy watching the POTA cartoons as much as I do?
    >
    > I want to get some of the comics next, and the series even though it
    > wasn't that good.
    >
    > Very respectfully, Paul
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39926 From: p3murds@aol.com Date: 12/20/2006
    Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
    .html
    .html
    The goatley site is great!  Thanks!  ~Paul
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39927 From: Paul Date: 12/20/2006
    Subject: Re: NEW TO THE POTA MESSAGE BOARD
    .html
    Sorry, I guess I should have called it Hunter's Site! I love it, and
    now I can read all those comics! I am looking forward to getting a
    collection of these books myself via Ebay of course!

    Here is another thing, I know that the last POTA movie wasn't
    considered good by many, but I disagree with not wanting another one
    made if some how anyone was considering doing so. I do think that the
    last movie left things very open for a sequel the could be great.

    Very respectfully Paul Wright


    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, p3murds@... wrote:
    >
    > The goatley site is great! Thanks! ~Paul
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39928 From: Paul Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: APE CITY WEBSITE
    .html
    Have any of you seen this site? Is the Ape-City.com website out of
    commision? I enjoyed it the first time I seen it, But had an email
    rejected when I sent it to the webmaster. Does this person frequent
    this board? I guess his name is Andrew Parmet (according to the
    website). Still, even though no updates, it is entertaining.

    ~Paul
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39929 From: James Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
    .html
    The site is still up and working. It hasn't been updated though. Andrew
    is a member here but has been quiet recently.

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Paul" <p3murds@...> wrote:
    >
    > Have any of you seen this site? Is the Ape-City.com website out of
    > commision? I enjoyed it the first time I seen it, But had an email
    > rejected when I sent it to the webmaster. Does this person frequent
    > this board? I guess his name is Andrew Parmet (according to the
    > website). Still, even though no updates, it is entertaining.
    >
    > ~Paul
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39930 From: James Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html

    First, welcome to the group Jon.

    In answer to your question, the classic films or the TV series never covered this subject. It would have been an interesting topic for the TV series to explore. Since that society was a caste system with each species having an assigned role, I would imagine that extra-species relationships were frowned upon.

    In the remake, we do see an elderly orangutan married to a Chimp trophy wife. So in that society interspecies marrige was acceptable. Or maybe they weren't married and it was just a civil union;-) 

     


    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Jonathan" <phil_harmonik2005@...> wrote:
    >
    >
    > My question to any interested members here is;
    > How much of a problem do you think this is in the
    > mixed Ape society that we have come to know so well,
    > with many questions... not answered, and likely not
    > forthcoming? How often do you think such things
    > occur? And perhaps, is hybridization actually even
    > possible betwen any of the three, or do they naturally
    > remain 'pure', in the same sense that cats and dogs
    > cannot interbreed?
    >
    > I'll be very interested in hearing your feedback
    > on this matter. Thankyou :-)
    >
    > Jon Rich
    >

    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39931 From: shanter2002 Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    And in the novels of the animated series, one of the gorillas is
    derided for having a chimp grandparent.John, Scrolls.
    >
    >
    > First, welcome to the group Jon.
    >
    > In answer to your question, the classic films or the TV series never
    > covered this subject. It would have been an interesting topic for
    the TV
    > series to explore. Since that society was a caste system with each
    > species having an assigned role, I would imagine that extra-species
    > relationships were frowned upon.
    >
    > In the remake, we do see an elderly orangutan married to a Chimp
    trophy
    > wife. So in that society interspecies marrige was acceptable. Or
    maybe
    > they weren't married and it was just a civil union;-)
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Jonathan" <phil_harmonik2005@> wrote:
    > >
    > >
    > > My question to any interested members here is;
    > > How much of a problem do you think this is in the
    > > mixed Ape society that we have come to know so well,
    > > with many questions... not answered, and likely not
    > > forthcoming? How often do you think such things
    > > occur? And perhaps, is hybridization actually even
    > > possible betwen any of the three, or do they naturally
    > > remain 'pure', in the same sense that cats and dogs
    > > cannot interbreed?
    > >
    > > I'll be very interested in hearing your feedback
    > > on this matter. Thankyou :-)
    > >
    > > Jon Rich
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39932 From: Jonathan Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Jonathan" <phil_harmonik2005@> wrote:
    > >
    > > My question to any interested members here is;
    > > How much of a problem do you think this is in the
    > > mixed Ape society that we have come to know so well,
    > > with many questions... not answered, and likely not
    > > forthcoming? How often do you think such things
    > > occur? And perhaps, is hybridization actually even
    > > possible betwen any of the three, or do they naturally
    > > remain 'pure', in the same sense that cats and dogs
    > > cannot interbreed?
    > >
    > > I'll be very interested in hearing your feedback
    > > on this matter. Thankyou :-)
    > >
    > > Jon Rich

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "James" <JamesA1102@...> wrote:
    >
    > First, welcome to the group Jon.

    Thankyou :-)

    > In answer to your question, the classic films or
    > the TV series never covered this subject.

    Indeed it didn't. And the TV series in parti-
    cular would have been a marvelous forum to explore
    it, since it had many more opportunities to do so
    that the cinema films didn't.

    The concept of 'forbidden relationships' or
    'forbidden love' in storylines goes back before
    even Romeo and Juliette- where warring families
    are the center of the forbidden love of the young
    couple, and for more modern times, and prior to
    the POTA TV series, TV shows like Star Trek ex-
    plored prejudice deeply [Let That Be Your Last
    Battlefield] and for TV defined the first inter-
    racial kiss [Plato's Stepchildren]. And since
    POTA-TV came somewhat later tha trek, I'm surprised
    that the writers weren't brave enough to explore
    the issue.

    > It would have been an interesting topic for the
    > TV series to explore. Since that society was a
    > caste system with each species having an assigned
    > role, I would imagine that extra-species relation-
    > ships were frowned upon.

    I think... that the problem was actually more
    centered on limits placed by the producers of the
    TV version. They didn't want to risk allegations
    or accusations of 'bestiality' in 'any' form. They
    took note, likely, of Taylor's kissing of Zira, as
    some fededback told that some people felt that that
    was such- so it was something of a real issue with
    some people. The producers of the TV version wan-
    ted to avoid the issue in any context. They had
    advertisers they didn't want to offend. As usual-
    it again boils down to 'money', tempered by the
    moral standards of the time.

    And interesting... considering that in these more
    recent times, TV shows like 'Hercules' quite often
    touched upon interspecies relationships, and... in-
    terbreeding, rooted in the actual Ancient greek
    myths. Good to see that times have changed :-)
    The subject is approached now in a more adult con-
    text now, and truer to the real history of the
    mythology.

    > In the remake, we do see an elderly orangutan mar-
    > ried to a Chimp trophy wife. So in that society
    > interspecies marrige was acceptable. Or maybe they
    > weren't married and it was just a civil union;-)

    I noted that too, though the Tim Burton film never
    addresed that situation. However, it does indeed ap-
    pear that in his version, such relationships weren't
    frowned upon, as it was taking place right in front of
    their highest leaders right there at the dinner table!
    One can presume that such was allowed in TB's version
    of Ape culture, at least in 'his' interpretation of it.
    But then again... he made many such 'adjustments'. It's
    not really the same culture. It's... a very different
    Ape planet. But then again, there's a lot of odd things
    about that film.

    Anyway... on the subject of miscegenation, I per-
    sonally think that the Ape culture would have similar
    problems dealing with it that many societies do in
    our world of today, and even... in free America, as
    the subject of racial and societal intermixing is still
    a deep issue with many people... unfortunately.

    The Ape movies, I can see, from the perspective of
    the Apes, defined Humans as 'one people'. Just... 'the
    Humans'. The Apes then become a parody of us... and
    our differences, the barriers we put up or still main-
    tain, the Humans becoming mindless innocents in the jungle
    while the Apes with their prejudices and corruptions re-
    flect... what Humans 'once' were. Or... still are...
    in the form of the underground Mutants. POTA as a form
    of commentary on our society it obvious, and hard to deny.
    The worst of what were are is defined... in them. And it
    can be hard... to look into that mirror...

    ~ Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39933 From: Jonathan Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "shanter2002" <john@...> wrote:
    >
    > And in the novels of the animated series, one of
    > the gorillas is derided for having a chimp grand-
    > parent. John, Scrolls.

    Well... if the animated series for POTA is accepted
    as Ape 'canon', and the novels too, then it tells that
    the Apes, especially the Gorillas and Chimps, can in-
    deed interbreed. And... jst as many humans of today,
    the child of mixed blood endures some real social ne-
    gativity for being such. it defines that Apes are
    just as prejudiced as many of us real life Humans are,
    and again... the Apes are a refelction in parody, of
    ourselves. More social commentary.

    I have noticed that in many stories, and in many
    role playing games that may involve anything from
    Elves and Gnomes to Aliens and Furries... Humans are
    often held up as examples of what 'not' to be like.
    the way of Humans... is to be avoided. But with POTA,
    the Apes are more reflections of ourselves, mirror
    of Humankind.

    And perhaps, just like in the evolutionary sense,
    as POTA defines, the Apes are not that far removed
    from us, since we ourselves evolved from an Ape-like
    ancestor. And it stands as social commentary, and
    most episodes serve as morality plays, as many are
    designed to. They are lessons... that we're expected
    to learn something from.

    ~ Jon Rich.
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39934 From: Paul Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
    .html
    Oh, thats good! As I mentioned, I once tried to email him, but the
    email was returned. ~Paul

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "James" <JamesA1102@...> wrote:
    >
    > The site is still up and working. It hasn't been updated though.
    Andrew
    > is a member here but has been quiet recently.
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Paul" <p3murds@> wrote:
    > >
    > > Have any of you seen this site? Is the Ape-City.com website out of
    > > commision? I enjoyed it the first time I seen it, But had an email
    > > rejected when I sent it to the webmaster. Does this person
    frequent
    > > this board? I guess his name is Andrew Parmet (according to the
    > > website). Still, even though no updates, it is entertaining.
    > >
    > > ~Paul
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39935 From: Glen Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: APE CITY WEBSITE
    .html
    I found this when I went on the site:

    New site with actual content coming soon! In the meantime, if there's
    something you'd like to see added, let me know.

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "James" <JamesA1102@...> wrote:
    >
    > The site is still up and working. It hasn't been updated though.
    Andrew
    > is a member here but has been quiet recently.
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Paul" <p3murds@> wrote:
    > >
    > > Have any of you seen this site? Is the Ape-City.com website out of
    > > commision? I enjoyed it the first time I seen it, But had an email
    > > rejected when I sent it to the webmaster. Does this person
    frequent
    > > this board? I guess his name is Andrew Parmet (according to the
    > > website). Still, even though no updates, it is entertaining.
    > >
    > > ~Paul
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39936 From: brendan486 Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Jonathan" <phil_harmonik2005@...> wrote:
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "shanter2002" <john@> wrote:
    > >
    > > And in the novels of the animated series, one of
    > > the gorillas is derided for having a chimp grand-
    > > parent. John, Scrolls.
    >
    > Well... if the animated series for POTA is accepted
    > as Ape 'canon', and the novels too, then it tells that
    > the Apes, especially the Gorillas and Chimps, can in-
    > deed interbreed.

    Are we to understand that since there are no examples of interbreeding
    with Orangutangs that even in Ape Society there is prejudice against
    people with Ginger Hair!!!!
    Well, it seems that Apes are no better than Humans afterall.
    Brendan ;- )
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39937 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the original
    PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows the
    full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is the
    version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    image, and details about it, are in my blog:

    http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-revealed.html"

    All best wishes.

    Rob


    ----------------
    ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer

    Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN

    http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    ----------------
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39938 From: Glen Date: 12/21/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Thanks, Rob...Great find...Too bad there isn't a clearer shot
    somewhere...

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the original
    > PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows the
    > full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is the
    > version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    > starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    > image, and details about it, are in my blog:
    >
    > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-revealed.html"
    >
    > All best wishes.
    >
    > Rob
    >
    >
    > ----------------
    > ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer
    >
    > Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    > Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    > John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN
    >
    > http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    > ----------------
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39939 From: Paul Date: 12/22/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Just yesterday in Ebay someone was selling a model kit of this
    spaceship. Nothing big, ...small scale. I guess someone snatched it
    up because I can't find it in there anymore.

    ~Paul

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Glen" <HotScheetz@...> wrote:
    >
    > Thanks, Rob...Great find...Too bad there isn't a clearer shot
    > somewhere...
    >
    > G
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@>
    > wrote:
    > >
    > > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the
    original
    > > PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows
    the
    > > full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967;
    it's
    > > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is
    the
    > > version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    > > starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    > > image, and details about it, are in my blog:
    > >
    > > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-
    revealed.htmlbr> > >
    > > All best wishes.
    > >
    > > Rob
    > >
    > >
    > > ----------------
    > > ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer
    > >
    > > Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    > > Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    > > John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN
    > >
    > > http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@
    > > ----------------
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39940 From: Jonathan Date: 12/22/2006
    Subject: Re: The Apes... and Miscegenation
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "brendan486" <nzape@...> wrote:
    >
    > > > And in the novels of the animated series,
    > > > one of the gorillas is derided for having
    > > > a chimp grandparent. John, Scrolls.
    > >
    > > Well... if the animated series for POTA is
    > > accepted as Ape 'canon', and the novels too,
    > > then it tells that the Apes, especially the
    > > Gorillas and Chimps, can indeed interbreed.
    >
    > Are we to understand that since there are no
    > examples of interbreeding with Orangutangs that
    > even in Ape Society there is prejudice against
    > people with Ginger Hair!!!! Well, it seems that
    > Apes are no better than Humans afterall.
    > Brendan ;- )

    LOL- Funny :-)

    ~Jon Rich
    Another dumb blond :-)
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39941 From: James Date: 12/22/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Thanks so much for pointing this out. I've watched Roody's home
    movies several times and never noticed the ship.

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the original
    > PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows the
    > full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is the
    > version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    > starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    > image, and details about it, are in my blog:
    >
    > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-revealed.html"
    >
    > All best wishes.
    >
    > Rob
    >
    >
    > ----------------
    > ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer
    >
    > Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    > Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    > John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN
    >
    > http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    > ----------------
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39942 From: James Date: 12/22/2006
    Subject: Lesson from the Lawgiver
    .html

    Happy Holidays everyone! To celebrate the holidays we're repeating a special LESSON FROM THE LAWGIVER from last year. Thanks to Elaine, Glen, Dave and all who contributed.

    To view the LESSON click on the banner on the Yahoo Home page or use this link: http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/files/LFTL.htm.

    Visit all the Group's special features including:

    Also, be sure to join our sub-groups:

    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39943 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/22/2006
    Subject: Estella Warren's Birthday , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
    .html
    .html
    Reminder from:   pota Yahoo! Group
     
    Title:   Estella Warren's Birthday
     
    Date:   Saturday December 23, 2006
    Time:   All Day
    Repeats:   This event repeats every year.
    Notes:   Thank you God!
     
    Copyright © 2006  Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved |
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39944 From: Paul Date: 12/23/2006
    Subject: Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
    .html
    She is a beauty, that is for sure! Wish I could be at her birthday
    party!

    ~Paul Wright



    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, pota@yahoogroups.com wrote:
    >
    > Reminder from: pota Yahoo! Group
    > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/cal
    >
    > Estella Warren's Birthday
    > Saturday December 23, 2006
    > All Day
    > (This event repeats every year.)
    >
    > Notes:
    > Thank you God!
    >
    >
    > All Rights Reserved
    > Copyright © 2006
    > Yahoo! Inc.
    > http://www.yahoo.com
    >
    > Privacy Policy:
    > http://privacy.yahoo.com/privacy/us
    >
    > Terms of Service:
    >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39945 From: brendan486 Date: 12/23/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    For years I sold your novels through my old business and only had a
    chance to read Illegal Alien.
    I will now read the rest.
    Had I known you were an Ape fan I would have forced every customer
    to buy one.
    Thank you for the Taylor ship photo.
    Brendan.






    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the original
    > PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows the
    > full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is the
    > version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    > starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    > image, and details about it, are in my blog:
    >
    > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-
    revealed.htmlbr>
    >
    > All best wishes.
    >
    > Rob
    >
    >
    > ----------------
    > ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer
    >
    > Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    > Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    > John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN
    >
    > http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    > ----------------
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39946 From: Glen Date: 12/23/2006
    Subject: Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:00 am
    .html
    Yes, she's a prime example of someone who has "made it" in Hollywood
    on their looks, and no talent...

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Paul" <p3murds@...> wrote:
    >
    > She is a beauty, that is for sure! Wish I could be at her birthday
    > party!
    >
    > ~Paul Wright
    >
    >
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, pota@yahoogroups.com wrote:
    > >
    > > Reminder from: pota Yahoo! Group
    > > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/pota/cal
    > >
    > > Estella Warren's Birthday
    > > Saturday December 23, 2006
    > > All Day
    > > (This event repeats every year.)
    > >
    > > Notes:
    > > Thank you God!
    > >
    > >
    > > All Rights Reserved
    > > Copyright © 2006
    > > Yahoo! Inc.
    > > http://www.yahoo.com
    > >
    > > Privacy Policy:
    > > http://privacy.yahoo.com/privacy/us
    > >
    > > Terms of Service:
    > >
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39947 From: Glen Date: 12/23/2006
    Subject: Happy Holidays everyone...
    .html
    Here's my gift for wishing everyone a happy and safe holiday season,
    and a prosperous New Year...:

    Desiderata

    Go placidly amid the noise and haste,
    and remember what peace there may be in silence.
    As far as possible without surrender
    be on good terms with all persons.
    Speak your truth quietly and clearly;
    and listen to others,
    even the dull and the ignorant;
    they too have their story.

    Avoid loud and aggressive persons,
    they are vexations to the spirit.
    If you compare yourself with others,
    you may become vain and bitter;
    for always there will be greater and lesser persons than yourself.
    Enjoy your achievements as well as your plans.


    Keep interested in your own career, however humble;
    it is a real possession in the changing fortunes of time.
    Exercise caution in your business affairs;
    for the world is full of trickery.
    But let this not blind you to what virtue there is;
    many persons strive for high ideals;
    and everywhere life is full of heroism.


    Be yourself.
    Especially, do not feign affection.
    Neither be cynical about love;
    for in the face of all aridity and disenchantment
    it is as perennial as the grass.


    Take kindly the counsel of the years,
    gracefully surrendering the things of youth.
    Nurture strength of spirit to shield you in sudden misfortune.
    But do not distress yourself with dark imaginings.
    Many fears are born of fatigue and loneliness.
    Beyond a wholesome discipline,
    be gentle with yourself.


    You are a child of the universe,
    no less than the trees and the stars;
    you have a right to be here.
    And whether or not it is clear to you,
    no doubt the universe is unfolding as it should.


    Therefore be at peace with God,
    whatever you conceive Him to be,
    and whatever your labors and aspirations,
    in the noisy confusion of life keep peace with your soul.


    With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams,
    it is still a beautiful world.
    Be cheerful.
    Strive to be happy.


    Max Ehrmann
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39948 From: p3murds@aol.com Date: 12/23/2006
    Subject: Re: [POTA] Re: Estella Warren's Birthday  , 12/23/2006, 12:0
    .html
    .html
    I've never heard anything bad about her either like Britney Spears, or Paris Hilton.  Is she as good of a girl as I think?

    ~Paul
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39949 From: Rich Handley Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Merry Christmas
    .html
    Hi, everyone,

    I just wanted to wish you all a very happy holiday season!

    Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39950 From: Tim "apefan" Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Holiday
    .html
    Have a great holiday everyone ......no matter what you
    celebrate!

    Gather your family for a reading of the Sacred Scrolls
    and decorate the Lawgiver statue!

    Tim

    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39951 From: john rutkoski Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Holiday


    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39952 From: john rutkoski Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Merry Christmas
    .html
    Thankyou very much Rich ! I wish you a joyous season also.

    Rich Handley <handleyr@...> wrote:
    Hi, everyone,

    I just wanted to wish you all a very happy holiday season!

    Rich


    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39953 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Hi, Brendan. I'm a HUGE Apes fan. In fact, it's been said that my
    NEANDERTHAL PARALLAX trilogy (the Hugo-winning HOMINIDS, plus HUMANS
    and HYBRIDS) is my response to PLANET OF THE APES ... ;) And here's
    a little snippet from my 2000 novel, CALCULATING GOD:

    >>

    Susan once quipped that the only piece of scripture I knew was the
    Lawgiver's Twenty-ninth Scroll:

    <BLOCKQUOTE>
    Beware the beast Man, for he is the devil's pawn. Alone among God's
    primates, he kills for sport, or lust, or greed. Yea, he will murder
    his brother to possess his brother's land. Let him not breed in great
    numbers, for he will make a desert of his home and yours. Shun him.
    Drive him back into his jungle lair, for he is the harbinger of death.
    </BLOCKQUOTE>

    It's what Cornelius read to Taylor near the end of PLANET OF THE APES.
    Powerful words, and, like Dr. Zaius, I've always tried to live by
    their injunction. But Susan isn't quite right. Back when I was a
    student at U of T, lo those many years ago, I occasionally audited
    classes by Northrop Frye, the great teacher of English ...

    <<

    Rob

    http://sfwriter.com


    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "brendan486" <nzape@...> wrote:
    >
    > For years I sold your novels through my old business and only had a
    > chance to read Illegal Alien.
    > I will now read the rest.
    > Had I known you were an Ape fan I would have forced every customer
    > to buy one.
    > Thank you for the Taylor ship photo.
    > Brendan.
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@>
    > wrote:
    > >
    > > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged in the original
    > > PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stumbled upon an image that shows the
    > > full-size exterior mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    > > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers. This is the
    > > version of the ship sometimes referred to as "Icarus" or the ANSA
    > > starship before it was modified for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little
    > > image, and details about it, are in my blog:
    > >
    > > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-
    > revealed.htmlbr> > >
    > > All best wishes.
    > >
    > > Rob
    > >
    > >
    > > ----------------
    > > ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer
    > >
    > > Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    > > Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    > > John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN
    > >
    > > http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@
    > > ----------------
    > >
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39954 From: theskulpter Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
    .html
    HI Ape gang. I just finished a new head sculpt of General Urko last
    week,figured I would share some pics, so I added some new photos of it
    in the photo section, I will add more when I finish the helmet after
    the Holidays. Ok Hope all have a great Holiday, The Farrow.
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39955 From: Jonathan Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Have a Merry Christmas :-)
    .html
    Hello all :-)

    I would like to wish all of you a very Merry Christmas :-)
    Seasons Greeting to all members, friends and lovers :-)
    May you all receive everything you've hoped for :-)

    Sincerely,

    Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39956 From: Jonathan Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Taylor's spaceship is only seen partially submerged
    > in the original PLANET OF THE APES. But I've stum-
    > bled upon an image that shows the full-size exterior
    > mock-up out of the water as it was in 1967; it's
    > grainy and small, but possibly of use to model makers.
    > This is the version of the ship sometimes referred to
    > as "Icarus" or the ANSA starship before it was modified
    > for BENEATH or ESCAPE. The little image, and details
    > about it, are in my blog:
    >
    > http://sfwriter.com/2006/12/bottom-of-taylors-starship-revealed.html"
    >
    > All best wishes.
    >
    > Rob

    Amazing that the spacecraft had so little in the way
    of an actual engine, for spaceflight, but even more
    amazing that it was able to be restored for flight again,
    for a complete new liftoff from Earth... by Apes with
    tech knowledge no better than found in the American Old
    West of the early 1800's!!! An amazing inconsistancy.

    It also additionally means that the Apes somehow had
    the industial-level tech to seek out and actually find
    the ship in deep water, also scuba-diving tech to rig
    the ship for raising to the water's surface (for a spe-
    cies that can't swim and fears the water!), and the
    ability to also bring it fully to the surface and then
    ashore, actually 'repair' water-soaked tech a couple of
    centuries ahead of their time, then somehow figure out
    what powers and fuels it and devise the tech for fuel
    synthesis or manufacturing--- THEN get it off the ground
    for a frightening trip to points unknown!!!

    It... boggles the mind. But then again... I'm nit-
    picking. It's just that good fiction, is 'believable'
    fiction.

    ~ Jon
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39957 From: Glen Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
    .html
    Excellent work!...Do you ever do figures for others to purchase?...

    G

    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "theskulpter" <theskulpter@...> wrote:
    >
    > HI Ape gang. I just finished a new head sculpt of General Urko last
    > week,figured I would share some pics, so I added some new photos of
    it
    > in the photo section, I will add more when I finish the helmet after
    > the Holidays. Ok Hope all have a great Holiday, The Farrow.
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39958 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Jon wrote, referring to the salvaging and relaunch of Taylor's ship,
    "It... boggles the mind."

    But you bought the part about the talking apes, right? ;)

    Really, it's fun to speculate, and there are many possibilities.

    For instance, Cornelius, Zira, and Milo are in the Forbidden Zone on
    an archeological dig. The Alpha-Omega bomb goes off some distance
    away, causes an earthquake that drains the lake, revealing the ship.

    As conditions get worse and worse in the chain reaction following the
    detonation of the bomb, they crawl into the ship for shelter, and Milo
    hits the launch button, and -- the rest is history. (The ship had to
    be at least partially automated, since it was designed to operate for
    many months without intervention while the crew was in hibernation,
    and we know it launched just before the chain-reaction got out of
    control, since Zira describes it as seen from space in ESCAPE.)

    Or the ship propels itself up onto dry land after having sunk, after
    something -- an electrical short, maybe -- causes its main engines to
    briefly fire, pushing it up on shore, where it's found by apes; again,
    automation to the rescue; they activate the computerized launch
    sequence, and we're off to 1973.

    We know the ship wasn't designed to come down in water (that's said in
    dialog in POTA), and we know from BENEATH that its sister ship had
    tripodal landing gear (the gear seen in the wreckage is actually the
    landing gear from the full-size mockup of the Jupiter 2 from LOST IN
    SPACE). So, again, once it's ashore, the apes might have used
    block-and-tackle (just as they do with the Alpha-Omega bomb) to raise
    it onto its landing gear, and they get in and fire the main engine.

    Remember, the flight isn't necessarily anything more than the ship
    going up and coming down (with the pesky business of a Hasslein-curve
    timewarp in between, but that's caused by the bomb, rather than by
    anything Milo does), so it's hardly as though they have to learn how
    to pilot it (and it obviously aborts its flight improperly, again
    coming down in water, which, as was said, it wasn't designed to do,
    although presumably at some point the ship's computer dumped the lower
    stage with the landing gear, leaving only the re-entry capsule with
    the heat-shield intact, as seen in ESCAPE).

    Or, how 'bout this: Landon's lobotomy isn't as bad as Taylor assumed.
    Although he's been rendered docile and mute (or maybe is just
    refusing to speak in front of the apes, having seen what happened to
    Dodge), Landon leads Milo to the site of the sunken ship. A lot of
    debris has floated out of the ship (the hatch was blown, after all),
    including a spacesuit with air tanks. Landon uses the spacesuit as a
    diving suit, dives down to the sunken ship, and manages to inflate the
    ship's emergency flotation collar (included in the unlikely event of
    an unplanned water landing), bringing the ship to the surface.

    You want to go really far out? There's the underexplored notion of
    psychic connections between apes in the film series: the apes' IQs
    are rising spontaneously and en masse BEFORE THE ADVENT OF CAESAR in
    CONQUEST, and Caesar himself says he can possibly communicate with
    apes on the five continents without actually talking to them, and he
    also seems to have a connection ACROSS TIME to his statue 600 years in
    the future (which cries at the end of BATTLE). So maybe Milo is
    channeling Virgil, the orangutan Einstein from BATTLE, and has all the
    knowledge he needs about Taylor's spaceship (the plans for which
    MacDonald's brother might have quietly taken with him from the
    Archives Section, where he used to work).

    Or ... well, make up your own scenario. To me, it's a lot more fun to
    imagine possible solutions than to reject the notion out of hand. For
    my money, Paul Dehn was a genius in thinking of having apes salvage
    Taylor's ship.

    Happy Holidays!

    Rob

    ----------------
    ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer

    Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN

    http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    ----------------
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39959 From: Judy Watson Date: 12/24/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Just wanted to add my Happy Holidays to all the group and I love this constant discussion about things that I never thought of - what a great bunch of intelligent ape loving people !

    "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...> wrote:
    Jon wrote, referring to the salvaging and relaunch of Taylor's ship,
    "It... boggles the mind."

    But you bought the part about the talking apes, right? ;)

    Really, it's fun to speculate, and there are many possibilities.

    For instance, Cornelius, Zira, and Milo are in the Forbidden Zone on
    an archeological dig. The Alpha-Omega bomb goes off some distance
    away, causes an earthquake that drains the lake, revealing the ship.

    As conditions get worse and worse in the chain reaction following the
    detonation of the bomb, they crawl into the ship for shelter, and Milo
    hits the launch button, and -- the rest is history. (The ship had to
    be at least partially automated, since it was designed to operate for
    many months without intervention while the crew was in hibernation,
    and we know it launched just before the chain-reaction got out of
    control, since Zira describes it as seen from space in ESCAPE.)

    Or the ship propels itself up onto dry land after having sunk, after
    something -- an electrical short, maybe -- causes its main engines to
    briefly fire, pushing it up on shore, where it's found by apes; again,
    automation to the rescue; they activate the computerized launch
    sequence, and we're off to 1973.

    We know the ship wasn't designed to come down in water (that's said in
    dialog in POTA), and we know from BENEATH that its sister ship had
    tripodal landing gear (the gear seen in the wreckage is actually the
    landing gear from the full-size mockup of the Jupiter 2 from LOST IN
    SPACE). So, again, once it's ashore, the apes might have used
    block-and-tackle (just as they do with the Alpha-Omega bomb) to raise
    it onto its landing gear, and they get in and fire the main engine.

    Remember, the flight isn't necessarily anything more than the ship
    going up and coming down (with the pesky business of a Hasslein-curve
    timewarp in between, but that's caused by the bomb, rather than by
    anything Milo does), so it's hardly as though they have to learn how
    to pilot it (and it obviously aborts its flight improperly, again
    coming down in water, which, as was said, it wasn't designed to do,
    although presumably at some point the ship's computer dumped the lower
    stage with the landing gear, leaving only the re-entry capsule with
    the heat-shield intact, as seen in ESCAPE).

    Or, how 'bout this: Landon's lobotomy isn't as bad as Taylor assumed.
    Although he's been rendered docile and mute (or maybe is just
    refusing to speak in front of the apes, having seen what happened to
    Dodge), Landon leads Milo to the site of the sunken ship. A lot of
    debris has floated out of the ship (the hatch was blown, after all),
    including a spacesuit with air tanks. Landon uses the spacesuit as a
    diving suit, dives down to the sunken ship, and manages to inflate the
    ship's emergency flotation collar (included in the unlikely event of
    an unplanned water landing), bringing the ship to the surface.

    You want to go really far out? There's the underexplored notion of
    psychic connections between apes in the film series: the apes' IQs
    are rising spontaneously and en masse BEFORE THE ADVENT OF CAESAR in
    CONQUEST, and Caesar himself says he can possibly communicate with
    apes on the five continents without actually talking to them, and he
    also seems to have a connection ACROSS TIME to his statue 600 years in
    the future (which cries at the end of BATTLE). So maybe Milo is
    channeling Virgil, the orangutan Einstein from BATTLE, and has all the
    knowledge he needs about Taylor's spaceship (the plans for which
    MacDonald's brother might have quietly taken with him from the
    Archives Section, where he used to work).

    Or ... well, make up your own scenario. To me, it's a lot more fun to
    imagine possible solutions than to reject the notion out of hand. For
    my money, Paul Dehn was a genius in thinking of having apes salvage
    Taylor's ship.

    Happy Holidays!

    Rob

    ------------ ----
    ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer

    Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN

    http://www.sfwriter .com * sawyer@sfwriter. com
    ------------ ----


    Do You Yahoo!?
    Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
    http://mail.yahoo.com

    <.html <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39960 From: pota@yahoogroups.com Date: 12/25/2006
    Subject: Planet of the Apes 1968, 12/25/2006, 2:00 am
    .html
    .html
    Reminder from:   pota Yahoo! Group
     
    Title:   Planet of the Apes 1968
     
    Date:   Monday December 25, 2006
    Time:   2:00 am - 4:30 am
    Location:   Sci Fi Channel
     
    Copyright © 2006  Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved |
    <.html
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39961 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Jon wrote, referring to the salvaging and relaunch
    > of Taylor's ship, "It... boggles the mind."
    >
    > But you bought the part about the talking apes,
    > right? ;)

    Sure, that's easy to accept, because... 'we'
    are actually 'talking apes' after all. It's not
    that big a leap between making sounds, and making
    sounds with more complex meanings and in greater
    variety.

    Notable... is a cable program I saw recently, which
    examined an odd Human condition in which some people
    were inexplicably incabale of cognitive speech. An
    examination of their DNA revealed a missing component,
    normally found in normal speaking people. AND... that
    gene is not found in any of the primates. It seems
    that evolution, by random chance, resulted in the
    development of a gene that makes intelligent Human
    speech possible. Strange? Not really. It is these
    miscropic differences between species that make them
    all unique in their own way. And since were are 97%-99%
    genetically similar to our closest primate relatives,
    it's parts of that 1%-3% difference that makes us what
    we are, and them... what they are. Amazing... how one
    missing or incorrect gene can make all the difference,
    and there are tens of thousands of 'defects', linked to
    a single gene, that cause maladies, and similarly, those
    that make us Human, genes smaller by count, but amazing
    in the effect of making us what we are.

    Another example of a similar defect is that
    of some people whom cannot walk upright, as they
    are apparently missing a gene... which permits a
    normal upright walking stance. It serves as evi-
    dence that the upright stance in more than skele-
    tal/anatomical. A gene missing, must be present,
    to permit for proper upright walking. Ultimately
    it took immense effort to get those poor folks to
    walk upright, but the walk isn't normal, and they
    do so with difficulty and lack of confidence.

    > Really, it's fun to speculate, and there are many
    > possibilities.

    And I'm happy to read about them :-) And...
    to politely debate them :-D

    > For instance, Cornelius, Zira, and Milo are
    > in the Forbidden Zone on an archeological
    > dig. The Alpha-Omega bomb goes off some dis-
    > tance away, causes an earthquake that drains
    > the lake, revealing the ship. As conditions
    > get worse and worse in the chain reaction
    > following the detonation of the bomb, they
    > crawl into the ship for shelter, and Milo
    > hits the launch button, and -- the rest is
    > history. (The ship had to be at least par-
    > tially automated, since it was designed to
    > operate for many months without intervention
    > while the crew was in hibernation, and we know
    > it launched just before the chain-reaction got
    > out of control, since Zira describes it as seen
    > from space in ESCAPE.)

    Your first supposition above falls apart at
    the beginning, sorry to say. The first reason
    I will cite, is that very likely the A-O bomb
    would have enveloped the area of the lake... in
    seconds, if not in fractions of a second. That
    leaves no time to run and hide in the ship. They
    would be too close to a bomb... that will eventu-
    ally consume the Earth. They're at point blank
    range. And once they even saw the light of the
    explosion- they'd be fried. See it- then die-
    and in the same instant.

    But you also have the timeline wrong. Zera
    herself confessed that they were already in space
    when the A-O bomb went off, and she described this
    sequence of events, as seen from space;

    1) A bright, white, blinding light.
    2) Then a 'storm'. Likely the shockwave of the
    explosion, the Earth's atmosphere blown out into
    space toward them.
    3) She/They witnessed the rim off the Earth 'melt',
    an odd thing to say, since it wouldn't be like the
    Earth could drip like a candle or anything, but it
    could have turned white-hot, suggesting 'melting',
    like soft metal in a hot furnace.

    Conclusively, they were already in space when the
    A-O bomb explosion occurred.

    Oh... and the idea that Milo merely 'hits a
    button' to launch the ship, is... well... prepos-
    terous. Just to drive a car alone takes a mini-
    mum of SIX actions, before one is driving down
    the road; Insert the key. Turn it to start the
    car. Put it into gear. Pull the emergency brake
    to unlock it. Press the gas. Turn the steering
    wheel to follow one's chosen course.

    Preflight checks are... enormous, requiring
    many steps. How did Milo learn what they are,
    those dozen... if not hundreds of preflight steps?
    From the computer? Gee... how did he learn how to
    work that??? I have been on computers for decades,
    Windows-operated IBM-type machines... and I GET LOST
    if asked to run a MAC! What about checking the sys-
    tems for air, potable water, fuel, electricity, pro-
    perly-operating systems and all thet? How does he
    know that they're working and up to par? it takes
    more than a preflight checklist for all of that.
    Where'd he get the fuel??? Did he use Ape lamp
    oil? Discover the undergrond tanks of an ancient
    gas station somewhere? How did he liquify the
    oxygen he would need? Where'd he find the hoses
    and fitings... needed to pump it aboard? How did
    he store it- before then, if he figured out how to
    make fuel and liquid oxygen? he would have... had
    to re-invent dozens of advanced technologies to
    make that flight... and... in a very short period
    of time, to make that ship flight-ready. I say...
    impossible.

    > Or the ship propels itself up onto dry land
    > after having sunk, after something -- an
    > electrical short, maybe -- causes its main
    > engines to briefly fire, pushing it up on
    > shore, where it's found by apes; again, auto-
    > mation to the rescue; they activate the com-
    > puterized launch sequence, and we're off to 1973.

    The above supposition, again viewed from a
    realistic point of view, itself does not hold
    water, because water alone is a BIG problem.
    The ship was filled to the gills with water, a
    ship designed to carry just four people by weight
    weighing in total somewhere between 700 and 800
    pounds. And ship... now filled with water and
    overburdened by many TONS. A ship that has to
    now move those tons of water... THROUGH water,
    then... somehow, by what can be described as
    nothing less than a miracle, wound up on that
    rocky shore... full of water, and not experiencing
    a singular dent in a fender or buckled hullplate!!!
    The simple physics of what your descrbe... just
    aren't being taken into account. The difference
    is similar to dropping a 1-gallon plastic milk jug
    filled only with air, and one filled with water.
    The carrying of an air-filled jug up to the roof
    for dropping, is virtually effortless. A water-
    filled one, a full gallon, takes much more work.
    Just carrying one home from the grocery store is
    a pain to the fingers. Now imagine that the water
    jug is much larger weighs tons. It will be geome-
    trically much, much heavier. Now drop both jugs.
    The air-filled one will drop to bounce safely,
    and would likely experience no damage at all is
    dropped from any building height. Now drop the
    water-filled milk jug. The effect is devasting.
    SPLASH- the jug bursts open to the point of use-
    lessness. And if tons in weight, even more so.

    The physics is simple, and considering that
    the darned thing began leaking so easily, to
    sink, proves that the ship was no submarine!
    My goodness- no. How, I wonder, how did Milo
    perform the repairs on the high tech metals of
    that leaking hull too??? Tar and Oakum? Chew-
    ing gum? A plasma welder? Delco Caulking Com-
    pound? Epoxy? Glue made from Human flesh?
    it makes one wonder.

    I would suggest an experiment, to show you
    how much water weighs, in real volume. Take
    a container that measure say, 12" in all sides,
    then another of merely double the dimensions, at
    24" on a side. Not fill both with water. Now try
    to pick each up from the floor, one at a time.
    The 12" container will be heavy, but you can lift
    it easily, but the 24" filled container will be 8X
    heavier, and you'd be hard-pressed to lift it at
    all, or with real difficulty. A starship of that
    size... would fill with many weighty tons. Quite a
    bit to demand of those engines, pre-programmed or
    not. Then... there's that rocky shore-side land-
    ing, with a full water load, and with nary a scratch
    Erf :-( I don't think so.

    And even if the ship didn't come ashore
    that way, but instead had to be brought up,
    how and why did the apes... develop diving
    bell and scuba technology? the former is
    easy, but very tricky. The latter... takes
    much more tech effort, including the re-inven-
    tion of compressor technology, to fill the
    scuba tanks. Many sciences were involved.
    Remember- Jaques Cousteau and other, after
    much investment of time, money, and much
    experimentation, perfected the simplest
    workable scuba gear. It took many people and
    years, to come up with something the worked
    reliably and safely. Diving bells and diving
    suits required less tech knowledge, but its
    a heck of a thing to re-invent and perfect,
    in such a VERY short period of time. A time
    way to short to perfect such for safe useful-
    ness.

    > We know the ship wasn't designed to come down
    > in water (that's said in dialog in POTA), and
    > we know from BENEATH that its sister ship had
    > tripodal landing gear (the gear seen in the
    > wreckage is actually the landing gear from the
    > full-size mockup of the Jupiter 2 from LOST IN
    > SPACE). So, again, once it's ashore, the apes
    > might have used block-and-tackle (just as they
    > do with the Alpha-Omega bomb) to raise it onto
    > its landing gear, and they get in and fire the
    > main engine.

    Thinking on this. But the same probs are
    fully in place. Read down further.

    > Remember, the flight isn't necessarily anything
    > more than the ship going up and coming down
    > (with the pesky business of a Hasslein-curve
    > timewarp in between, but that's caused by the
    > bomb, rather than by anything Milo does), so
    > it's hardly as though they have to learn how
    > to pilot it (and it obviously aborts its flight
    > improperly, again coming down in water, which,
    > as was said, it wasn't designed to do, although
    > presumably at some point the ship's computer
    > dumped the lower stage with the landing gear,
    > leaving only the re-entry capsule with the heat-
    > shield intact, as seen in ESCAPE).

    Well... dumping the rear engine sure does make
    liftoff again- imposible- right? it's then just
    an enginless capsule, meaning that the engine
    would still have ti be recovered, meaning that
    TWO big parts had to be retrieved. A doubly
    tough ffort, then the followup reassembly by
    non-high-tech-comprehending Ape-folks. The above
    premise has all kinds of holes in it. Just...
    not plausible.

    And yes, it IS all just science fiction, but the
    difference between science fiction, and fantasy, is
    the workable plausibility of it. Often something
    touted as sci-fi is so poorly plausible that it
    cannot be enjoyed, because the 'science' is just
    so bad, that the serious watcher of the film can-
    not enjoy it. magic as found in fantasy, is auto-
    matically accepted as is. Magic... is just magic,
    and accepted on belief alone. How it works is
    entirely irrelavent. It requires no more explana-
    tion than does one's believe in (a) God, or Angels.
    What makes good science fiction, is plausibility,
    especially if it's part of the plotline, in a
    universe where things are naturally explanable in
    one way or another... even if the pseudo-scientific
    explanation is pure balony... as with Star Trek's
    Warp Drive, Transporters, and Antigrav lifting de-
    vices. Tech-lovers love that stuff, watch science
    fiction often because of it, and its plausibility,
    and it's part of what scirnce fiction stories are
    made of, that makes them what they are, along with
    hopefully decent stories and plot-lines.

    As a rule... the 'story' of POTA is more important,
    even when the science fails. It's a great fish-out-
    of-water story, and an immense informative morality
    tale. Science... was never meant to be a part of any
    actual center of the story. the truest science fic-
    tion parts, are shown and done, at the beginning of
    most of the film stories, meant thereafter to be ig-
    nored, and forgotten. The spaceships... are just
    plot devices, used then cast aside, where in stories
    like Star Trek and Star wars and others, the tech is
    around all the time, in common daily use.

    In POTA... the tech of it was never really planned
    out well, nor explained, and was never meant to be,
    BUT... sci-fi tech lovers love those parts of science
    fiction, as I am one, and suck it up with relish.
    But with POTA... there are too many holes in the tech,
    forcing us to try to figure it out, which in itself...
    is part of the whole of the fun! :-D

    > Or, how 'bout this: Landon's lobotomy isn't as
    > bad as Taylor assumed. Although he's been ren-
    > dered docile and mute (or maybe is just refusing
    > to speak in front of the apes, having seen what
    > happened to Dodge), Landon leads Milo to the site
    > of the sunken ship. A lot of debris has floated
    > out of the ship (the hatch was blown, after all),
    > including a spacesuit with air tanks. Landon uses
    > the spacesuit as a diving suit, dives down to the
    > sunken ship, and manages to inflate the ship's
    > emergency flotation collar (included in the unlike-
    > ly event of an unplanned water landing), bringing
    > the ship to the surface.

    Sorry... but I just don't buy that. I can't
    even magine how that proposal would fit into the
    possibilities, and there's no hint of any kind,
    none, that Landon was able, or willing, or capable,
    of doing any such a thing.

    I think that Landon, injured and in a semi-
    conscious stupor, was 'talking in his sleep' as
    it were, babbling ro smething in his injured
    state, as Zaius was made aware of this, when he
    decided to, One; have him operated on to see how
    this speech was possible, or Two; ordered him
    labotomized to silence him. Remember, Zaius
    'knows' that man could once speak, and is likely
    aware that Speakin Man as a civilization preceeded
    the Apes, and is hell-bent on keeping Man at the
    bottom of the social ladder, merely one among all
    the other animals. This... conflicts with his
    Faith, and will do anything to maintain his Faith,
    and Ape superiority Zaius and other know this 'Big
    Secret', and cannot cope with the possible compe-
    tion with another sentient, and very violent, race
    or species. They want to rule, forever, and nothing
    will stop them from trying to maintain their status
    as the most intelligent species on the planet. it
    is their turn, as it were, and they want to stay on
    top- at all costs.

    And in this day and age, in real life, we all
    know what people will do... in the name of self-
    preservation... and... Faith :-(

    > You want to go really far out? There's the under-
    > explored notion of psychic connections between apes
    > in the film series: the apes' IQs are rising spon-
    > taneously and en masse BEFORE THE ADVENT OF CAESAR
    > in CONQUEST, and Caesar himself says he can possibly
    > communicate with apes on the five continents without
    > actually talking to them, and he also seems to have
    > a connection ACROSS TIME to his statue 600 years in
    > the future (which cries at the end of BATTLE). So
    > maybe Milo is channeling Virgil, the orangutan Ein-
    > stein from BATTLE, and has all the knowledge he needs
    > about Taylor's spaceship (the plans for which MacDo-
    > nald's brother might have quietly taken with him from
    > the Archives Section, where he used to work).

    Well... I don't but any psychic scenario or
    idea that may be presented. Nothing at all sup-
    ports the Apes having 'psionic' abilities of any
    kind, or spirits 'communicating' across the eons.
    Just doesn't work for me at all. Sorry.

    > Or ... well, make up your own scenario. To me,
    > it's a lot more fun to imagine possible solutions
    > than to reject the notion out of hand. For my
    > money, Paul Dehn was a genius in thinking of hav-
    > ing apes salvage Taylor's ship.

    That... was the only possible solution to the
    problem of making the storyline work, I would say.
    Salvage was the only solution.

    But for my money- no way it could have happened.
    It would make more sense if the Apes had stumbled
    upon a solar-powered time-machime, which was ready'
    to use... when the 'Big War' started, preventing
    the Humans that invented it from using it for some
    reason. But that of course would have presented
    something of a different story, as far as ESCAPE
    is concerned, in particular.

    Anyway... in my view the knowledge and
    logistics and additional tech needed, to raise
    and prepare and launch that ship, would have
    involved many years, and likely decades to work
    out... to fit to 'reason'. Being technologically
    more than a century or two behind, is just too much,
    and it's worse than a hundered years before our
    real life present time, bacause Ape tech goes back
    at least two full centuries before the present,
    again more like Old America of the Early 1800's
    or worse. That concept of their level of tech
    works, that comparitive timeframe of development,
    because they do have firearms and photography, but
    no electricity, radio, or electric lighting. They
    had not as yet re-invented the 'Age of Electricity',
    and are in fact Pre-Industrial. Their tech is just
    above Medieval a smidgeon or so. Yheir society is
    also somewhat Feudal, or more a Caste system. And
    that hardly permits much in the way of important in-
    dividual efforts to progress technologically. The
    incentives really just aren't there.

    Just imagine a cowboy of 1820 America... suddenly
    presented with a keyless 2007 Cadilac. He'd more
    likely shoot holes in it in fear or frustration,
    than even think of imagining... driving it around.

    The truest 'fix' for this whole issue, would
    just be that the spaceship didn't 'crash' in the
    first place. It landed nicely, as they then just
    began to explore their 'new' world :-) That would
    leave the rest of the story intact, deaths and
    injuries and all, Taylor keeping the ship a
    secret because he hopes to get back to it, in
    hopes of making a clean... ESCAPE FROM THE PLANET
    OF THE APES! :-D But... he is captured by the
    underground mutants... before he can get back to
    it. Sad :-(

    In conclusion, so that I can just sit and
    enjoy the story, I just accept that they did
    what they did, and... that's it. Somehow they
    simply pulled it off. I can then enjoy the
    acting and storyline and concept, to great plea-
    sure, since the story itself is the thing- what's
    truly important about it all :-) The 'story' is
    what truly counts :-) To Devil with the tech-
    such as it is...

    > Happy Holidays!

    You too, good buddy :-)

    And... sorry for the long reply, but... this
    'issue' poses immense questions, and a great many
    of them. That's... just the way it is.

    AND... you don't have to agree with any of what
    I said. It's just discussion, and I have no inten-
    tion of bursting anyone's bubble on what they be-
    lieve as far as POTA tech is concerned. It's a big
    nit-pick, but I for one won't be upset if you agree
    with nothing I said, or don't want to 'argue' any
    of my points :-) I just love... chatting about
    things like this. That's the fun of it, just as
    it is :-D

    > Rob

    Merry Christmas!!! :-D

    ~ Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39962 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
    Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "theskulpter" <theskulpter@...> wrote:
    >
    > HI Ape gang. I just finished a new head sculpt of
    > General Urko last week,figured I would share some
    > pics, so I added some new photos of it in the pho-
    > to section, I will add more when I finish the hel-
    > met after the Holidays. Ok Hope all have a great
    > Holiday, The Farrow.

    WOW! THAT'S AMAZING WORK! Bloody fantastic!
    Love it. Perfectly marvelous :-) Kudos, Fallow :-D

    A big ape-like pat on the back there :-)

    ~ Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39963 From: Jonathan Date: 12/25/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, Judy Watson <bettabeedee@...> wrote:
    >
    > Just wanted to add my Happy Holidays to all the
    > group and I love this constant discussion about
    > things that I never thought of - what a great
    > bunch of intelligent ape loving people !

    Thank you so much, Judy :-)

    I must say that I've been in groups that 'claim'
    to be open to such extensive levels of discussion,
    but... they aren't. Many have childish members
    whom, thier own theories not being accepted, get
    defensive, angry, or worse.

    I lurked here for a long time before I decided
    to speak up, because I was judging the maturity of
    this group. I found it to ve VERY mature, and
    decided to get involved :-) And so far... I am
    loving it. Glad you are too :-)

    And here's a question for you; Ahve you ever
    wondered why the Apes had such nice automatic
    weapons, such nice frearms that work so well and
    are, apparently, the most advanced tech they have?
    Have you noticed... how technologically smooth and
    clean and functional they are, when everything else
    they design looks so rough and angular and... stone-
    aged? Ever notice that? :-) Even a common and
    surely function wagon wheel... looks like the
    Flintstones themselves desighed it!

    I have my own theory about that. I say that
    such things as guns, a device and tool so very
    necessary for hunting and defense, will, as a
    useful design, be maintained and carried one for
    many hundreds if not thousands of years. The
    gun mechanisms and working principles were carried
    on over time for all that time, because they worked,
    and worked well, the original designs being Human
    in origin and carried on across all those centuries,
    and such designs, as efficient as they are now,
    will be just as effecient as the then to come,
    centuries hence. A Human of today, knowledgeable
    of current gun designs, will likely recignize me-
    chanical elements that are largely unchanged over
    those many centuries!!! You just can't beat- what
    works :-)

    And the technology for it all is very simple too,
    and can be carried out in any blacksmith's shop,
    by someone trained in gun-making. Given the plans
    and current tools, even 'you' can make a gun in
    your own home from raw metal stock. Such has even
    been done... in actual real life prisons, with what
    they have very limited access to. Given the time
    and tools, anything can be done, especially if the
    tech is relativelt simple :-)

    It's notable that in the POTA Tv series, Human
    books were all over the place. Likely the acid-
    laden paper f those times did not survive to the
    time of Taylor's entry into POTA, but surely, like
    the Bible, those pages were copied numerous times
    over the centuries, drawings included :-)

    Knowledge... is power, and surely even the Apes
    know that. And guns are power too, as a certain
    Gorilla in BATTLE knew that. Knowledge... and guns.
    Knowledge... and... guns...

    ~ Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39964 From: Robert J. Sawyer Date: 12/25/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    Hi, Jon.

    Well, neither of us knows anything about how the Alpha-Omega bomb does
    its business, but, as you say, we have Zira's testimony that it
    "melted" the rim of the earth, plausibly implying that its destructive
    mechanism isn't one we're familiar with. :)

    So it might have been a slow-acting or multi-step process that could
    have allowed earthquakes, etc., prior to actually destroying the
    planet. It's plausible that Taylor's ship wasn't at point-blank range
    to the Mutant Cathedral ("ground zero"); after all, Taylor and Nova
    were heading AWAY from where he'd been before, not back to where the
    ship had come down.

    And your discussion of the difficulty of moving a jug full of water
    through air is missing a hugely key point: you're forgetting that the
    ship full of water (or partially full of; we don't know which) is
    surrounded BY water -- right up until the very end, when it comes out
    of it onto shore.

    Most living tissue has about the same density as water, and moving it
    through water can be done with no more energy than is provided by a
    Big Mac and a large order of fries: we call it swimming. :)

    And very large entities, on the order of the size of the part of
    Taylor's ship we saw, that have densities equal to water also move
    through it easily, with little energy; think of giant squids.

    Plus, of course, the engines on Taylor's ship aren't mere rockets;
    rather, they're engines capable of interstellar travel -- his was a
    starship, remember. An engine that can propel a ship from Sol to a
    star in the constellation of Orion (where Taylor thought they were
    going) can surely push it up onto shore.

    There's no canonical reason to believe that what landed in POTA was
    only a landing module and not the full ship.) And I disagree that the
    ship shows no signs of damage; look at it in ESCAPE -- it's a lot more
    beat up than it was in PLANET, and it's just as plausible that the
    beating-up happened as the ship came ashore in 3955 as that it
    happened during re-entry in 1973. After all, we saw in PLANET that
    the ship could do a re-entry on its own without even getting singed.

    In any event, we have no idea what sort of fuel the ship used, or
    whether its reserves were depleted or intact. Milo may have found the
    ship fully fueled.

    As for breathing air -- we have no idea how long the ape-o-nauts were
    aboard the ship, but if the interior is large enough, there's
    breathing air for hours just in the sealed ship, without any need for
    any further life-support equipment. And, yes, there are all kinds of
    substances the apes had that could be used to plug holes in the hull
    (or maybe they never bothered: it's notable that the ape-o-nauts don
    spacesuits for their flight, meaning perhaps that the ship's hull
    never was completely sealed again).

    Or, if it was a multistage landing craft, like the Apollo-era Lunar
    Module it may have been something as simple as when the ship finally
    hit the bottom of the lake, the shock jolted free the ascent stage
    which floated to the surface of its own accord.

    And we don't know how many stages there were: there could have been
    three or more: a stardrive section, which could have broken off when
    the ship hit the lake's bottom; an ascent-engine, which could have got
    them into space in 3955 and been jettisoned by the computer upon
    commencement of re-entry in 1973; and the capsule that we saw already
    down in the water in 1973. We just don't know.

    And, yes, if the ape-o-nauts hadn't been blown back in time, they
    might have died rather quickly after the ship launched, because of all
    the things Milo doubtless didn't understand or overlooked, but the
    "fact" is that they WERE blown backwards in time.

    And, forgive me, but, again, it's funny to me that you balk at the
    salvaging of the ship, but say nothing about the far-less-likely
    reverse time travel. One either buys the looseness of the science in
    the films as a whole, or one doesn't, but to get so hung up on one
    point seems odd to me, but, hey, to each his own ... :)

    Anyway, yes, a launch is complex -- but so is re-entry; indeed, the
    re-entry that Taylor's ship did in POTA is arguably a much more
    complex operation than the launch that Milo presumably engineered:
    all Milo had to do was get the ship to go more-or-less up (he never
    needed to worry about achieving orbit or executing a flight plan),
    whereas in POTA the ship had to get the angles and speeds exactly
    right to avoid burning up on re-entry -- AND ALL OF THAT HAPPENED WITH
    NO ONE PUSHING EVEN A SINGLE BUTTON. The ship is demonstrably highly
    automated.

    But if you want to argue that Milo had to push more than one button,
    fine: we see in BENEATH that the Apes not only speak our language,
    but they also read and write it (recall the signs written in English
    used by the anti-war protesters). So, all Milo had to do was read the
    (plasticized hardcopy) manual, or follow on-screen prompts. And we
    saw the instrumentation in Taylor's ship: it's very simple, much
    simpler than the flight deck of a Space Shuttle (or even a Gemini
    capsule), again, arguing for a very high degree of automation.

    As for the psionics stuff, I agree it's far out, but psionics ARE
    canonically part of the POTA cycle; the mutants in BENEATH absolutely
    have them (and Caesar does sound like he's arguing for a form of them
    at the end of CONQUEST with the Emperor Moth analogy). If you are
    arguing that ONLY humans might be capable of them in a universe in
    which they categorically do exist, well, that's a bit specist, and I
    doubt Virgil would approve. :)

    Also, if there is in fact no psychic connection between Caesar of the
    early 21st century in the main story of BATTLE, and the Caesar statue
    of the 27th century in the epilogue to BATTLE, how do you explain the
    statue crying at the end of BATTLE? :) (No, I'm not pushing the
    psychic angle; it's just a fun one to consider in a fictional universe
    that demonstrably -- the mutants in BENEATH -- has already allowed for
    psychic powers.)

    The bottom line for me is that it IS canonical to the Apes series that
    Milo DID manage to get Taylor's ship to fly, at least briefly. For
    me, saying "it couldn't have happened" over and over again is far less
    interesting (or fun!) than trying to think of ways in which it might
    have. :)

    As for the rules for writing science fiction, I'll try to keep 'em in
    mind ... ;)

    All best wishes.

    ----------------
    ROBERT J. SAWYER, Science Fiction Writer

    Hugo Award winner for HOMINIDS
    Nebula Award winner for THE TERMINAL EXPERIMENT
    John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner for MINDSCAN

    http://www.sfwriter.com * sawyer@...
    ----------------
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39965 From: Jonathan Date: 12/26/2006
    Subject: Re: Taylor's spaceship on Fox lot in 1967, showing rear details
    .html
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Robert J. Sawyer" <robertjsawyer@...>
    wrote:
    >
    > Hi, Jon.

    Hello, Robert :-)

    > Well, neither of us knows anything about how
    > the Alpha-Omega bomb does its business, but,
    > as you say, we have Zira's testimony that it
    > "melted" the rim of the earth, plausibly im-
    > plying that its destructive mechanism isn't
    > one we're familiar with. :)

    Well... certainly it was 'atomic', or better-
    'nuclear', and it would have to be to have the
    effect it had. Otherwise the 'visual' or practical
    effect of the bomb need not be that unusual. It
    quite simply was a very, very, very powerful type
    of nuclear bomb.

    The description of Zira of the 'the rim of the
    Earth melting' was merely her best interpretation
    of what she saw as the planet went white hot after
    the initial blast wave. The 'storm' the preceded
    Zira's observations, surely could have drawn them to
    a viewport to see what in fact was happening outside.
    Otherwise... her limited experience and interpreta-
    tion of the thing she saw, was based on her life
    experience in a society 100 to 200 years behind our
    modern times. She merely described what she saw,
    as best she could.

    Then again... the blast and effects of the A-O
    bomb surely could be such- enough- to bulge out
    enormous globules of Earth-mass, much in the way
    of the goo in a lava lamp, and with it happening
    on such a largely massive scale, could have moved
    and flowed like... melting. Surely the force of
    the A-O blast 'could' have had that effect. And it
    certainly would have been something amazing to see,
    the Earth rippling and bulging it protest against
    what it just endured.

    > So it might have been a slow-acting or multi-step
    > process that could have allowed earthquakes, etc.,

    I don't see... how a singular explosion could
    be a multi-step process, especially as far as a
    nuclear-like process is concerned. It's effect
    is so devastating due to its sudden-release-of-
    all effect, after all. And the effect had to be
    so intense, that it virtually induced fission of
    the mass of the Earth itself, at least in large
    part, and surely enough... to destroy the world-
    with just one shot. Devastating. At the least
    the Earth was reduced into a huge, totally molten
    mass. Heck... life could even arise there again,
    given 3 billion years or so... to cool. Over that
    period of time, even the Sun itself would still have
    some 3 nillion years of its own life left, assuming
    it has 6 billion remaining now.

    > prior to actually destroying the planet. It's
    > plausible that Taylor's ship wasn't at point-blank
    > range to the Mutant Cathedral ("ground zero"); after
    > all, Taylor and Nova were heading AWAY from where
    > he'd been before, not back to where the ship had
    > come down.

    Well... Cornelius' own map, shown to Taylor,
    told that the Forbidden Zone wasn't all that far
    from Ape City proper. Even a conventional nu-
    clear explosion would have reached Ape city quickly
    if above ground, and it's obvious that the A-O
    bomb was much, much more powerful than that-
    enough to destroy the entire Earth, of course.
    Ape City, I feel certain, would have been itself
    destroyed in the first second, and the entire
    Earth within a couple of moments.

    > And your discussion of the difficulty of moving
    > a jug full of water through air is missing a
    > hugely key point: you're forgetting that the
    > ship full of water (or partially full of; we
    > don't know which) is surrounded BY water --
    > right up until the very end, when it comes out
    > of it onto shore.

    True. Very true. But you're forgetting
    about inertia. Surrounded by water or not,
    the engines STILL have to push around many tons
    of water- through a watery medium that is 800
    time DENSER than AIR. Another major negative
    influence. So... that poor ship had to have
    pushed a LOT of mass, through even a much denser
    mass than air. Oh... the strain.

    And still... that ship, overburdened with
    its liquid load, had to land on the beach intact
    with that load. Heck, it couldn't even withstand
    just floating on the surface, without springing
    leaks all over the place. So... how can it pos-
    sibly have withstood a full-load beaching, with-
    out bursting open like a dropped whale??? See
    my point? :-)

    > Most living tissue has about the same density
    > as water, and moving it through water can be
    > done with no more energy than is provided by
    > a Big Mac and a large order of fries: we call
    > it swimming. :)

    Very true, even if we can swin faster than
    a walk, and run faster than swimming. But it
    must be taken into account the the geometrically
    larger mass of the water-filled ship... is an
    entirely different problem.

    I don't know what the volume of the spacecraft
    was, but... if it is approximately the volume of
    the trailor of a semi truck that carries gasoline,
    oil, milk or whatever, the sheer weight of all that
    is between 50,000 and 54,000 pounds. I know because
    I weighed such trucks before and after loading, for
    a living. So, in addition to it's own weight or
    mass, the ship was perhaps carrying an additional
    50 to 54 tons! Not a light burder. And I'll wager
    that the truer volume- was much greater than that,
    because that ship was as high as a semi-truck tank
    container, but was easily twice as wide. It may have
    been hauling between 75 and 100 additional tons... and
    without bursting open- when beached... at speed. So
    if that 'is' what occured, its an amazing feat, for
    a spacecraft meant to just hold back vacuum, or rather,
    just to hold air and fly like a jet and spacecraft.
    Gee... it's a cast-iron bucket! A Sherman tank!

    > And very large entities, on the order of the size
    > of the part of Taylor's ship we saw, that have
    > densities equal to water also move through it
    > easily, with little energy; think of giant squids.

    Apples and oranges. The ship cannot possibly
    be compared to a squid in any way. Sorry... my
    friend.

    > Plus, of course, the engines on Taylor's ship
    > aren't mere rockets; rather, they're engines
    > capable of interstellar travel -- his was a
    > starship, remember. An engine that can propel
    > a ship from Sol to a star in the constellation
    > of Orion (where Taylor thought they were going)
    > can surely push it up onto shore.

    But you see... that would make that stardrive
    even more amazing! It can move the ship, at
    any speed below that of light, AND propel FTL!
    Bloody amazing versatility... even when serving
    as an impromptu submarine! LOL :-)

    Improbable considering the decade that 'engine'
    was developed, during a time, when in real life,
    at least four different kinds of jet engines are
    required to fly in differing altitude environments,
    and none of them can operate in 'all' of them. A
    scamjet engine for example, cannot operate at all
    at below supersonic speeds. It requires supersonic
    velocities to be in effect- to operate- in the first
    place. Any slower... and it stalls and shuts down.
    The point is... is that that ship's engine would
    have to have positively amazing operating flexibility
    to do what it does, in so many varied environments,
    truly. Quite amazing, from a RL engineering point
    of view.

    > There's no canonical reason to believe that what
    > landed in POTA was only a landing module and not
    > the full ship.) And I disagree that the ship
    > shows no signs of damage; look at it in ESCAPE
    > -- it's a lot more beat up than it was in PLANET,
    > and it's just as plausible that the beating-up
    > happened as the ship came ashore in 3955 as that
    > it happened during re-entry in 1973. After all,
    > we saw in PLANET that the ship could do a re-entry
    > on its own without even getting singed.

    The kind of damage I'm defining would have
    to be considerably more than the dents and dings
    the ship experienced, as seen in the films. If
    it did do, what is described as it may have done,
    that ship would be a bloody wreck. Not programmed
    to land in the water? Why not? Likely because
    it was very bad for it, a thin-skinned lightweight
    craft... now having to endure water impact, crushing
    water depths instead of the vacuum of space (grossly
    reversed environmental stresses) and now... must
    serve as a submarine, fully loaded with water, and
    land on a rocky, or sandy shore... totally intact.
    Really??? Even more amazing engineering... border-
    ing on 'magic', I say.

    > In any event, we have no idea what sort of fuel
    > the ship used, or whether its reserves were de-
    > pleted or intact. Milo may have found the ship
    > fully fueled.

    'Fully' fueled??? What, Taylor and crew used
    no fuel at all, for the first trip to the Monkey
    Planet? I find that... rather unlikely. At best,
    it had fuel enough for the two noted trips, at
    the very, very least. And interesting... consider-
    ing that it was to be a one-way trip in the first
    place. Reserves, if any, would have been minimal,
    and likely only enough for some air flight time,
    enougn to find a good landing spot. But... the
    ship failed to do that... surrounded by desert all
    around! A big arguement against super high-tech
    automation. The darned computer couldn't even
    find the land... ALL around that Dead Lake. It
    must have been havng a bad camera day.

    > As for breathing air -- we have no idea how
    > long the ape-o-nauts were aboard the ship, but
    > if the interior is large enough, there's breath-
    > ing air for hours just in the sealed ship, with-
    > out any need for any further life-support equip-
    > ment. And, yes, there are all kinds of substances
    > the apes had that could be used to plug holes in
    > the hull (or maybe they never bothered: it's no-
    > table that the ape-o-nauts don spacesuits for their
    > flight, meaning perhaps that the ship's hull never
    > was completely sealed again).

    Well, let's forget about the plugging stuff. Let's
    just look at the trip the Apes took. The trip origi-
    nally required suspended animation to make a trip that
    was at the least... many months long. Suspended anima-
    tion is necessary, for only one reason; That the ship
    could not possibly carry enough food, water, and air,
    for an awake crew to make the trip comfortably. SA
    serves no other purpose otherwise. It certainly did
    not stop their aging, because as Taylor noted- Landon
    had 'gone gray'. SA serves no other purpose than to
    stretch minimal suppies. Suspended Animation as
    appied in the film, can't have served any other
    purpose. It defined no other benefit.

    So... unless Milo ALSO figured out what the SA
    chambers were for, he ALSO figured out how to make
    them work. And surely... finding Stewart's body
    inside one with broken glass... would not have in-
    stilled much confidence in any of them- towrd using
    them. I know that I sure as heck wouldn't :-/

    So, okay, they made the entire long trip... in
    those spacesuits. The entire trip?!?! Oh my
    goodness, they must have been gamey by the time
    they reached Earth! Gee... and nothing tells that
    the ship even had toilets!!! But... we can ignore
    that. Anyway, IF the ship could hold air, why the
    need for the suits then? If the ship could not hold
    air, and they were stuck in those suits, how did they
    eat and drink all that time, locked in those suits,
    the cabin 'filled' with vacuum, at it were? Big...
    big questions, really, and again, if looked at from
    a realistic persepctive. Then there's the logistics
    of taking aboard enough food and water. Okay- forget
    the water- it 'can' be recycled. Kool. But to take
    enough food, in its raw and bulky form, must have
    very nearly filled the ship to the rafters. And how
    did any of them know how much to take? Taylor never
    told any of them, how long the trip took, and how
    much bulky food they'd need. My... goodness. And
    even if they found 'manuals' aboard, do you imagine
    that they would tell how much raw bulky food would be
    needed, if such was required for a return trip, which
    was supposed to be one-way in the first place? I would
    say... not. No way. I also can't even imagine how they
    kept all that food fresh, for so long. the smell of
    the rotting food... would have been awful, and even...
    fatal, because of some of the gasses rotting food puts
    out. it would have smeeld worse than a garbage dump in
    that small tight space. ICK!!!

    And I very seriously doubt that high-tech compact
    foods were aboard in any real quantity, since such
    isn't needed... if the astronauts were to be asleep
    for the entire trip. A few snacks, maybe, but likely
    little else. Think about it.

    Those Apes, Zira, Cornelius, and Milo, should
    have looked like hell by the time then got back to
    1973 Earth. They would have been in worse con-
    dition than Altantic-crossing travelors from the
    time of Columbus or the Pilgrims. They would have
    been in terrible shape, I believe. They likely
    would have all died, before arriving back in 1973.

    And oh yes... these are delightful nit-picks, AND...
    I have never seen anyone, anywhwere, point them out be-
    fore, so... these are entirely NEW! :-D

    > Or, if it was a multistage landing craft, like
    > the Apollo-era Lunar Module, it may have been
    > something as simple as when the ship finally
    > hit the bottom of the lake, the shock jolted
    > free the ascent stage which floated to the sur-
    > face of its own accord. And we don't know how
    > many stages there were: there could have been
    > three or more: a stardrive section, which could
    > have broken off when the ship hit the lake's bot-
    > tom; an ascent-engine, which could have got them
    > into space in 3955 and been jettisoned by the com-
    > puter upon commencement of re-entry in 1973; and
    > the capsule that we saw already down in the water
    > in 1973. We just don't know.

    Indeed- we don't know. Quite true. But... since
    we are making suppositions all over the place, let's
    suppose that this is the case, while we throrize;
    Let's say, and prehaps agree, since you brought it
    up, that the ship we see is indeed at least the des-
    cent or ascent stage. We can say it's capable of
    launching, landing, and perhaps several times with one
    good load of fuel, all by itself, then presume further
    that the stardrive stage... was in orbit! Ever see a
    movie called 'Journey to the Far Side of the Sun'?
    That stage, left in orbit, was used to go from Earth,
    to the Doppleganger Earth on the far side of the sun.
    It was used to traverse the immense space in between,
    while the descent craft, also an ascent craft, moved
    up to it, or down away from it, when necessary. The
    POTA ship could have worked the very same way, as its
    amazing automation docked and undocked with it, no
    matter where it was, when the ascent-descent stage
    arrived back in orbit. If still in orbit, the tra-
    versing stardrive stage would be found, and redocked
    with, and used again. Thusly the stardrive stage
    never made landfall :-) And it could remain in
    orbit for years, decades... or even centuries. The
    concept otherwise is very workable, especially in
    a science fiction workable sense :-) Put an engine
    on the International Space Station, for trips back
    and forth to Mars, and you'd have the same thing :-)

    > And, yes, if the ape-o-nauts hadn't been blown
    > back in time, they might have died rather quick-
    > ly after the ship launched, because of all the
    > things Milo doubtless didn't understand or over-
    > looked, but the "fact" is that they WERE blown
    > backwards in time.

    Yes-yes-yes... they were. Accepted, and canon.
    But the point of a nit-picker's discussion is to
    approach the subject from a RL perspective. All
    of the books known as 'The Nit-picker's Guide to
    Star Trek'... made that writer comparitively RICH!
    And we do what we do, for free :-D Sad... when
    you think about it :-( So, there's no need to
    point out that things 'did' happen as they did.
    We both know that. The fun is defining why such
    things 'shouldn't' or 'couldn't' have happened,
    That IS where the pleasure is :-)

    > And, forgive me, but, again, it's funny to me
    > that you balk at the salvaging of the ship, but
    > say nothing about the far-less-likely reverse
    > time travel. One either buys the looseness of
    > the science in the films as a whole, or one
    > doesn't, but to get so hung up on one point
    > seems odd to me, but, hey, to each his own ... :)

    Again, that's the fun of nit-picking. Yes,
    canon is canon. In the film(s) what happened-
    happened. Granted. But the point of nit-picking
    is to serve other writers... in pointing out why
    some story elements fail so badly, resulting
    in nit-pick sessions like this one. It defines
    how things need to be thought out with reasonable
    clarity, so that the story reader and movie watcher
    isn't naturally forced to make natural double-takes
    and question the validity of the logic that should
    be in place. Again, 'good' science fiction takes
    this into account, the completeness of the apparent
    or applied pseudo-science that is being employed in
    the story. This principle has been pointed out by
    MANY writers before I ever said a word on the subject.
    Issac Asimov was just one among many. He too was a
    nit-picker. But more about him- below- later :-)

    As far as POTA in particualar was concerned, it
    was a great story and meant for a good telling,
    and the spacecraft was just a plot device utilized to
    get the main characters to where they were supposed
    to be. BUT... that ship, that simple and very useful
    tool as a plot device, serving the same purpose trans-
    porters do in Start Trek, has been analyzed to death
    LONG before I myself ever mentioned it, with an entire
    website noted as being devoted to that one spacecraft
    alone! Amazing, really. I've found less material,
    about the Jupiter 2, at least as well known.

    About Isacc Asimov- early in his writing career
    he wrote a series of novels, about a space-faring
    Earth group, and in one novel, in the storyline
    they encountered an alien spacecraft that had a
    'ray weapon'. Now... this story was written BE-
    FORE the laser was invented, and in the plot dialog
    Asimov expressed, via the characters, that such a
    ray weapon was impossible- because it had to be
    hotter at the source- than at the target, if fired.
    TRUE... given what was known by science at the time.
    Then some time later, the ruby laser was invented,
    proving that in fact the weapon did NOT have to be
    hotter at the source, than at the target. In fact
    it runs... cool to the touch, the flash being momen-
    tary, but with the target receiving many hundreds of
    degress of photon energy. Asimov highly prided him-
    self on writing science fiction, with real science at
    work in his fictions. He was a genius in that respect,
    and truly respectful of physics, chemistry, engineering
    and so on. He applied what was truly scientific fact-
    'at the time'. In this case, he was both embarassed and
    pleased- to be proven wrong, as were the scientists whom
    were also quite wrong. Fantastic :-)

    > Anyway, yes, a launch is complex -- but so is re-
    > entry; indeed, the re-entry that Taylor's ship
    > did in POTA is arguably a much more complex oper-
    > ation than the launch that Milo presumably engi-
    > neered: all Milo had to do was get the ship to go
    > more-or-less up (he never needed to worry about
    > achieving orbit or executing a flight plan), where-
    > as in POTA the ship had to get the angles and speeds
    > exactly right to avoid burning up on re-entry -- AND
    > ALL OF THAT HAPPENED WITH NO ONE PUSHING EVEN A SINGLE
    > BUTTON. The ship is demonstrably highly automated.

    Yes... but not smart enough to find... 'land'.
    Strange. *Snicker* :-) Automation, even in this
    case, has its obvious very serious drawbacks.

    Anyway, granted, since canon tells that's what
    Milo 'must' have done :-] *Wince*

    > But if you want to argue that Milo had to push more
    > than one button, fine: we see in BENEATH that the
    > Apes not only speak our language, but they also
    > read and write it (recall the signs written in Eng-
    > lish used by the anti-war protesters). So, all Milo
    > had to do was read the (plasticized hardcopy) manual,
    > or follow on-screen prompts. And we saw the instru-
    > mentation in Taylor's ship: It's very simple, much
    > simpler than the flight deck of a Space Shuttle (or
    > even a Gemini capsule), again, arguing for a very
    > high degree of automation.

    Again, granted. I still believe it would have
    been better if in fact the ship landed on land,
    safely and fully intact. That would have made ALL
    of this much more believable. Launch... could even
    have been a fortunate accident, rather than purpose-
    ful, as Milo fiddled with controls while the three
    were aboard, and... away they went- ZOOM! :-D But
    then again... there's that pesky Suspended Animation
    and bulky food problem. I can't even imagine why they
    would take so much aboard, being no logical reason.
    The only saving grace in that case, is the possibility
    that going BACK in time, occurs much faster than being
    forced forward. It may occur even in a few seconds
    once orbit was reached. Climbing the 'mountain of
    time' is a lot harder... than rolling back down the
    mountain of time. Going down hill, coming back, just
    happens to be easier. Bouncing back, comes with
    greater ease. FOOD PROBLEM SOLVED... and no SA re-
    quired ;-D And a virtually medieval Milo isn't ex-
    pected to really figure out much at all. He becomes
    a fortunate bumbler, like many other scientists :-)

    > As for the psionics stuff, I agree it's far out,
    > but psionics ARE canonically part of the POTA
    > cycle; the mutants in BENEATH absolutely have
    > them (and Caesar does sound like he's arguing
    > for a form of them at the end of CONQUEST with
    > the Emperor Moth analogy). If you are arguing
    > that ONLY humans might be capable of them in a
    > universe in which they categorically do exist,
    > well, that's a bit specist, and I doubt Virgil
    > would approve. :)

    Erf... the Apes have already developed and been
    given the gifts of sentience and reason! Would
    you give them Psi powers too! Ugh. Next... comes
    Flying Monkeys, I suppose :-( Lions and Tigers
    and Bears... oh my...

    ... but... speaking through time does not
    require psionics at all. The Lawgiver does so
    just fine, whith his written words, the Scrolls,
    and others similarly could have had their writings
    passed down through time- a method going back before
    Sanskrit. With that method, speaking across time
    is child's play, and positively anyone can do it.
    No psionics required :-)

    > Also, if there is in fact no psychic connection
    > between Caesar of the early 21st century in the
    > main story of BATTLE, and the Caesar statue of
    > the 27th century in the epilogue to BATTLE, how
    > do you explain the statue crying at the end of
    > BATTLE? :) (No, I'm not pushing the psychic
    > angle; it's just a fun one to consider in a fic-
    > tional universe that demonstrably -- the mutants
    > in BENEATH -- has already allowed for psychic
    > powers.)

    I understand. But I'd prefer leaving the gift
    or ability of psionics- to the Mutants. It's their
    condition of forced mutation due to radiation that
    provided that 'power', and their societal conditions
    and isolation that drove them to develop it to an
    ability and art.

    > The bottom line for me is that it IS canonical
    > to the Apes series that Milo DID manage to get
    > Taylor's ship to fly, at least briefly. For me,
    > saying "it couldn't have happened" over and over
    > again is far less interesting (or fun!) than try-
    > ing to think of ways in which it might have. :)

    Well... I haven't so much said that it 'couldn't'
    have happened, but to define why it 'shouldn't have
    happened, all things considered from a realistic point
    of view, even if it 'is' science fiction.

    The real probem, if a problem it is, is that;

    1) POTA was never meant to be produced as a series
    as per sequels, but it did so well that sequels
    proved profitable, one after another.

    2) The spacecraft itself was NEVER meant to become
    one of the 'characters' of the film, like the Enter-
    prise, the Jupiter 2, or the Proteus from Fantastic
    Voyage (an Isaac Asimov tale).

    3) Considering point 1 & 2, the spacecraft and how
    it all worked, was never developed beyond the shape
    of the descent craft, as a tool- a plot device- to
    get the astronauts where they needed to be. There
    was no need for that, and it would have been, quite
    simply, a very unnecessary studio expense, and it
    ALWAYS boils down to money! No question. Never
    forget that as far as cinematography is concerned.
    Money is always the real concern, from day one.
    Staying in budget is always the first consideration.
    It may be entertainment but it is first- a business.

    No, that silly spaceship and the circumstances of
    its use... doesn't 'need' to be scrutinized so closely,
    but... there's no fun in not doing that. It just re-
    fuses... to be ignored, and... we so much love her,
    don't we? Yeah- sure we do :-D

    > As for the rules for writing science fiction,
    > I'll try to keep 'em in mind ... ;)

    They... aren't so much rules, as suggestions
    offered by many other writers, and why such shows
    as Star Trek: The Next generation... actually has
    scientists- physicists, on their writer and crea-
    tive staff. Most script-writers of the show could
    not come up with all of that pseudo techno-babble,
    as those science advisors had to come up with all
    of that baffling crap. AND... the reason that most
    of it 'works' as fiction, is because the majority
    of it is all made up! 95% of the techno-babble is
    itself truly fiction. And... it fits very nicely
    in ST's timeframe and sci-fi universe, and virtual-
    ly everyone accepts it- just as is :-D Amazing.

    > All best wishes.

    Same to you, good buddy :-)

    > ROBERT J. SAWYER

    ~ Jon Rich
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39966 From: theskulpter Date: 12/26/2006
    Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
    .html
    Thanks so much Jonathan, Glad you like it. I have been missing all the
    Ape figures being released, and items etc,so I figured it was about
    time to make my own figures. I just finished a new General Ursus last
    night when I got home after celebrating Christmas with the family, Iam
    real happy with the way it came out, I will post photos next week
    sometime. I have to make a Helmet for the both of them this week.
    Alrighty Ape, Happy New Year, The Farrow.--- In
    pota@yahoogroups.com, "Jonathan" <phil_harmonik2005@...> wrote:
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "theskulpter" <theskulpter@> wrote:
    > >
    > > HI Ape gang. I just finished a new head sculpt of
    > > General Urko last week,figured I would share some
    > > pics, so I added some new photos of it in the pho-
    > > to section, I will add more when I finish the hel-
    > > met after the Holidays. Ok Hope all have a great
    > > Holiday, The Farrow.
    >
    > WOW! THAT'S AMAZING WORK! Bloody fantastic!
    > Love it. Perfectly marvelous :-) Kudos, Fallow :-D
    >
    > A big ape-like pat on the back there :-)
    >
    > ~ Jon Rich
    >
    <.html
    Group: pota Message: 39967 From: theskulpter Date: 12/26/2006
    Subject: Re: New General Urko 12" custom pics added,+ Merry Christmas APES!
    .html
    Hi Glen, thanks for the compliment. Yes I have alot of orders from
    people, mostly rock groups like KISS, AEROSMITH, THE STONES,ETC. But I
    just did these Apes for myself,I love Palnet of the apes, I was not
    thinking of selling any when I did the sculpt. they are alot of work,
    and they would be pretty expensive . But you can email me at
    theskulpter@... if you are interested in working a deal out.I
    just finished a highly detailed General Ursus last night, so hopefully
    I can post pics next week sometime. Ok thanks again, The Farrow.
    --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "Glen" <HotScheetz@...> wrote:
    >
    > Excellent work!...Do you ever do figures for others to purchase?...
    >
    > G
    >
    > --- In pota@yahoogroups.com, "theskulpter" <theskulpter@> wrote:
    > >
    > > HI Ape gang. I just finished a new head sculpt of General Urko last
    > > week,figured I would share some pics, so I added some new photos of
    > it
    > > in the photo section, I will add more when I finish the helmet
    after
    > > the Holidays. Ok Hope all have a great Holiday, The Farrow.
    > >
    >
    <.html


    Copyright © 2026, Hunter Goatley. All rights reserved.
    Last updated 2026-03-31 10:43.